Erin & Troy vs. The Midnight Society — AYAOTD Recap, The Tale of the Twisted Claw

RECAP

After Gary complains that the night’s almost over and the Midnight Society still hasn’t heard a complete story, David steps up to the plate.

On Mischief Night, friends Kevin and Dougie prank Miss Clove, the neighborhood “witch.” Like the silly boys that they are, they return to her house the next night to trick-or-treat. Instead of candy, Miss Clove gives them a twisted vulture claw and explains that the claw will grant them each three wishes. Dougie’s so shaken up by the experience tha...