date
newest »

message 1:
by
Lavinia
(new)
Apr 24, 2018 06:06AM

reply
|
flag


Reading this play was making me so sad and frustrated. But I bet the actors and the team is great :) I just wish the story and the characters would make sense :(

Reading this play was making me so sad and frustrated. But I bet the actors and ..."
Sincerely it all made sense when you see the play ! I just saw the play in London few days ago and I realised I didn't understand 10% when reading... There are so much feelings that you forget the pitfalls of the story^^

Reading this play was making me so sad and frustrated. But I bet t..."
I'm sure that's the magic of theater and the great work of actors! because the plot is just so bad, and characters are not themselves at all!


Yes it is not the same as the Harry Potter series because the book( script) wasn't written that way. Even though goodreads named a script for a play as a book of the year. People continue and will continue to cash in on the Harry Potter.


Reading this play was making me so sad and frustrated. But I bet the actors and ..."
Hear, hear!!

Reading this play was making me so sad and frustrated. But I bet the actors and ..."
Agree 100%! This was never written by J.K. Rowling, I refuse to believe it.

Reading this play was making me so sad and frustrated. But I bet t..."
Agree 100%! This was never written by J.K. Rowling, I refuse to believe it.
That's because it wasn't. She only gave it her approval. Will never understand why, though.

Reading this play was making me so sad and frustrated...."
That's quite relieving to hear. But I too find it shocking that she approved to that.. I think the actors are great, the story is just shit tho.

Reading this play was making me so ..."
That's quite relieving to hear. But I too find it shocking that she approved to that.. I think the actors are great, the story is just shit tho.
Yeah, like Terra said, it's fanfiction with OOC moments. Then again, J.K. isn't the same person she was when she wrote the HP books. She's become quite corporate and opinionated. Can't say I'm too surprised she gave it her blessing. Guess the amount of money she's getting for it outweighs her wanting to stay true to the characters.

Reading this play was m..."
Yeah, I think you're right. Very sad, but I'll just keep pretending like cursed child had never existed.

Read..."
Jacqueline and Lea, you give me life :D
It's really nice to see that there are people out there seeing the issues with this book.

Read..."
Agreed! I was so excited when it came out and it started feeling wrong to me after just reading the first few pages, I simply don't understand how someone who passionately read all the Potter Books could be pleased with The Cursed Child, but well, each to his own I guess.^^

I know that our opinion is kind of the unpopular opinion, and that we're a minority, but yeah that play's got so many issues. It's like the people who wrote it just don't get it, and have never truly read nor analyzed the books thoroughly. And I guess most of the people who read it and liked it just don't really care too much about the details or the characterizations; they might just be in it for the magic and the nostalgia..

Exactly how I felt. But I'm actually really glad this wasn't written by J. K. Rowling, because if it was it would be hard to deny that it's a real part of the Harry Potter Universe. Like this, it's really not much more than some sort of fanfiction.


I'm not sure about that. I heard it is coming out on Broadway so maybe yes.

I'm not sure about that. I heard it is coming out on Broadway so maybe yes."
The play is in Broadway since April 2018^^

I'm not sure about that. I heard it is coming out on Broadway so maybe yes."
The play is in Broadway since April 2018^^"
Really? Wow, I haven't been keeping up with the date. Sadly, I can't go see it.