date newest »
						  
						newest »
				
		 newest »
						  
						newest »
				
        message 1:
      by
      
          pop
      
        
          (new)
        
    
    
      Jan 14, 2010 04:07AM
    
     Hmmm, your article requires some thought and consideration. Not saying I agree or disagree, yet.
      Hmmm, your article requires some thought and consideration. Not saying I agree or disagree, yet. 
    
          reply
          |
      
      flag
    
   Sometimes though the analysis of professional identity can be a very stilting thing. Most writers already do struggle with "do I have the chops to be a pro writer?" The "I'm no good my stories keep getting rejected!" type of thing. But some of the great authors were rejected hundreds of times and died penniless. But their focus was on what they were exploring in their work. It was about the exploration and the content and the story. Not about credentials or worth by measurement. I agree, it's good to self evaluate goals and skill sets and work to expand ones capabilities. But to focus a lot of time on "is this what I should be doing" is not a good thing. That time should be spent on "what do I want to explore and how do I want to communicate it?"
      Sometimes though the analysis of professional identity can be a very stilting thing. Most writers already do struggle with "do I have the chops to be a pro writer?" The "I'm no good my stories keep getting rejected!" type of thing. But some of the great authors were rejected hundreds of times and died penniless. But their focus was on what they were exploring in their work. It was about the exploration and the content and the story. Not about credentials or worth by measurement. I agree, it's good to self evaluate goals and skill sets and work to expand ones capabilities. But to focus a lot of time on "is this what I should be doing" is not a good thing. That time should be spent on "what do I want to explore and how do I want to communicate it?"
     I agree that it's worthwhile to evaluate and question one's motivations. However, I think if you look to ego clues that you're a 'writer' (such as awards, money, status publications), then you're missing part of the point of being a writer. Writers write because they have to, want to, need to -- even if they don't get paid for it! Be careful not to use those criteria as the only measure of success.
      I agree that it's worthwhile to evaluate and question one's motivations. However, I think if you look to ego clues that you're a 'writer' (such as awards, money, status publications), then you're missing part of the point of being a writer. Writers write because they have to, want to, need to -- even if they don't get paid for it! Be careful not to use those criteria as the only measure of success. 
     I agree with Ashley. I write because I have a story to tell, not because I expect to make a fortune on it. I think the question writers should be asking themselves is whether they would still write if there were no such things as computers! Would you still write if all you had was a typewriter or, better yet, just a piece of paper and a pen?
      I agree with Ashley. I write because I have a story to tell, not because I expect to make a fortune on it. I think the question writers should be asking themselves is whether they would still write if there were no such things as computers! Would you still write if all you had was a typewriter or, better yet, just a piece of paper and a pen? 
     Personally, I would not write without a computer. No way, since what I write often runs more than a hundred thousand words, nope, unt uh, ain't gonna try that mess. Now, I know writers that still write with paper and pen, at least in the early stages, but they have people to type it out for them later. Patterson writes on legal pads with pens, dozens of books. My handwriting sucks too bad.
      Personally, I would not write without a computer. No way, since what I write often runs more than a hundred thousand words, nope, unt uh, ain't gonna try that mess. Now, I know writers that still write with paper and pen, at least in the early stages, but they have people to type it out for them later. Patterson writes on legal pads with pens, dozens of books. My handwriting sucks too bad. 
    ![Maria [the clockwork creeps on useless lives]](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1322709957p1/2412416.jpg) I write with a paper and pen. sometime's it's a waste, because my handwriting is so dreadful, but my computer crashes all the time. And my stuff has never been published to anything meaningful. In fact, the only people who have read my writing are close friends and family. Goodreads people don't count, because they don't read a lot of my writing.
      I write with a paper and pen. sometime's it's a waste, because my handwriting is so dreadful, but my computer crashes all the time. And my stuff has never been published to anything meaningful. In fact, the only people who have read my writing are close friends and family. Goodreads people don't count, because they don't read a lot of my writing.
     Nadia, personally I like the before picture better. I hope you're not falling for the skinny is the way to be crap. Fasting is not a good, reasonable way to lose weight, not if you plan on keeping it off. It's actually harmful for your body. Any church that would suggest such a thing is not at all interested in your health. Never fast more than three days at one time. Seriously, I mean it. To do more than that can be seriously harmful to your body, from which you might not recover. It can cause so many problems, I won't list them here, it's a long list. First of all, forty day fasts are NOT biblical. I don't know which version you use, but you have to remember that all versions of the bible currently available have been messed with time and time again by kings, interpreters, high priests, and the list goes on. One easy way to tell if your "church" is even trying to be biblical is that services are held on the sabbath, Saturday, not Sunday. "Church" in it's true meaning refers to the believers, the people as a whole, not one particular place, building or even one congregation.
      Nadia, personally I like the before picture better. I hope you're not falling for the skinny is the way to be crap. Fasting is not a good, reasonable way to lose weight, not if you plan on keeping it off. It's actually harmful for your body. Any church that would suggest such a thing is not at all interested in your health. Never fast more than three days at one time. Seriously, I mean it. To do more than that can be seriously harmful to your body, from which you might not recover. It can cause so many problems, I won't list them here, it's a long list. First of all, forty day fasts are NOT biblical. I don't know which version you use, but you have to remember that all versions of the bible currently available have been messed with time and time again by kings, interpreters, high priests, and the list goes on. One easy way to tell if your "church" is even trying to be biblical is that services are held on the sabbath, Saturday, not Sunday. "Church" in it's true meaning refers to the believers, the people as a whole, not one particular place, building or even one congregation. 
     I'm with Deborah. I don't consider myself a writer or an author - I consider myself a storyteller. Rather, I have stories in me that I want to explore, and it's only by recording them that I can bring them to some sort of conclusion.
      I'm with Deborah. I don't consider myself a writer or an author - I consider myself a storyteller. Rather, I have stories in me that I want to explore, and it's only by recording them that I can bring them to some sort of conclusion.Interestingly, I'm now in my sixties and until a little over three years ago I'd no interest in writing at all, not anything. Then I wrote a novel more or less out of out of curiosity. I've now published six.
I call myself an author, as I wish to sell my work, but this is simply so I can write full-time and dispense with having to work for a living (not there yet, sadly, but I still don't think of myself as a writer.
 Nadia, thanks for the article. This is something I would like to tell these "writers" I meet but they don't want to hear it. Mostly, I ask them, do you write everyday? Is your butt in a seat and your hands are moving rapidly for hours? For years? Then I would say you're a writer, endeavoring to improve, and being swept away in the world that is your only choice in life. Flannery O'connor said, "I write to discover what I know." I say, I write because if I didn't I would fall into the abyss where there surely are monsters! :)
      Nadia, thanks for the article. This is something I would like to tell these "writers" I meet but they don't want to hear it. Mostly, I ask them, do you write everyday? Is your butt in a seat and your hands are moving rapidly for hours? For years? Then I would say you're a writer, endeavoring to improve, and being swept away in the world that is your only choice in life. Flannery O'connor said, "I write to discover what I know." I say, I write because if I didn't I would fall into the abyss where there surely are monsters! :)
     uh huh, if that's a writer, I qualify. I write every day, most days for hours, if I'm not writing I'm rewriting and editing.
      uh huh, if that's a writer, I qualify. I write every day, most days for hours, if I'm not writing I'm rewriting and editing. 
     I just wrote a post on my blog about it, too. www.elisabethkinsey.com and the blog link is right under my pic. As a writer, you might enjoy it.
      I just wrote a post on my blog about it, too. www.elisabethkinsey.com and the blog link is right under my pic. As a writer, you might enjoy it.:)
 Just a little research into the lives of some of the greatest painters, writers, musicians, artists... might make anyone who is not truly vested in the craft turn away. But for those truly vested it might go a little something like this...
      Just a little research into the lives of some of the greatest painters, writers, musicians, artists... might make anyone who is not truly vested in the craft turn away. But for those truly vested it might go a little something like this...We might
pick up a bottle from time to time...
roll over from beneath a cardboard box or two...
stray away from what makes sense to those looking in...
and still nothing will sway us from the dizzy passion that compels us to write!
 It sometimes happens that someone is, for whatever reason, drawn away from that thing they are meant to do. My husband is an artist. It's wired into every fiber of his being. Yet, for nearly twenty years, he did no actual art. During that time he struggled with depression, but did try to make a living by conventional means. It didn't work at all. When the time came, he again took up his brushes and magic happened.
      It sometimes happens that someone is, for whatever reason, drawn away from that thing they are meant to do. My husband is an artist. It's wired into every fiber of his being. Yet, for nearly twenty years, he did no actual art. During that time he struggled with depression, but did try to make a living by conventional means. It didn't work at all. When the time came, he again took up his brushes and magic happened.
     Yes, Julie. You're right. Writing is like that, too. The best thing for a writer-or anyone for that matter-to do is to stop trying to define themselves.
      Yes, Julie. You're right. Writing is like that, too. The best thing for a writer-or anyone for that matter-to do is to stop trying to define themselves.
     Jeff wrote: "Sometimes though the analysis of professional identity can be a very stilting thing. Most writers already do struggle with "do I have the chops to be a pro writer?" The "I'm no good my stories keep..."
      Jeff wrote: "Sometimes though the analysis of professional identity can be a very stilting thing. Most writers already do struggle with "do I have the chops to be a pro writer?" The "I'm no good my stories keep..."I agree with you, Jeff. I believe people can get hung up in anything. Some people want to be singers or movie stars or actors, and yes, there are all kinds of accolades and titles which we would all love to claim, but I feel a writer is just that. The motivation is to speak either from the heart or the images of the mind, to tell a story. It is something which one is compelled to do. It is gift that demands to heard, whether accepted or rejected.






