Sin-Eater Part I & II (Finder # 1), by Carla Speed McNeil
Finder is a fairly famous science fiction comic that was originally self-published, then moved to Dark Horse. I was reading it for while, then forgot to keep up, then decided I needed to re-read everything before reading the latest volume, didn’t get around to that, and then forgot about it, which is what inevitably happens with me and all long ongoing comic series no matter how much I like them. I am now re-reading in the hope of actually catching up with some of the new volumes.
The world is post-apocalyptic, with incredibly intricate cultural worldbuilding. If you enjoy that sort of thing, you will probably enjoy this comic. The first two volumes center around Jaeger, a Finder and Sin-Eater and wanderer and ex-soldier who comes from the desert to a domed city where he knows some people, including but not remotely limited to…
- the people who work in a bookshop, such as an elderly woman who does divination with rocks and an intelligent male lion-creature left there as a guard by one of the more humanoid lion-women.
- Brigham, a violent and unbalanced man from a clan with strictly defined male/female gender roles, who has just been released from prison and is about to go back to stalking his family.
- Emma, Brigham’s ex-wife, from a clan where everyone presents as female, who lives much of her life in a literal dreamworld, works as a landscape architect, and has an AI assistant who speaks in a phonetic French accent.
- Their three children, each with their own complex story. Gender roles and identity figure prominently in their lives, but how is too complicated and ambiguous to summarize.
The main plot in this volume is Jaeger’s attempts to protect Brigham’s ex-family from him, their attempts to move on from Brigham’s control, and the backstory of how and why the current situation came about. But the world and story have a very complex and largely unexplained background. For instance, as I was writing this I realized that I wasn’t sure whether Jaeger came to the city specifically to check up on the family because he knew Brigham was going to be released from prison, or whether that was coincidental, or whether he didn’t know but it wasn’t a coincidence but rather a way that his Finding abilities operate.
And that sums up my experience of the actual plot of this comic. I enjoyed it a lot, but I felt like at least half of it was going over my head. Far more than Sandman, which is ostensibly about dreams but is really much more about stories, reading this feels dreamlike. It’s fragmented, incredibly vivid, emotionally realistic in the weird way that emotions really are weird, and often inexplicable.
Possibly the most odd, quirky, and worldbuilding-intensive aspect of a very odd, quirky, and worldbuilding-intensive comic are the footnotes. There are pages and pages of them after the comic, explaining everything from the entire culture of the miniature dinosaur only ever seen in the background of one panel in one issue to Easter egg-type references to the motivation of major actions of main characters which are otherwise inexplicable.
The footnotes range from interesting throwaways to explanations of events essential to the plot. If you don’t read them, the stories are compelling but dreamlike, inexplicable; if you do read them, well, kind of the same but they at least make more sense. I’m honestly not sure whether placing crucial elements of the story in footnotes that not everyone will read is McNeil’s artistic intention, or if she’s just the sort of artist who knows her world and story so well that she tends to forget to actually write in big chunks of it. I suspect the latter, but maybe also the former.
I like the art a lot. McNeil obviously enjoys drawing Jaeger’s body hair, which is not something I normally find hot but I really do here. It’s an incredibly dense, lifelike world where even the random raving wolf-headed dude and the girl who trails him have their own very detailed backgrounds (only explained in footnotes, natch) and the art shows it.
This is a very cool series but you have to approach it on its own weird terms. Contains domestic violence, other violence, a teenage girl crushing on an adult man, and probably other warning-worthy elements I forgot about or missed.
Finder Volume 1[image error]
[image error] [image error]
comments
The world is post-apocalyptic, with incredibly intricate cultural worldbuilding. If you enjoy that sort of thing, you will probably enjoy this comic. The first two volumes center around Jaeger, a Finder and Sin-Eater and wanderer and ex-soldier who comes from the desert to a domed city where he knows some people, including but not remotely limited to…
- the people who work in a bookshop, such as an elderly woman who does divination with rocks and an intelligent male lion-creature left there as a guard by one of the more humanoid lion-women.
- Brigham, a violent and unbalanced man from a clan with strictly defined male/female gender roles, who has just been released from prison and is about to go back to stalking his family.
- Emma, Brigham’s ex-wife, from a clan where everyone presents as female, who lives much of her life in a literal dreamworld, works as a landscape architect, and has an AI assistant who speaks in a phonetic French accent.
- Their three children, each with their own complex story. Gender roles and identity figure prominently in their lives, but how is too complicated and ambiguous to summarize.
The main plot in this volume is Jaeger’s attempts to protect Brigham’s ex-family from him, their attempts to move on from Brigham’s control, and the backstory of how and why the current situation came about. But the world and story have a very complex and largely unexplained background. For instance, as I was writing this I realized that I wasn’t sure whether Jaeger came to the city specifically to check up on the family because he knew Brigham was going to be released from prison, or whether that was coincidental, or whether he didn’t know but it wasn’t a coincidence but rather a way that his Finding abilities operate.
And that sums up my experience of the actual plot of this comic. I enjoyed it a lot, but I felt like at least half of it was going over my head. Far more than Sandman, which is ostensibly about dreams but is really much more about stories, reading this feels dreamlike. It’s fragmented, incredibly vivid, emotionally realistic in the weird way that emotions really are weird, and often inexplicable.
Possibly the most odd, quirky, and worldbuilding-intensive aspect of a very odd, quirky, and worldbuilding-intensive comic are the footnotes. There are pages and pages of them after the comic, explaining everything from the entire culture of the miniature dinosaur only ever seen in the background of one panel in one issue to Easter egg-type references to the motivation of major actions of main characters which are otherwise inexplicable.
The footnotes range from interesting throwaways to explanations of events essential to the plot. If you don’t read them, the stories are compelling but dreamlike, inexplicable; if you do read them, well, kind of the same but they at least make more sense. I’m honestly not sure whether placing crucial elements of the story in footnotes that not everyone will read is McNeil’s artistic intention, or if she’s just the sort of artist who knows her world and story so well that she tends to forget to actually write in big chunks of it. I suspect the latter, but maybe also the former.
I like the art a lot. McNeil obviously enjoys drawing Jaeger’s body hair, which is not something I normally find hot but I really do here. It’s an incredibly dense, lifelike world where even the random raving wolf-headed dude and the girl who trails him have their own very detailed backgrounds (only explained in footnotes, natch) and the art shows it.
This is a very cool series but you have to approach it on its own weird terms. Contains domestic violence, other violence, a teenage girl crushing on an adult man, and probably other warning-worthy elements I forgot about or missed.
Finder Volume 1[image error]
[image error] [image error]
comments
No comments have been added yet.
