Mark André ’s Reviews > The March of Folly: From Troy to Vietnam > Status Update
Mark André
is on page 377 of 447
Too many Americans had come to feel that the war war wrong, out of all proportion to the national interest and in successful besides. Populists like to speak of the “wisdom of the people”; the American people were not so much wise as fed up, which in certain cases is a kind of wisdom. Withdrawal of public support proved the undoing of an Executive that believed it could conduct... war without... the national will...
— Aug 18, 2024 11:59AM
9 likes · Like flag
Mark’s Previous Updates
Mark André
is on page 63 of 447
beneath a reign of uncouth stars
November 6, 2024. A black day!
The blackest we’ve ever known.
Poor US. Poor World. Poor All.!
— Nov 05, 2024 10:40PM
November 6, 2024. A black day!
The blackest we’ve ever known.
Poor US. Poor World. Poor All.!
Mark André
is on page 63 of 447
To an unusual degree in the Renaissance good walked with evil in a wondrous development of the arts combined with political and moral degradation and vicious behavior. Discovery of classical antiquity with its focus on human capacity instead of on a ghostly Trinity was exuberant experience that led to a passionate embrace of humanism,...
— Oct 24, 2024 01:46PM
Mark André
is on page 368 of 447
On 7 October Senator Eugene McCarthy of Minnesota, in the long line of political independents bred in that region, filled the void with the announcement of his candidacy.
— Aug 18, 2024 10:45AM
Mark André
is on page 352 of 447
American fighting tactics were designed in terms of large troop formations making use of mobility, and in terms of industrial targets for the exercise of air power. Once in motion the American military machine could not readjust to a warfare in which these elements did not exist. The American mentality counted on superior might, but a tank cannot disperse wasps.
— Aug 12, 2024 09:33AM
Mark André
is on page 318 of 447
American forces in Vietnam...also took casualties
14 killed or wounded in 1961, 109 in 1962, 489 in 1963.
This was war by the Executive, without Congressional authorization,
The United States is now involved in an undeclared war in South Vietnam.” wrote James Reston on the same day (February 1962).
“This is well known to the Russians, the Chinese Communists and everyone else concerned except the American people.
— Aug 10, 2024 12:09PM
14 killed or wounded in 1961, 109 in 1962, 489 in 1963.
This was war by the Executive, without Congressional authorization,
The United States is now involved in an undeclared war in South Vietnam.” wrote James Reston on the same day (February 1962).
“This is well known to the Russians, the Chinese Communists and everyone else concerned except the American people.
Mark André
is on page 265 of 447
As 1950 opened, Senator Joseph McCarthy announced that he had a list of 205 “card-carrying” Communists in the employ of the State Department, and for the next four years Americans joined in more than they opposed his vilification of fellow citizens as Communist infiltrators of American society.
— Jul 07, 2024 11:55AM
Mark André
is on page 49 of 447
In the search for meaning we must not forget that the gods ... are a concept of the hunan mind: ... They are needed and invented to give meaning and purpose to the puzzle that is life on earth, to explain strange and irregular phenomena of nature, haphazard events and, above all, irrational human conduct. They exist to bear the burden of all things that cannot be comprehended except by supernatural intervention or ..
— Jun 16, 2024 02:27PM
Mark André
is on page 29 of 447
A peace without victory would not only terminate dreams of mastery but require enormous taxes to pay for years of fighting that had grown profitless. It would mean revolution. To the throne, the military caste, the landowners, industrialists and barons of business, only a war of gain offered any hope of their survival in power.
— Jun 14, 2024 10:04AM
Mark André
is on page 6 of 447
While all other sciences have advanced, confessed our second President, John Adams, “government is at a stand: little better practiced now than three or four thousand years ago.
— Jun 13, 2024 12:05PM
Comments Showing 1-13 of 13 (13 new)
date
newest »
newest »
Thank you, Alicia! >)Nice to hear from you. Bad government doesn’t seem to belong to either party or any particular individual. It is pervasive all the time and everywhere.
Thank you, Clarissa! >)Nice to hear from you. It’s sad reading to be reminded of our national folly, and the 59 thousand men and women who lost their lives, for in the end, nothing.
Thank you, Joana! >)Nice to hear from you. Reading the history of events contemporary to one’s own time is a lot different than reading about the past.
I feel sorrier for the untold Vietnamese who were slaughtered in this horror...and the Cambodians who were "in the way".And zero reparations to this day. The American way.
Nocturnalux wrote: "I feel sorrier for the untold Vietnamese who were slaughtered in this horror...and the Cambodians who were "in the way".And zero reparations to this day. The American way."
Thank you, Nocturnalux! >)
Nice to hear from you. You’re quite right. And Tuchman details most thoroughly the massive hurt done to the civilians both South and North where causality and loss were much more extreme than America’s. You’re quite right.
Thank you, India M.! >)Nice to hear from you. I like history and I like Tuchman’s approach. I got this specifically for the discussion of Vietnam.
I loved reading of the decadent renaissance popes, the over-inbred fops of British parliament... but the Vietnam section was too painful. The folly of history is humorous unless it's your history.
Thank you, Raymond. >)Good to hear from you. Very well said. I bought the book specifically for her review of the Vietnam War. What’s saddest to me is that our government hasn’t gotten any smarter in the 60 years since.
Thank you, Raymond. >)Good to hear from you. I finished the Vietnam chapter(s). The whole thing is very sad and foreboding. We seem incapable of learning, as the stupid people who the politicians play to seem as numerous as ever. It’s rather different reading the history of something you lived through yourself.✌️


Good to hear from you. It is a sad memory.