Michael E. Shea's Blog, page 10

Running Investigations and Mysteries

This article is one in a series where we look at particular adventure types ��� how to prepare them, how to run them, what pitfalls we might run into, and how we can overcome these pitfalls.

This series of articles includes:

Dungeon CrawlsInfiltrations and HeistsInvestigations and MysteriesMissionsTravelDefenseIntrigue

These articles describe one approach for these adventure types and your own style may differ. That's totally fine. There are many right ways to enjoy this game.

Robin Laws's book Adventure Crucible ��� Building Stronger Scenarios for any RPG inspired my thoughts on this topic.

Understanding Investigations and Mysteries

In investigation and mysteries, one or more previous events have occurred which have led to the current situation. The characters spend their time in the adventure learning what happened and potentially changing the course of future events based on what they find. During investigations, the characters talk to people, explore locations, uncover clues, and face those foes who seek to thwart them.

Mysteries are difficult to run because, unlike narrative fiction, we don't know where the characters are going to go, what they're going to investigate, or what clues they might pick up. They could identify the key villain in the first scene or pursue tangents away from the clues you expect them to follow. Both of these situations need to be accounted for in your prep and play.

Preparing Investigations and Mysteries

These steps can help you prepare to run an investigation or mystery:

Develop the starting situation. What happened? Who did what? What is the timeline of previous events?Develop your strong start. How and when do the characters get involved in the situation? What hooks them into the mystery?Develop a list of NPCs the characters can talk to. Who are they? What was their involvement in the situation? What do they want? What are their goals? Avoid introducing the main villain too early if you're trying to keep them a secret.Develop locations the characters can investigate. Where can they go? How can they uncover the clues they eventually need? What happened at these locations?Develop a list of secrets and clues. Keep them abstract from their place of discovery so you can drop in these clues when it makes sense based on the investigation undertaken by the characters. In investigations and mysteries, you may need more than ten.Write down monsters and treasure for the more traditional adventure elements.Running an Investigation or Mystery

The following list provides a structure around running investigations and mysteries:

Use your strong start and sink in the hook so the characters, and their players, want to dig in and figure out what's going on.Introduce NPCs helpful to the characters who can give them a push in the right direction.As the characters investigate, drop in clues that lead the characters to other locations, meeting other NPCs, and discovering more clues and so on.Throughout the adventure, expose clues until the players can piece together the whole scenario.Add henchmen or other hostiles to add some combat as desired.When the time is right, drop in your villain and have a big confrontation.Common Pitfalls for Investigations and Mysteries

Investigation and mysteries may sometimes include the following pitfalls. During prep and play, keep these pitfalls in mind so you can avoid them and run a fun evolving game.

There's only one way to find the right clues and the characters don't follow it.The characters discover the villain or source of the mystery too early.The characters never discover the villain or figure out the mystery.The GM leads the players on too much ��� making it clear the players didn't figure it out but had the results spoon-fed to them.The pacing gets tiresome. Players who want to crack some skulls end up bored.The mystery is too complex. Players can't figure out all the important details.Avoiding Pitfalls

Consider the following ways to avoid the pitfalls listed above.

Keep the clues needed to uncover the mystery abstract from their location of discovery. Drop in clues along the path the characters take during the investigation.Don't introduce the villain too early. Keep them a blank spot in the story until it's time for their revelation.Provide the right amount of information for the players to be able to piece together the puzzle themselves. Don't spell it out for them.Clarify that the characters are the ones discovering information and piecing it together ��� not you the GM.Have multiple ways to uncover the truth. Don't let discovery of the mystery hinge on a single element the characters might miss.Include combat and skirmishes to keep combat-focused players interested.Keep in mind that players only grasp about half of what you reveal. Keep mysteries simple enough that players can actually piece them together.Build Situations, Not Mystery Novels

A key to running a good investigation and mystery is not to assume you know how the players will discover the truth. Build and set up the situation during prep and let the characters follow their own path to their ultimate discovery.

More Sly Flourish Stuff

The Lazy DM's Companion is currently on sale for 50% off the PDF and 20% off the PDF and softcover version! If you don't have this book, now is a fantastic time to pick it up! The Lazy DM's Companion includes tools, tables, and tips for running awesome fantasy D20 games. Grab it today!

Last Week's Lazy RPG Newsletter

I had a cold last week and didn't record an episode of the Lazy RPG Talk Show (also available as a podcast). Instead, I wrote a text-version of the talk show in the Lazy RPG Newsletter for 3 March 2024 with news, tips, and Patreon questions and answers.

I did post a YouTube video on Using Paper Character Sheets.

RPG Tips

Each week I think about what I learned in my last RPG session and write them up as RPG tips. Here are this week's tips:

Name villains and sentient opponents. Make each one unique.Have players identify monsters with interesting physical characteristics.Add an interesting usable environmental object or effect into significant combat encounters.Tie clues, treasure, and MacGuffins to the backgrounds, knowledge, and history of the characters.Reveal the world through the eyes of the characters.Ask each character what they think about from their past and their current larger goals during short or long rests.Show the characters the results of their actions in the world.Related ArticlesManaging Mysteries and Plot TwistsRunning Dungeon CrawlsRe-Using Secrets and CluesGet More from Sly FlourishArticlesNewsletterBookstorePatreonPodcastYouTubeBuy Sly Flourish's Books Return of the Lazy Dungeon Master Lazy DM's Companion Lazy DM's Workbook Forge of Foes Fantastic Lairs Ruins of the Grendleroot Fantastic Adventures Fantastic Locations

Have a question or want to contact me? Check out Sly Flourish's Frequently Asked Questions.

Running Infiltration and Heist Adventures

This article is one in a series where we look at particular adventure types and identify how to prepare them, how to run them, what pitfalls we might run into, and how we can overcome these pitfalls.

This whole series of articles will include:

Dungeon CrawlsInfiltrations and HeistsInvestigationsMissionsTravelDefenseIntrigue

This article is only one way to run infiltration-style adventures and even the categorization may go against your own views. That's totally fine. There are many right ways to enjoy this game.

Robin Laws's book Adventure Crucible ��� Building Stronger Scenarios for any RPG heavily inspired my thoughts on this topic.

Understanding Infiltration Adventures

In infiltration adventures, the characters often have significant information about their goal, the location in which they must accomplish the goal, and knowledge of the inhabitants of the location. Heists are a common form of infiltration adventure but many infiltrations involve doing something other than stealing something.

Infiltration adventures differ from dungeon crawls because the characters often know more about the location they're infiltrating and spend more time planning their approach. Goals for infiltration adventures can vary, even if how we prepare and run them remains mostly the same. These goals include:

Stealing somethingKidnapping someoneRescuing someoneHunting down a bad guyPerforming a magic ritualDisrupting a magic ritualUncovering war plansRecovering blackmail evidenceUncovering evidence of a plotPlanting evidencePreparing Infiltration Adventures

Preparing infiltration adventures focuses on the following activities:

Clarifying the goal and ensuring it's something important enough that the characters are willing to risk their lives for it.Choosing a map. Unlike dungeon crawls, there's a good chance we'll give a copy of this map to the players.Filling in the location with details. I like printing out a Dyson map and writing a couple of words per room or area right on the page.Listing out inhabitants and understanding their behaviors. What are they doing when the characters aren't there? Unlike dungeon crawls, inhabitants of a location in an infiltration adventure are often more mobile.Listing potential complications. What unknown events might shake things up? Make a list of a handful to either choose from or roll on during the infiltration.Ensuring there are multiple paths to achieve the goal. Do they sneak in an upper window? Pretend to be servants? Delve in through the sewers below?

With that material in hand, we're ready to run our infiltration adventure.

Running Infiltration Adventures

Infiltration adventures often break down into the following phases:

Planning. Unlike other adventures, players spend a lot of time planning their infiltration.Choosing roles. What jobs are each of the characters taking on the infiltration? Is someone acting as the "face" character? Is someone the muscle? Is someone sneaking around and spying on things from a higher floor?Execution. This is where the real adventure begins. The characters start doing the things they planned.Flashbacks. A concept taken from Blades in the Dark gives players an opportunity to flash back earlier in the story to set something up or acquire something they need. Inspiration or luck may be a good mechanic to allow for adjustments or additions to the party's plan.Complications. Things never go according to plan. What changes? What complications do you throw in from your list of potential complications? Or do you roll it? Complications don't always have to go against the characters.The climax. What happens when the characters achieve their goal? What happens if they fail or partially succeed?The escape. How do the characters get out afterwards?Infiltration Adventure Pitfalls

Infiltration adventures might go wrong for the following reasons:

Players spend too long planning.The plans go out the window too early.The characters aggro the entire location, making the job impossible to complete.A single bad check affects too much of the outcome.Too many complications disrupt the whole plan.The changing situation makes it too hard to adjudicate.Pitfall Mitigation

What can we do to help ensure these pitfalls don't crud up our fun session?

Arbitrate conversations and get the players to a consensus so the game can move forward. Ensure the players you're not pushing them down one path or leading them to utter destruction.Keep a balance on consistency and chaos. Some things should go to plan, some things should go haywire. Don't disrupt or destroy the whole plan too early.Give leeway in choosing when adversaries become aware of the characters. It should take multiple failed attempts before the characters are discovered and it shouldn't chain out to every adversary in the whole location.A Framework for Countless Adventures

The infiltration style adventure is a popular and flexible model we can use for many different adventures. Change the goal, the location, and the situation and you have something fresh every time yet still have a consistent framework around which to build your adventure.

More Sly Flourish Stuff

Last week I posted a couple of YouTube videos on High Value Prep and The Marrow Fiend ��� Shadowdark Gloaming Session 23 Lazy GM Prep.

Last Week's Lazy RPG Talk Show Topics

Each week I record an episode of the Lazy RPG Talk Show (also available as a podcast) in which I talk about all things in tabletop RPGs. Here are last week's topics with time stamped links to the YouTube video:

Rascal.News for TTRPG NewsGinny Di on D&D with ADHDShadow of the Weird Wizard ReleasedThe Benefits of Character FactionsThe Many Right Answers of TTRPGsPatreon Questions and Answers

Also on the Talk Show, I answer questions from Sly Flourish Patrons. Here are last week's questions and answers:

WOTC and Table-Usable MapsSelling Magic Items -- Info and InventoriesTying Backgrounds to Curse of StrahdHow do I Feel about AI in TTRPGs?RPG Tips

Each week I think about what I learned in my last RPG session and write them up as RPG tips. Here are this week's tips:

Write your own map key on a printed map.For dungeons, focus on one or two word descriptions for each chamber. Save longer descriptions for complicated set-piece chambers.Build your own binder with your favorite reference pages in it.Stuck for an idea? Write down ten and pick the best one.Need inspiration? Take a walk and let your mind wander.Find a suite of tools for your prep that you love and you'll be drawn to use it.Put dialog-friendly NPCs in the deepest dungeons ��� talking statues, paintings, magic items, or ghosts. Everyone wants a friend!Related ArticlesRunning Dungeon CrawlsDungeon Crawls Versus SituationsPrepping a DungeonGet More from Sly FlourishArticlesNewsletterBookstorePatreonPodcastYouTubeBuy Sly Flourish's Books Return of the Lazy Dungeon Master Lazy DM's Companion Lazy DM's Workbook Forge of Foes Fantastic Lairs Ruins of the Grendleroot Fantastic Adventures Fantastic Locations

Have a question or want to contact me? Check out Sly Flourish's Frequently Asked Questions.

Lazy RPG Newsletter ��� 3 March 2024

A nasty cold knocked me on my ass so instead of a YouTube and Podcast recording of the Lazy RPG Talk Show, I'm going to deliver the same info to you in beloved HTML!

New Maps Features on D&D Beyond

Wizards of the Coast released a video of new D&D Beyond Maps features. They've updated a lot since the last time I played around with it�������token naming and re-naming, a spectator view, a drawing tool, and a pointer. I spent some time on Twitch mucking around with the new features and I like it a lot. WOTC is definitely taking a lighter-weight Owlbear Rodeo approach which I appreciate. I'd love to see them let people upload custom tokens and add text-based notes to the map. It's far more functional now than it was a couple of months ago.

For those running WOTC adventures with WOTC character options, it's a great tool.

It's interesting that WOTC / Hasbro chose to hedge their bets by investing in both a lightweight 2d map-based VTT and a heavy-weight expensive 3d VTT. I'll bet the former is more popular than the latter.

Marilith Preview for the Tales of the Valiant Monster Vault

Kobold Press released a preview of the Tales of the Valiant Monster Vault Marilith and I think it looks awesome. It hits hard, has a simple stat block, and still has interesting crunchy features befitting this high-power demon. I'm eager to see the Tales of the Valiant Monster Vault. It's going to be wild to have four different core monster books by this time next year: the 2014 D&D Monster Manual, the 2024 D&D Monster Manual, the Tales of the Valiant Monster Vault, and the Level Up Advanced 5e Monstrous Menagerie. We have lots of core monsters to choose from and no limitation on which monsters we decide to use at our tables.

Bob World Builder on GM Regrets

Bob World Builder has an awesome YouTube Video on GM Regrets. I don't think it's useful to fixate on our regrets but we can learn a lot by listening to the regrets of others. I don't have many GM regrets. I'm happy with how things turned out in my TTRPG life. I do regret not playing OD&D in the early 80s with my oldest friend Scott �����a friend I've had for almost half a century. I talked to him yesterday about it and we both had a laugh. We both barely remember the time anyways.

Dread Laironomicon

Raging Swan released the Dread Laironomicon, a tome standing side-by-side with the Dread Thingonomicon to fill in the details of one hundred lairs from the Cultists' Hidden Fane to a Roper's Cave. Each lair includes seven lists of ten details to fill in such lairs. This book is an excellent source of inspiration for filling in the details of a location during prep �����making such places come alive. If you're a fan of the excellent works of Raging Swan Press, you will not be disappointed. My only complaint is a lack of higher-focus lists of chambers in such lairs but the major and minor features lists largely fill in that need. I received a review copy of the Dread Laironomicon for this spotlight.

Dune on Humble Bundle

Humble Bundle currently offers a 17 book digital package for Modiphius's Dune RPG for $18. Such bundles are a great way to dive into an RPG for a low cost. I don't intend to run it but after awaiting Dune part 2 and re-reading the original Dune books, it's great fun to delve into the artwork and read the lore behind the RPG. If you love Dune and want a taste of the RPG, this is a great deal.

Being Good Stewards of the Hobby

Based on an excellent conversation with Graham Ward on Mastering Dungeons, I was inspired to consider what we can do to be good stewards of the TTRPG hobby. I asked folks across several platforms and got many excellent responses which I'll put together into a longer article. For a quick preview, here are some things I think we can all do to be great stewards of the TTRPG hobby:

Embrace the diversity of our hobby, both in the games we play and the people playing them.Learn from everyone, whether they are new to the hobby or a grizzled veteran.Welcome new players. Teach them how to play and learn from their experiences.Focus on the fun we can have at the table with our friends.Support peoples' love for their chosen systems, even if those systems aren't for you.Avoid gatekeeping with jargon, how one came to the hobby, the games one chooses to play, or how long one has played games.Share our love of the hobby openly.Simple Online Combat Tracking with a Text Editor

I've been playing a mix of online and in-person games recently and return to the simple text editor as a great way to track combat when playing online. Using Notepad or whatever text editor you prefer you can track initiative, positioning in theater of the mind combat, damage done to creatures, and more.

Here's a quick example of the text I had for a battle I ran last night:

23 Chartreuse 12 Crimson Lotus 71 > Chartreuse 12 Blackguard Wight 10 > Voxi 12 Blackguard Wight 49 > Helm 7 Voxi 7 Zaffre In the Back 6 Helm 5 Radon 3 Eldrox

The above has the characters and creatures in initiative order. The left-hand numbers are their initiative roll. The right-hand numbers are the damage done to the creature. The angle brackets indicate that a monster is adjacent to a particular character. You can type status effects, multiple adjacent characters, or any other notes next to a creature's name to keep track.

Using text editors for combat tracking is fast, easy, cheap, and independent of RPG system or digital tools. I love it.

Page 12 of the Lazy DM's Companion has more tricks for tracking theater of the mind combat in a text editor that differs from the above but both can give you ideas how to easily track combat in a text editor.

Patreon Questions

Every month, Patrons of Sly Flourish can ask any question in a special monthly Q&A. I answer every RPG-related question each Friday morning. Here are some highlights for this week. Please note these questions have been edited for length.

Announcing a Villain's Plans and Progress

From Jason. I was curious how you balance multiple story arcs throughout a campaign. The villain in our campaign, who is progressing his own plans, is coming to a point where some of those plans will come to fruition. I'm struggling with "announcing" those plans when the PC's are in the middle of another story arc. I'm worried that may seem railroad-like if I throw a hook out there that they will feel inclined to investigate and move off of what they are currently on. My goal with the villain's plans was to keep him going in the background, and thus in the PC's consciousness, instead of having everything happen at the very end.

Sometimes we get stuck between revealing interesting information and such information ending up as an adventure hook. It's important to clarify to the players that not all information is actionable. Such information isn't something they can or should feel pressure to do something about right now.

Secrets and clues can help characters learn about the escalation of villainous quests without immediately changing their current direction to chase them down. If characters choose to chase down such a situation, and have the opportunity to do so, perhaps that's the way the story should go. Otherwise, make it clear to players when they receive information about an escalating villainous quest that they can't necessarily do anything about it right now. Tell, don't show.

Published Adventures Don't Require Less Work

From William J. What do you think of the amount of work published adventures expect the DM to do? I'm normally a homebrew campaign kind of guy, but recently picked up a Wotc published adventure (shattered obelisk). The idea being that I was paying a professional writer to do most of the "prep" for me so with very little notice, I could almost just pick the book up and play. However I have been left rather disappointed. Am I being unrealistic with my "pay to prep less" expectation?

It's a misconception that published adventures require less work. That's certainly not the case and, sometimes, they take more work than a homebrewed adventure because you have to internalize a published adventure in a way a homebrew adventure is already internalized. Almost always, they require different kind of work �����more of a focus on reading, absorption, and modification instead of thinking things up from scratch.

We shouldn't buy published adventures expecting them to be easier to run. Instead, we should buy them for the depth and quality of material we can't create ourselves. Stories, backgrounds, artwork, maps �����these are components of good adventures we simply can't create at the same quality of a published adventure.

I think it actually works better to build homebrew adventures in published settings for the best of both worlds. A published setting gives you a great depth of lore and quality of materials along with the flexibility of building the adventure you want in that world.

Letting Non-Magic Users Use Relics

From Robert. Any house rules for letting non magic users use magic items/relics? If one of my non spell casting PCs picks up a relic, I���d like them to have a solid chance of it actually working (at least the same chance a magic user would have) and the existing rules for say, scrolls, don���t really cut it.

I don't expect a single-use magical relic to be limited to magic users. Relics should be identifiable and usable by anyone who picks them up. That's what makes them fun. Let players know what a relic does and let any character use them.

Adding CR to Published Adventures

From Ryan. I find for me one of the minor speed bumps that prevent me from improvising a monster is if I���m adapting a published module. If it says ���4 skeletons���, I have to look up the skeleton stat block to see what the CR is to figure out what I���d replace it with or what the FoF baseline is that I���d swap in for an easier time stat line to run with just some flavour or a single monster power. I think for me the missing piece would be if an adventure said ���4 skeletons (CR 1/4)���. Thoughts? Maybe when I first read an adventure I should just mark up all the CRs.

That's a great idea and something I'll consider for future adventures of my own. You can use the "monster stats by CR table" in Forge of Foes to benchmark any monster in any adventure against the "example 5e monsters". The intention of that column is to help you identify a monster's CR by comparing it to those examples. Is it less or more powerful than an elemental? What about a frost giant? Understanding what sorts of monsters have which CRs is a great way to use that table to build monsters you need as you use them.

Introducing Cursed Magic Items Without Removing Player Agency

From Garry. One of the players has just picked up a magic item which while useful, is cursed. If he attunes to it, it will slowly turn him evil and lure him towards the BBEG and his cult of monstrous followers. While this is good, the original text explicitly explains that the previous user (high level cleric) went mad and killed all his followers with everyone turning to wraiths. That player tends to dominate the direction play by force of personality from time to time, but he is usually very fair minded. I'm reluctant to have the whole curse thing in case he runs wild with it to the detriment of the game. Should I just change the properties of the item? Any advice?

Yeah, change the properties. My absolute favorite "cursed" magic items are intelligent items that continually make offers to the characters in exchange for information or power. The best cursed items are those the players know are cursed and still use them anyway.

You're right to be concerned about taking agency away from the player. Don't do it. Instead, let them know the sword is cursed and have it steer them with continual offers, dancing that dangerous line. It's great fun. A smart magic weapon knows how to manipulate its user and the whole thing is much more fun when everyone is in on it. Of course, "pause for a minute" to make sure everyone's still having a good time.

Introducing Rivals Who Aren't Instantly Killed

From R. Scott W. I want to introduce a rival team into the mix since my PCs are so competitive. How do I keep the party from killing off the rivals so that they can have a long term impact on the game?

Let the characters, and the players, know about these rivals without having them get within sword-swinging distance. If you put the rivals and the characters in the same room together, swords and spells may fly. Instead, what if the characters hear about and see the results of these rivals without getting close to them. Maybe they meet them in a bar sometime if you think it isn't going to end up in bloodshed. Eventually things might come to blows but even more fun is when those rivals end up becoming allies instead.

Another Great Week for TTRPGs!

Thank you for digging into this week's tabletop RPG news! Sorry I couldn't do it on a video but hopefully this newsletter gave you the taste you desire. See you next week and keep on rolling those 20s!

Related ArticlesThe Case For Published Adventures2016 D&D 5th Edition Dungeon Master QuestionnaireRun Homebrew Adventures in a Published SettingGet More from Sly FlourishArticlesNewsletterBookstorePatreonPodcastYouTubeBuy Sly Flourish's Books Return of the Lazy Dungeon Master Lazy DM's Companion Lazy DM's Workbook Forge of Foes Fantastic Lairs Ruins of the Grendleroot Fantastic Adventures Fantastic Locations

Have a question or want to contact me? Check out Sly Flourish's Frequently Asked Questions.

Running Dungeon Crawls

This article is one in a series where we look at particular adventure types ��� how to prepare them, how to run them, what pitfalls we might run into, and how we might overcome these pitfalls.

The adventure types in this series include:

Dungeon crawlsInfiltrationInvestigationMissionsTravelDefenseIntrigue

This article focuses on one approach for running dungeon crawls and your own preferences may differ. That's totally fine. There are many right ways to prepare, run, and enjoy our games.

Robin Laws's book Adventure Crucible ��� Building Stronger Scenarios for any RPG heavily inspired this article.

Understanding Dungeon Crawls

In dungeon crawls, characters travel room-by-room through a relatively unknown maze-like location to accomplish one or more goals. Such dungeons can include crypts, caves, caverns, castle ruins, derelict ships, ruined towers, planar nodes, old temples, and other room-and-hall-based locations.

Preparing Dungeon Crawls

Consider the following steps when preparing a dungeon crawl:

Choose a map (I love dysonlogos maps.) Fill in location details ��� just a word or two per room. You can handwrite these notes right on a printed copy of the map.Write down potential traps and hazards.If using a published adventure, read over the rooms in the dungeon from the adventure.Write a clear goal to reinforce with your players. The goal should be important enough to offset the danger of going into the dungeon.Write out ten secrets and clues the characters might find in the dungeon. You don't have to set these clues in specific locations. Drop them in when it makes sense for the characters to learn them.List out potential monsters. Some monsters may be location specific but many might be wandering around.List out potential NPCs. They might reside in one room or wander around.List out treasure the characters might find. Feel free to place this treasure wherever it makes sense.Running Dungeon Crawls

At the beginning, perhaps as part of a strong start, make sure to state or reinforce the goal. Why are the characters going into the dungeon? Why is it worth risking their lives?

When the characters are in the dungeon, set up how the dungeon crawl works by asking the following questions:

Who's up front and who's in the back?What sort of lighting do the characters have?Who's keeping an eye out for monsters?Who's checking for traps, hazards, and secret doors? How are they checking?What paths do the characters want to take when they come to forks in the dungeon?

As the characters explore, dungeon inhabitants might move and react to the characters activities or the GM might roll for random encounters to shake things up.

Dungeon Crawl Pitfalls

The following common pitfalls can suck the fun out of a dungeon crawl. Be aware of them and account for them in your prep and play.

Too many downward beats.A boring or overly complicated dungeon design.Too many hard battles.No clear goal or reason to go into the dungeon.No place to rest after expending all the characters' resources.Few opportunities to roleplay.No real choice or useful information when picking a path.The monsters always surprise the characters.Offsetting Dungeon Crawl Pitfalls

Try the following ideas to offset potential pitfalls.

Fill out exploration of a dungeon with secrets and clues.Include upward beats like finding secret passages or getting the drop on unsuspecting foes.Include safe places for a short or long rest.Select maps with engaging dungeon designs including loopbacks, secret passages, multiple paths, and asymmetric designs.Ensure there's useful information to inform the characters' choices.Include non-hostile NPCs with whom the characters can roleplay.Mix easy and challenging battles that make sense for the situation, not just those tuned for the characters' level.The Most Common Adventure Type

Dungeon crawls are one of the most common adventure types, going back to the origins of D&D 50 years ago. With the tools above, we can use a common structure for preparation, gameplay, and avoiding pitfalls to run an awesome game for our friends.

More Sly Flourish Stuff

Last week I posted a couple of YouTube videos on Awarding Treasure in 5e and Roots of the Marrow Tree ��� Shadowdark Gloaming Session 22 Lazy GM Prep.

Last Week's Lazy RPG Talk Show Topics

Each week I record an episode of the Lazy RPG Talk Show (also available as a podcast) in which I talk about all things in tabletop RPGs. Here are last week's topics with time stamped links to the YouTube video:

D&D 2024 Core Book Release DatesCall the New Books "D&D 2024"D&D 2024 on Roll20Humblewood on D&D BeyondHow D&D Began VideoBest of Sly Flourish 2013-2023Different Steps for Different CircumstancesPatreon Questions and Answers

Also on the Talk Show, I answer questions from Sly Flourish Patrons. Here are last week's questions and answers:

Shadowed Keep on the Borderlands CampaignA Player's Version of Forge of Foes. Forge of Heroes?Favorite Three RPG MechanicsRPG Tips

Each week I think about what I learned in my last RPG session and write them up as RPG tips. Here are this week's tips:

Give each monster type one cool unique defining ability. Draw quick maps to orient players during a dungeon crawl. Ask one player to act as the cartographer. Ask one player to manage initiative. Ask one or more players to be the official note taker. Ask them to share their notes with the group. Include a friendly NPC the characters can talk to. Run a mix of easy and challenging encounters. Related ArticlesDungeon Crawls Versus SituationsRunning a Dungeon CrawlRunning Infiltration and Heist AdventuresGet More from Sly FlourishArticlesNewsletterBookstorePatreonPodcastYouTubeBuy Sly Flourish's Books Return of the Lazy Dungeon Master Lazy DM's Companion Lazy DM's Workbook Forge of Foes Fantastic Lairs Ruins of the Grendleroot Fantastic Adventures Fantastic Locations

Have a question or want to contact me? Check out Sly Flourish's Frequently Asked Questions.

Prepping, Running, and Overcoming the Pitfalls of Dungeon Crawls

This article is one in a series where we look at particular adventure types ��� how to prepare them, how to run them, what pitfalls we might run into, and how we might overcome these pitfalls.

The adventure types in this series include:

Dungeon crawlsInfiltrationInvestigationMissionsTravelDefenseIntrigue

This article focuses on one approach for running dungeon crawls and your own preferences may differ. That's totally fine. There are many right ways to prepare, run, and enjoy our games.

Robin Laws's book Adventure Crucible ��� Building Stronger Scenarios for any RPG heavily inspired this article.

Understanding Dungeon Crawls

In dungeon crawls, characters travel room-by-room through a relatively unknown maze-like location to accomplish one or more goals. Such dungeons can include crypts, caves, caverns, castle ruins, derelict ships, ruined towers, planar nodes, old temples, and other room-and-hall-based locations.

Preparing Dungeon Crawls

Consider the following steps when preparing a dungeon crawl:

Choose a map (I love dysonlogos maps.) Fill in location details ��� just a word or two per room. You can handwrite these notes right on a printed copy of the map.Write down potential traps and hazards.If using a published adventure, read over the rooms in the dungeon from the adventure.Write a clear goal to reinforce with your players. The goal should be important enough to offset the danger of going into the dungeon.Write out ten secrets and clues the characters might find in the dungeon. You don't have to set these clues in specific locations. Drop them in when it makes sense for the characters to learn them.List out potential monsters. Some monsters may be location specific but many might be wandering around.List out potential NPCs. They might reside in one room or wander around.List out treasure the characters might find. Feel free to place this treasure wherever it makes sense.Running Dungeon Crawls

At the beginning, perhaps as part of a strong start, make sure to state or reinforce the goal. Why are the characters going into the dungeon? Why is it worth risking their lives?

When the characters are in the dungeon, set up how the dungeon crawl works by asking the following questions:

Who's up front and who's in the back?What sort of lighting do the characters have?Who's keeping an eye out for monsters?Who's checking for traps, hazards, and secret doors? How are they checking?What paths do the characters want to take when they come to forks in the dungeon?

As the characters explore, dungeon inhabitants might move and react to the characters activities or the GM might roll for random encounters to shake things up.

Dungeon Crawl Pitfalls

The following common pitfalls can suck the fun out of a dungeon crawl. Be aware of them and account for them in your prep and play.

Too many downward beats.A boring or overly complicated dungeon design.Too many hard battles.No clear goal or reason to go into the dungeon.No place to rest after expending all the characters' resources.Few opportunities to roleplay.No real choice or useful information when picking a path.The monsters always surprise the characters.Offsetting Dungeon Crawl Pitfalls

Try the following ideas to offset potential pitfalls.

Fill out exploration of a dungeon with secrets and clues.Include upward beats like finding secret passages or getting the drop on unsuspecting foes.Include safe places for a short or long rest.Select maps with engaging dungeon designs including loopbacks, secret passages, multiple paths, and asymmetric designs.Ensure there's useful information to inform the characters' choices.Include non-hostile NPCs with whom the characters can roleplay.Mix easy and challenging battles that make sense for the situation, not just those tuned for the characters' level.The Most Common Adventure Type

Dungeon crawls are one of the most common adventure types, going back to the origins of D&D 50 years ago. With the tools above, we can use a common structure for preparation, gameplay, and avoiding pitfalls to run an awesome game for our friends.

More Sly Flourish Stuff

Last week I posted a couple of YouTube videos on Awarding Treasure in 5e and Roots of the Marrow Tree ��� Shadowdark Gloaming Session 22 Lazy GM Prep.

Last Week's Lazy RPG Talk Show Topics

Each week I record an episode of the Lazy RPG Talk Show (also available as a podcast) in which I talk about all things in tabletop RPGs. Here are last week's topics with time stamped links to the YouTube video:

D&D 2024 Core Book Release DatesCall the New Books "D&D 2024"D&D 2024 on Roll20Humblewood on D&D BeyondHow D&D Began VideoBest of Sly Flourish 2013-2023Different Steps for Different CircumstancesPatreon Questions and Answers

Also on the Talk Show, I answer questions from Sly Flourish Patrons. Here are last week's questions and answers:

Shadowed Keep on the Borderlands CampaignA Player's Version of Forge of Foes. Forge of Heroes?Favorite Three RPG MechanicsRPG Tips

Each week I think about what I learned in my last RPG session and write them up as RPG tips. Here are this week's tips:

Give each monster type one cool unique defining ability. Draw quick maps to orient players during a dungeon crawl. Ask one player to act as the cartographer. Ask one player to manage initiative. Ask one or more players to be the official note taker. Ask them to share their notes with the group. Include a friendly NPC the characters can talk to. Run a mix of easy and challenging encounters. Related ArticlesDungeon Crawls Versus SituationsRunning a Dungeon CrawlAdventure TypesGet More from Sly FlourishArticlesNewsletterBookstorePatreonPodcastYouTubeBuy Sly Flourish's Books Return of the Lazy Dungeon Master Lazy DM's Companion Lazy DM's Workbook Forge of Foes Fantastic Lairs Ruins of the Grendleroot Fantastic Adventures Fantastic Locations

Have a question or want to contact me? Check out Sly Flourish's Frequently Asked Questions.

Using Advantage and Disadvantage in 5e

"Advantage" and "disadvantage" are fantastic improvisational tools for 5e GMs. They give you incentives and discouragements to steer things towards the fun. Always remember that you have the ability to assign advantage and disadvantage in your toolbox to make the game more fun.

Many situations in the game already apply advantage or disadvantage. Being invisible or being unable to see applies such effects. Attacking someone within 5 feet who is prone gives you advantage while shooting at them from range gives you disadvantage.

Setting DCs and Offering Advantage or Disadvantage

It's important to understand when to raise or lower a DC and when to use advantage and disadvantage. Here's my lazy rule of thumb: You set a DC for a given situation regardless of the character performing the action. Breaking down a door might be a DC 18 but it's a DC 18 for anyone. The DC doesn't change based on who's doing it.

Advantage and disadvantage can change depending on who's performing the action. A circus performer might have a better chance at calming down an owlbear who used to work at the circus. Not only do they use their Wisdom bonus and add their proficiency with Animal Handling but their own special background makes them particularly good at this one specific thing. You might decide that their past experiences grants them advantage.

DCs are fixed based on the situation �����advantage and disadvantage are circumstantial to the characters performing the action.

Advantageous Situations

There are many other places we can offer advantage. Here are a few:

Terrain features. High ground might give characters advantage against targets down below. Fighting in a big mud pit might provide disadvantage.

Cinematic Action. Performing a fantastic acrobatic feat might provide advantage if you make the right check (see "Cinematic Advantage" for details).

Superior knowledge. A character's background, upbringing, species, or some other part of their history might grant them advantage on particular ability checks alongside their skill proficiency.

Incentives for Dangerous Choices. We can use advantage to incentivize players to draw characters into danger. Often we'd do this through inspiration, giving them inspiration for being willing to accept a risk they might not otherwise take but we might also offer direct advantage in the situation. Hugging the door isn't enough to get a great view of the arcane pillar but if they get right on top of it, they'd have advantage on the check.

For superior roleplaying. Often we hear about the situation in which a player does an amazing job roleplaying a situation but rolls a 2 on their Charisma (Persuasion) check. We can offer a player advantage if they do a particularly great job attempting to convince the viceroy of their need to speak to the queen. If a player does an amazing job roleplaying, maybe they automatically succeed.

Encouraging Teamwork. Lean in on characters helping one another by providing the character with the best overall bonus advantage as one or more other characters use the "help" action (see chapter 9 of the Player's Handbook) to help them succeed. Don't look for ways to stop two characters working on a problem ��� leap at the chance.

Steering Away with Disadvantage

We probably want to invoke disadvantage less often than we offer advantage. For every ten times we offer advantage, we may invoke disadvantage once. We can use disadvantage to steer characters away from things that clearly wouldn't work and we can declare it ahead of time. If a character is attempting something clearly too difficult, we might give it a high DC and disadvantage.

Often we invoke disadvantage with the expectation that the character simply changes their mind. That's totally fine.

Your GM's Helper

Advantage and disadvantage are powerful and easy tools to shift the direction of the game. Give them freely and use them to steer the game towards the most fun.

More Sly Flourish Stuff

Last week I posted a couple of YouTube videos on Last Minute RPG Prep and Journey to the Marrow Tree ��� Shadowdark Gloaming Session 21 Lazy GM Prep.

Last Week's Lazy RPG Talk Show Topics

Each week I record an episode of the Lazy RPG Talk Show (also available as a podcast) in which I talk about all things in tabletop RPGs. Here are last week's topics with time stamped links to the YouTube video:

Ginny Di on One-on-One D&DCrown and Skull by RunehammerCity of Arches Updates1d100 MonumentsBuild Custom Faction ListsPatreon Questions and Answers

Also on the Talk Show, I answer questions from Sly Flourish Patrons. Here are last week's questions and answers:

Banning SubclassesDecision Paralysis When Choosing What to RunRPG Tips

Each week I think about what I learned in my last RPG session and write them up as RPG tips. Here are this week's tips:

Watch out for the long monologue. Get to character decisions quickly. Let players customize improvised home bases. Make it clear when social chatter has stopped and the game has begun. Clarify the need for player consensus on in-world conflicts. Use table tools and notebooks you love to connect you to the joy of the game. Have an easy way to take notes during the game. A weird trans-dimensional home base is a great way to bring in irregular characters. Related ArticlesImprovising Combat Situations with Advantage, Disadvantage, and InspirationReplace Flanking with Cinematic AdvantageOur Ability Check ToolboxGet More from Sly FlourishArticlesNewsletterBookstorePatreonPodcastYouTubeBuy Sly Flourish's Books Return of the Lazy Dungeon Master Lazy DM's Companion Lazy DM's Workbook Forge of Foes Fantastic Lairs Ruins of the Grendleroot Fantastic Adventures Fantastic Locations

Have a question or want to contact me? Check out Sly Flourish's Frequently Asked Questions.

Tell, Don't Show

"Most readers are in trouble about half the time."

E.B. White

In 1990, Elizabeth Newman at Stanford University earned her PhD with an experiment. She had one participant tap out the rhythm of a popular song with their fingers while the other participant tried to guess what it was.

The tappers expected that 50% of the time respondents would be able to guess the song. It was actually 2.5%.

We GMs build rich worlds in our heads. We think through complex situations. We imagine NPCs living their lives, villains moving through their plots, vast dungeons buried beneath ancient mountains, and monsters lurking in the depths.

We do our best to describe these worlds and situations and adjudicate the results of the actions of the characters to our players. We love to imagine that the world we've built in our heads is the same one living in the heads of our players.

It's not.

Players understand about half of what we describe to them.

For a video on this topic, watch my Tell, Don't Show YouTube video.

A lot of the time, players don't really grab what's going on and we see this manifest in lots of ways.

Players don't realize the danger of their situation.Players miss a potential quest hook they'd be interested in.Players misinterpret an NPC's motivation or mannerisms.Players grab onto a piece of lore thinking it's a main quest when it's not.Players go after a minor villain and ignore the major one.Players make a poor choice on where to defend or where to rest.Players miss an obvious safe path and follow a more dangerous one.Players fully expect a trap when it's perfectly safe.Players think a location is perfectly safe when it's obviously trapped.Don't Hold Your Cards Too Close

Many DMs hold back information, thinking it's too much to tell players what's going on. They think it should be a surprise or the players need to say the right words to get the information they need. They think telling too much is leading the players or taking agency away from them.

But, when we realize players aren't always grasping the situation, we should put those cards on the table. Explain the situation. Reiterate things we think we've already said. Repeat ourselves. Emphasize what's important to understand.

The Players Are Not Their Characters

The characters in our games are full-time adventurers. They have eyes and ears and fingers most of the time. They're there in the situation. Our players are not. Players aren���t adventurers. Their lives aren't on the line. They're busy people with lives and jobs and families sitting at our table for an evening of fun. They're not really seeing what's going on the same way their characters are. Don't assume players understand what's going on.

Help players see what their characters see. If a player makes a bonehead decision, don't punish them for it. Reinforce what their character sees and what their character knows. Assume their character acts appropriately for their experience and their place in the world.

Assume players aren't grabbing what you're describing and help them out.

Tell, Don't Show

Sometimes, instead of waxing colorful metaphors, just tell players what's going on. Here are some situations where it might make sense.

A monster is clearly out of the characters' league.A monster is legendary and has legendary resistances.What happened the turn before in combat impacts the situation surrounding the character now.The characters exhausted all of the information they're going to get from an NPC.The characters thoroughly checked a room for traps, secrets, and treasure.A character will provoke an opportunity attack if they move.The three paths that stand in front of the characters.The characters' current goal in the area they're exploring.The characters don't have the item they need to progress further.The characters learned everything they can about a new magic item.When the characters act on a misunderstanding or follow a red herring too far.

Many of these things may seem obvious. You've given them the signs. You've seeded the secrets. And yet they're not grabbing on.

Just tell them.

Tell Them Colorfully

We don't have to fully break character when we tell them what's going on. We can keep our flowery narrative. Here are some in-world ways to make it clear to the players what's going on:

Looking at Xartherex the Balor, you are confident that this foe is beyond any of you.Behold! You face Hellmaw, the legendary ancient red dragon.After a thorough search, you are confident you've learned everything you can in this room.After careful study, you are confident you've learned everything you can about this magic sword.Study as you might, you can't get your head around these runes. You think only another primer or a more learned sage can help you.After a thorough examination, you don't believe spell, lock pick, or the mightiest hammer swing will break this massive door.

Feel free to keep your language colorful and stay in the world but state clearly what the characters know, or should know, about the situation. Give players the information they need to have fun.

Tell players what's going on.

More Sly Flourish Stuff

Last week I posted a couple of YouTube videos on Fantasy RPG Adventure Structures and .

Last Week's Lazy RPG Talk Show Topics

Each week I record an episode of the Lazy RPG Talk Show (also available as a podcast) in which I talk about all things in tabletop RPGs. Here are last week's topics with time stamped links to the YouTube video:

D&D on FoundryD&D Beyond Isn't Destroying the 5e HobbyShadowdark Print Books For SaleWhen To Use Simple or Complicated Stat BlocksPatreon Questions and Answers

Also on the Talk Show, I answer questions from Sly Flourish Patrons. Here are last week's questions and answers:

XP Loss on Death in ShadowdarkWhy No Shapechange for Flee Mortals Vampires?Looking Back on Old SecretsTeaching New Players 5e through D&DQuest Continuity in ShadowdarkRPG Tips

Each week I think about what I learned in my last RPG session and write them up as RPG tips. Here are this week's tips:

Pool damage in one tally for large groups of monsters. Each time it has enough damage to kill a monster, remove the last monster hit. Roll once for several attacks or saves for large numbers of monsters. Choose a number of rolls and divide total damage by the number of rolls.For quick skirmishes, go around the table or alphabetically instead of rolling for initiative. Ask players to describe new features to the group when they level up. Let characters build their own safe haven for resting even in the darkest dungeons.Feeling overwhelmed? Boil your next session down to its most necessary elements: a strong start, a map, some monsters, and some discoveries.Improvise monsters with core stats and an interesting feature or two. Related ArticlesAsk Players to Describe New Character AbilitiesFocus Extra Prep Time on the CharactersOffer Secret Paths in Dungeons or Overland JourneysGet More from Sly FlourishArticlesNewsletterBookstorePatreonPodcastYouTubeBuy Sly Flourish's Books Return of the Lazy Dungeon Master Lazy DM's Companion Lazy DM's Workbook Forge of Foes Fantastic Lairs Ruins of the Grendleroot Fantastic Adventures Fantastic Locations

Have a question or want to contact me? Check out Sly Flourish's Frequently Asked Questions.

Tune Monsters with Extra Attacks

Not all monsters are created equal for their challenge rating. Some monsters don���t hit very hard at higher challenge ratings. Others hit well above their weight class.

I���ve talked about the four dials of monster difficulty before:

The number of monsters in a battleA monster's maximum hit pointsThe number of attacks the monster hasThe amount of damage those attacks inflict

We can tweak monsters, either before or during a fight, using these four dials. Has a battle overstayed its welcome and gotten boring? Drop those monster hit points. Is an otherwise fun and challenging battle becoming boring because it's too easy? Jack up that damage.

If this topic is of high interest to you, please check out our book Forge of Foes with tons of great advice and tools to help you run monsters in your 5e games.

Adding or reducing the number of attacks a monster has is an easy and powerful way to change the difficulty of a monster. We don't have to do any complicated math or calculations in our head for this modification. We don't have to roll more damage dice. Instead, we just have a monster attack again or have it make one less attack.

This "number of attacks" dial has a big impact. If a monster only has one attack and you give it two ��� you're doubling its potential damage output. If a monster attacks three times but you only have it attack twice, you're removing 50% of its damaging threat. It's a big dial but it's an easy one to turn and create a big effect.

Normalizing the Action Economy

We might turn the "number of attacks" dial to account for a big delta in the action economy. Four characters versus a single monster has a big sway in the action economy ��� the number of actions (attacks) the characters have versus the number of attacks the monster has.

In a case like this example, giving the monster more attacks helps even out that delta. We probably don't want to have the monster make all of its attacks against a single target, though, instead spreading them out to other members of the group.

Reducing the Threat

Likewise, if a particular monster proves too deadly for a group, it can attack less. Just because Agdon Longscarf can make two branding iron attacks doesn't mean he has to every round. Maybe he does so if he's surrounded. Maybe he does a jaunty dance instead of that second attack. Monsters don't always behave optimally.

Fixing Sub-Par Monsters

Often higher CR monsters hit below their challenge rating. I think this is due to overweighting the extra abilities these monsters have. I argue these monsters need those extra abilities to challenge higher level characters. The result of these overweighted abilities is a reduction in damage. It's not uncommon to find lower challenge monsters hitting at 10 damage per challenge rating (the thug hits at 20 per CR!) but higher challenge monsters hit for 5 or 6 damage per CR. Their extra abilities don't make up for that drop in damage.

If a monster isn't holding up its end of the fight, give it another attack.

Think About Why You're Doing It

It's important to know why you're adding or subtracting attacks. Are you really adding to the fun of the game or just making yourself feel better? I like to imagine the dials have resistance to them. They like to spring to the average. They need force to move. We don't just move them willy nilly. We need a good reason. What are some good reasons?

A monster is significantly outclassed in the action economy.A monster hits below the challenge it represents in the fiction of the game.A big boss is really only threatening one character instead of almost all of them.The amount of damage the monster inflicts is boring.A lower challenge monster faces higher level characters and would otherwise be completely useless without more attacks.We want to increase the threat without making battles longer.

Why shouldn't we give a monster more attacks?

We're mad at the players.We want to punish the characters.We're sad our monster rolled so many failed attacks.An Easy Tool for the Toolbox

Of all of the dials of monster difficulty, adding or removing an attack to a monster's arsenal might be the easiest to implement and have a significant impact on the situation. Keep this tool handy and use it to tune your game for the most fun at the table.

More Sly Flourish Stuff

Each week I record an episode of the Lazy RPG Talk Show (also available as a podcast) in which I talk about all things in tabletop RPGs. Here are last week's topics with time stamped links to the YouTube video:

Vault 5e Crafting and Alchemy by Cubicle 7Making Your Lore Optional by PHD20Bob World Builder on 15 Different RPGsKelsey Dionne and Baron de Ropp on RPG DesignTegan J Gaming on a Defense of Dungeons & DragonsDwarven Forge VTT BackdropsTTRPG Tips from Baldur's Gate 3

I also posted a YouTube video on the Tomb of Kytheros ��� Shadowdark Gloaming Session 19 Lazy GM Prep.

Patreon Questions and Answers

Also on the Talk Show, I answer questions from Sly Flourish Patrons. Here are last week's questions and answers:

Are Casters Better than Martial Characters in 5e?Running Single-Session One-Shot Games On TimeRunning Too Many NPCsWriting Adventures as Good as Published OnesWolfgang Baur on WorldbuildingRPG Tips

Each week I think about what I learned in my last RPG session and write them up as RPG tips. Here are this week's tips:

Keep the situation dynamic in big battles. Change up the tactics and environment. Roleplay villains in combat. What do they say? How do they react to the characters?More monsters are a bigger threat than big monsters. Boss monsters almost always have allies. Intelligent magic items are tag-along NPCs who don���t take up the spotlight. Did a character die? Give their player an NPC to control. Set up hard set piece battles with lots of monsters and then lean in on cool character ideas. Related ArticlesThe Dials of Monster DifficultyWhat Does Challenge Rating Mean in D&D 5e?Customizing MonstersGet More from Sly FlourishArticlesNewsletterBookstorePatreonPodcastYouTubeBuy Sly Flourish's Books Return of the Lazy Dungeon Master Lazy DM's Companion Lazy DM's Workbook Forge of Foes Fantastic Lairs Ruins of the Grendleroot Fantastic Adventures Fantastic Locations

Have a question or want to contact me? Check out Sly Flourish's Frequently Asked Questions.

Lazy Monster Damage ��� Subtract 3, Add 1d6

This tip is a trick I first heard attributed to Chris Perkins. I've used it a lot and love it. First, I'm a huge proponent of using static monster damage. It's fast, easy, and moves the game forward at a good clip. It's super lazy.

Some don't like how static damage is so, well, static. So here's a trick to add variance without a lot of work.

Subtract 3 from the static damage of a monster and add 1d6.

It adds just enough variance to make the damage feel different but needs only a single d6 and the math is easy.

What About Critical Hits?

For critical hits, double the static damage, subtract 3, and add 1d6. Sure, crits hit harder than usual but monsters can use the love.

Ignore for Lower Dice Damage

You really only need this trick if rolling monster damage uses two or more dice. If it's a single die and a modifier then subtracting 3 and adding 1d6 isn't making things easier. When a monster inflicts two or more dice worth of damage �����often on a multi-attack ��� rolling all those dice slows things down.

That said, if you want to use a d6 for everything, you can still subtract 3 and add 1d6 to every static damage value you come across.

Give it a try!

More Sly Flourish Stuff

Last week I posted a couple of YouTube videos on Building Fantastic Monuments in D&D and 5e Combat and a Forge of Foes Deep Dive.

Last Week's Lazy RPG Talk Show Topics

Each week I record an episode of the Lazy RPG Talk Show (also available as a podcast) in which I talk about all things in tabletop RPGs. Here are last week's topics with time stamped links to the YouTube video:

Tales of the Valiant Gamemaster's GuideGate Pass Gazette 2023 for Level Up Advanced 5eWhat Is 5e?Using the Eight Steps At the TablePatreon Questions and Answers

Also on the Talk Show, I answer questions from Sly Flourish Patrons. Here are last week's questions and answers:

How Many Battles in a Dungeon?Should We Demand Players Read the Books?Player Rolls or Player Skill for Puzzles?RPG Tips

Each week I think about what I learned in my last RPG session and write them up as D&D tips. Here are this week's tips:

Expect single monsters to be taken out with a single ability above 7th level. What did this location used to be?The enemy of their enemy may be their friend.Be very careful taking agency away from a character.Go around the table for quick initiative during small battles. Use a d6 as an oracle die to determine things like guard patrols or other random events. Ask players to discuss new abilities when they level up. Write them down.Related ArticlesThe Case for Static Monster DamageUse Static Initiative for MonstersHow Do You Feel Rolling a Crit?Get More from Sly FlourishArticlesNewsletterBookstorePatreonPodcastYouTubeBuy Sly Flourish's Books Return of the Lazy Dungeon Master Lazy DM's Companion Lazy DM's Workbook Forge of Foes Fantastic Lairs Ruins of the Grendleroot Fantastic Adventures Fantastic Locations

Have a question or want to contact me? Check out Sly Flourish's Frequently Asked Questions.

Replacing 5e's Inspiration with Luck

In the Tales of the Valiant 5e RPG and their Project Black Flag system reference document, Kobold Press introduces us to the Luck mechanic�������a direct replacement for the standard 5e "Inspiration" mechanic. Here's how it works.

The Luck SystemEvery time a character misses an attack or a saving throw, they gain one luck point.They can only hold up to five luck points. If they gain a sixth luck point, they roll 1d4 and that's how many luck points they have now.They can spend one luck point to get +1 to a D20 roll after they roll.They can spend three luck points to re-roll a d20 check.

GMs can award luck points for good roleplaying, brave behavior, and other times we might award inspiration but players will primarily gain luck with missed attacks and saving throws (not ability checks.)

I've used this luck mechanic in my 5e games for a while now and I love it. It takes the burden off of the GM to award inspiration, something I often forget. For players, it takes the edge off of the disappointment of rolling a missed attack or saving throw. It's an entire system managed primarily by players and yet we GMs can still offer luck points to incentivize heroic deeds. We can also use luck points as bargaining chips with players when they want to do something risky but are worried about consequences of failure.

Introducing Luck

If we do decide to bring in luck, or any other new mechanics into our game, it behooves us to have a conversation with our players about it. Ask them if it's something they're interested in. Maybe give it a trial run and see if people like it before using it regularly.

Expanding 5e's Mechanics

Luck is one of the many new mechanics we're seeing designers bring into the larger 5e space. Because it's encapsulated, we can remove inspiration and replace it with luck and nothing else needs to change.

I think we're going to see a lot of cool ideas like this one come out over 2024 and I'm excited to see them. Not every variant needs to work for all groups �����you may not like the luck mechanic, and that's fine. But you might like some other mechanic like Level Up Advanced 5e's "Strife" condition or its use of "Supply" for exploration and resting. You might like the way exhaustion worked in the early 2024 D&D playtest where each level of exhaustion was -1 to D20 checks.

With all of these variants and sub-systems coming out, we can build the version of 5e we want for our own table. None of them need be the same. If it works for you and your group �����it works.

More Sly Flourish Stuff

Last week I posted a couple of YouTube videos on Blocking Rooms in Owlbear Rodeo and Mummy on the Bridge.

Last Week's Lazy RPG Talk Show Topics

Each week I record an episode of the Lazy RPG Talk Show (also available as a podcast) in which I talk about all things in tabletop RPGs. Here are last week's topics with time stamped links to the YouTube video:

City of Arches UpdateJennell Jaquays Passes AwayDon't Throw Away 5e Because of HasbroWeapons of Legend for 5e by Jeff StevensAdd the Black Flag Luck System to your 5e gamesPatreon Questions and Answers

Also on the Talk Show, I answer questions from Sly Flourish Patrons. Here are last week's questions and answers:

Pacing Quests for Villainous PlotsPricing Magic ItemsBest Quest Vehicles in City of ArchesPreparing Players for a 2e CampaignRPG Tips

Each week I think about what I learned in my last RPG session and write them up as D&D tips. Here are this week's tips:

Write out a loose outline of scenes even if you know they could go off track.Prep NPCs with appearance, mannerisms, and motivations. What do they want? What would they be doing if the characters aren't around?Avoid chains of hard combat. Throw in easy fights, conversations, and elements of exploration.What can the characters learn in your next game?Use maps and minis for conversations. Use theater of the mind for combat.Let characters knock bad guys into their own traps and make your players love you forever.Put choices and options in front of your players near the end of a session so you know what to prep next.Related ArticlesAlternative Standard Arrays for 5e Ability ScoresDescribe your GM StyleFocus Extra Prep Time on the CharactersGet More from Sly FlourishArticlesNewsletterBookstorePatreonPodcastYouTubeBuy Sly Flourish's Books Return of the Lazy Dungeon Master Lazy DM's Companion Lazy DM's Workbook Forge of Foes Fantastic Lairs Ruins of the Grendleroot Fantastic Adventures Fantastic Locations

Have a question or want to contact me? Check out Sly Flourish's Frequently Asked Questions.