To be a queen

Sorry to disappear again, but I’ve had to devote most of my waking hours to working on the copy-edited manuscript of The Land Beyond the Sea. This is never fun, for by this time, writers have become thoroughly sick of their own books, having had to dwell upon them at great length as they tried to make the manuscripts ready for submission, then going over their books again with their editors, and then with copy editors. The longer the book, the more tedious it becomes; I remember being so eager to escape Sunne that I’d was almost ready to root for Henry Tudor at Bosworth!

Today’s historical post is a few days late. On February 13, 1177, Eleanor and Henry’s daughter Joanna, age eleven, wed William de Hauteville and was crowned as Queen of Sicily. It seems as if she and William had a happy marriage, although I doubt that she was thrilled about his harem of Saracen slave-girls. Yes, medieval women were realists when it came to male fidelity, but I suspect Joanna would have seen a harem as a bit much. Certainly “my” Joanna thought so. Joanna has always been a favorite of mine, the daughter most like Eleanor, and I was delighted to give her so much time on center stage in Ransom.

And on February 13, 1542, silly little Catherine Howard became yet another victim of her husband’s monstrous ego. When Henry VIII discovered that she’d had a colorful past prior to their marriage, he was so outraged that he pushed a bill of attainder through Parliament making it treason for an “unchaste” woman to marry the king, then sent Catherine to the Tower, where she was beheaded on this date. It could be very dangerous to be a Tudor Queen, and I am not just thinking of Bluebeard’s wives. Jane Grey paid with her life for her family’s all-consuming ambition. So did Catherine Howard, although she had none of Jane’s intelligence or education, which makes her pathetic story all the sadder. Marriage to the aging, ailing, hot-tempered Henry was more than punishment enough for any sins of her feckless youth. Despite the legend, though, she did not say that she died the Queen of England but would rather have died the wife of Thomas Culpepper. Those about to be executed in Tudor England did not make defiant gallows speeches, wanting to spare their family from royal retribution. But Catherine really did ask for the block to be brought to her the night before her execution; she wanted to practice kneeling and putting her head upon it so she would be sure to do it correctly come the morning. How pitiful is that?
14 likes ·   •  7 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on February 16, 2019 10:53
Comments Showing 1-7 of 7 (7 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Therese (new)

Therese So Henry made it treasonous for an unchaste woman to marry the King?!?! What about his responsibilities in that equation? Last time I heard it takes two! I know very little about Catherine, but what choice did she have? Whether she did something or not, if Henry didn’t like her, he would make up something. She couldn’t win for trying.


message 2: by Sharon (new)

Sharon She was a minnow swimming with sharks, Therese.


message 3: by Therese (new)

Therese Good analogy.


message 4: by Dorothy (new)

Dorothy Well, Catherine was also sleeping around on the King with Thomas Culpepper, one of his attendents, so that might have helped her untimely exit?


message 5: by Sharon (new)

Sharon That is why I said she was a minnow swimming with sharks, Dorothy. She'd been poorly educated, poorly supervised while living with her grandmother, and she never struck me as being all that intelligent. Few teenagers would want to marry a man so much older, a man whose health was already starting to fail. She seems to have been easily influenced, too. If my memory serves, she had George Boleyn's widow whispering in her ear, too. All in all, an easy recipe for disaster.


message 6: by Anduine (new)

Anduine plus once the King's eyes were "upon" her what choice did she really have (back then you did not say "no" to a king), with her ambitious and ruthless family in the background, using her to gain more power as well. A minnow swimming with sharks, is indeed a very good analogy, in this case


message 7: by Iset (new)

Iset Actually, the latest biographies of Catherine note that we don't even know that she was sleeping with Culpeper, and that it is possible they were meeting because he was blackmailing her about Francis Dereham. Now I have not studied Catherine's life extensively in any way, but I was shocked to realise that the book makes a very good point - it isn't actually proven anywhere that Catherine and Culpeper were sleeping together; for decades it has just been assumed. I couldn't believe that I'd accepted it along with everyone else - it is such a cardinal sin as a historian to accept a massive assumption like that. It really made me rethink Catherine Howard and nowadays I have to acknowledge the possibility that something else was going on instead.


back to top

Sharon Kay Penman's Blog

Sharon Kay Penman
Sharon Kay Penman isn't a Goodreads Author (yet), but they do have a blog, so here are some recent posts imported from their feed.
Follow Sharon Kay Penman's blog with rss.