Against Meritocracy Quotes

“Meritocracy offers a ladder system of social mobility, promoting a socially corrosive ethic of competitive self-interest which both legitimises inequality and damages community ‘by requiring people to be in a permanent state of competition with each other’ (Hickman 2009). The ‘fair’ neoliberal meritocratic dream rests on the idea of a level playing field, conveniently ignoring systematic inequality, social location and the head start accrued by the children of those at the top or high up the social ladder.”
― Jo Littler, Against Meritocracy: Culture, power and myths of mobility

“The first problem with the contemporary meaning of meritocracy is that it endorses a competitive, linear, hierarchical system in which by definition certain people must be left behind. The top cannot exist without the bottom. Not everyone can ‘rise’.”
― Jo Littler, Against Meritocracy: Culture, power and myths of mobility

“Meritocracy may seem a very contemporary idea, but, as Raymond Williams argued in a book review in 1958, the ladder is a perfect symbol of the bourgeois idea of society, for, while it undoubtedly offers the opportunity to climb, ‘it is a device that can only be used individually; you go up the ladder alone’. Such an ‘alternative to solidarity’, pointed out Williams, has dazzled many working-class leaders and is objectionable in two respects: firstly, it weakens community and the task of common betterment; and secondly, it ‘sweetens the poison of hierarchy’ by offering advancement through merit rather than money or birth, whilst retaining a commitment to the very notion of hierarchy itself (Williams 1958: 331).”
― Jo Littler, Against Meritocracy: Culture, power and myths of mobility

“The neoliberal idea of meritocracy as enabling a fair system of social mobility is therefore both profoundly unfair and an ideological sleight of hand, working to justify a system based on greed and extensive structural injustice.”
― Jo Littler, Against Meritocracy: Culture, power and myths of mobility

“Meritocracy contradicts the principle of equality, of an equalitarian democracy, no less than any other oligarchy. Hannah Arendt”
― Jo Littler, Against Meritocracy: Culture, power and myths of mobility