Defining the Indefinable, Defending the Indefensible

In reference to this essay here (http://www.scifiwright.com/2011/01/gnosticism-in-action/), a reader asks:

“This may be an odd point to ask this, but how are you defining ‘leftist’? For example, are you describing a garden variety member of the Democratic party or something else?”

This is not odd at all. A call for a definition is always in order, since most disagreement is based on improperly defined terms.

Alas, I am not defining the word Leftist. I cannot. They have spent so much of their time and effort to avoid, elude, evade, and weasel out of defining themselves, that no mere mortal has any ability to find a label that can fit on them.

I do not think the movement, for which I have no satisfactory name, can be defined.

Read the rest of this entry »

Originally published at John C. Wright's Journal. Please leave any comments there.