Review a Research Paper: Constructive Critique in Five Steps

I���m helping organize the ICCQ conference this year for the fourth time, with thein-cooperation support of the IEEE Computer Society. Based on this short-termexperience, I can assert that reviewing research papers is a skill that even somereputable and experienced academicians either don���t possess or are too lazy toapply. We often encounter sketchy, subjective, and disputable reviews thatdon���t assist authors but only frustrate and discourage them. In this short blogpost, as an absolu...