Determinism or Free-Will? Quotes

“All science is a search for the conditions that determine phenomena.”
― Chapman Cohen, Determinism or Free-Will?

“When a dog is about to rest it often tramps round and round the spot on which it is to recline. Naturalists explain this as the survival of an instinct which in the wild dog served the useful function of guarding it against the presence of harmful creatures hidden in the grass.”
― Chapman Cohen, Determinism or Free-Will?

“Man is a social animal; his character is a social product. The purely human qualities not only lose their value when divorced from social relationships, it is these relationships that provide the only medium for their activity. To say that a person is free to express moral qualities in the absence of his fellows is meaningless, since it is only in their presence that the manifestation of them is possible.”
― Chapman Cohen, Determinism or Free-Will?

“And why urge people to make an effort in this or that direction if everything, including the effort or its absence, is determined?”
― Chapman Cohen, Determinism or Free-Will?

“A satisfactory answer clearly cannot be found in the assumption that each person's actions proceed from an unfettered, autonomous will. The reason for the choice would still have to be discovered. Nor will it do to attribute the difference of choice to different environmental influences in which the "self" is placed. This would indeed be reducing the man to the level of a machine, or to a lower level still. And the same environmental influences do not produce identical results.”
― Chapman Cohen, Determinism or Free-Will?

“A newly-born child has no volitions, only reflexes. It is only when experience has supplied us with an idea of what may be done that we will it shall be done. This consideration alone is enough to shatter the case for the supposed freedom of the will. [3]”
― Chapman Cohen, Determinism or Free-Will?