Netflix Fans Erupt in Anger Over Show Cancellations

Netflix fans are furious about the streamer's years of cancelled shows, and they're unloading about it on a social media thread.

Fans expressed anger over the cancellations of a variety of shows on a Reddit thread that was first posted on May 8, 2025, and titled, "I will never forgive you for this 💔" People then listed the shows they are most upset that Netflix has cancelled over the years.

Netflix has cancelled multiple shows in 2025 alone, but the Reddit thread wasn't limited to this year. Rather, it turns out that fans have long memories when it comes to their favorite shows being killed, especially if storylines are left hanging.

The original poster on Reddit included a collage with photos from Netflix's cancelled shows, including 1899, Gypsy, I Am Not Okay With This, and First Kill.

How does Netflix decide which shows to keep and which to cancel?

Netflix co-CEO Ted Sarandos told Vulture, "It’s 70 percent gut and 30 percent data.”

According to Wired, Netflix has to take a show's cost into consideration.

In January 2023, Wired reported that 1899 wasn't continuing "despite debuting at the end of 2022 to positive reviews and a place on the streamer’s top 10 list."

"When mysterious events change the course of an immigrant ship headed for New York in 1899, a mind-bending riddle unfolds for its bewildered passengers," the Netflix blurb for the show says.

Fans offered up a variety of other shows that they're still angry at Netflix for cancelling.

"Mindhunter!!" one Reddit user declared. "We lost Mindhunter but got a billion reality shows no one asked for," another wrote.

Cast and crew attends the screening of the Netflix film "1899" at Funkhaus Berlin on November 10, 2022 in Berlin, Germany.

Ben Kriemann/Getty Images

Several others agreed that 1899 didn't deserve the axe. "1899 had so much potential," a fan of the show opined.

"1899 was the only one of these I watched, and I was gutted when I finished it to find out there would be no more. It was a slow burner, so definitely not for everyone, but it was so unique and I really wanted to see where it would go," another person agreed.

A fan explained, "I wish when shows like this get cancelled, the show runners would just come out and tell us what the end game, twist, secret, mystery was. Especially if after a time it’s clear no one else is picking it up, just give us a summary, the cliff notes, whatever."

Other Netflix shows receiving mentions on the thread included Spinning Out, The Society, Black Summer, Dead Boy Detectives, Lockwood & Co., Santa Clarita Diet, 1670, Nobody's Watching, Teenage Bounty Hunter, Archive 81, Inside Job, Marco Polo, Kaos, and OA.

Related: Beloved TV Shows Cancelled in 2025, From Netflix to NBC