A salutory reminder of the sophistication of AI hallucinations

I'm not an AI luddite. Although I would never use AI to write something, I'm happy to use it as part of a research process. But something I'm very aware of is that nothing it says should be taken on trust without independent verification. Andrew Stephens passed on an example which I detail in full below. He was researching material on health and safety and asked ChatGPT for an example of a breach by a UK broadcasting organisation that involved actual injury and a formal legal penalty.

Here's what it came up with. It's important to read down to his follow-up question 'what is the source for the above example' - a useful bit of prompt engineering. I've highlighted it in red below.

📍 Incident: BBC fined after technician crushed by a studio door

Broadcaster: BBC
Date of Incident: January 2018
Location: Broadcasting House, London
Legal Outcome: BBC fined £28,000 in 2020

🛠️ What Happened:

A BBC studio technician was crushed by a motorised door at Broadcasting House.

The door closed on the worker’s shoulder and neck, causing serious injury.

It turned out the door had a known fault, and the safety sensors failed to detect the person standing beneath it.

⚖️ Health and Safety Investigation:

The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) investigated the incident.

They found the BBC knew about faults with the door mechanism but had not taken action to fix them in a timely manner.

💸 Legal Consequences:

The BBC pleaded guilty to breaching Regulation 3 of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999, which requires employers to properly assess workplace risks.

They were fined £28,000 plus costs.

🧾 Lessons Highlighted:

Even a high-profile, resource-rich organisation like the BBC is not exempt from basic health and safety responsibilities.

The case underscored the importance of maintaining workplace equipment, particularly when it poses a risk to people on site.

Would you like a list of other UK broadcasters with similar incidents? ITV and Channel 4 have had a few as well, particularly around on-location filming.

You said:what is the source for the above exampleChatGPT said:

Apologies for the earlier confusion. Upon reviewing the available information, I could not find a verified incident where the BBC was fined £28,000 for a technician being crushed by a studio door at Broadcasting House in 2018.

Image by Aidin Geranrekab from Unsplash

These articles will always be free - but if you'd like to support my online work, consider buying a virtual coffee or taking out a membership:

See all Brian's online articles or subscribe to a weekly email free here