Nostalgia Reader’s Reviews > The Return of Sherlock Holmes > Status Update

SECO: 3 stars. Started off with the potential to be really interesting, ended up being very anti-climactic.

ABBE: 3.5 stars. Enjoyable, kind of obvious where it was going and it feels like a mash up of tropes from various previous stories were used.

MISS: 2.5 stars. Not terrible, not much of a mystery, and, as Holmes says "My ramifications stretch out into many sections of society, but never, I am happy to say, into amateur sport."

GOLD: 3.5 stars. An interesting, straightforward case.

3STU: 2 stars. Very much felt like a one off side mystery.

SIXN: 3.5 stars. Fun, but predictably racist... at least it wasn't an orangutan!

CHAS: 4.5 stars. I was mostly bored until the last two pages--YOU GO, GIRL!!!

PIRO: 3 stars. Atmospheric with the moorish setting, but otherwise too long and boring.

SOLI: 4.5 stars. Lots of reasons to like this one: higher stakes and action, relevant to Researcher's First Murder, and, once again, SO VIVIDLY reminds me of an Avengers episode!

DANC: 4.5 stars. Finally something with some high stakes!!