Nostalgia Reader’s Reviews > The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes > Status Update
Nostalgia Reader
is finished
FINA: 4.5 stars. If only the rest of the stories could have been this thrilling! Even though I knew how it ended, it was a very enjoyable cat and mouse chase to get there.
— May 27, 2024 05:59PM
Like flag
Nostalgia Reader’s Previous Updates
Nostalgia Reader
is 91% done
NAVA: 3 stars. Not a bad story, but unnecessarily long, and a bit of a disapointing finish to such a long story.
— May 25, 2024 04:05PM
Nostalgia Reader
is 61% done
CROO: 2 stars. If you've read Kipling, you've read this story. Points for Teddy.
— Apr 13, 2024 09:37AM
Nostalgia Reader
is 53% done
REIG: 2.5 stars. The case was well played out, but motive was barely there or explained.
— Apr 13, 2024 09:36AM
Nostalgia Reader
is 44% done
MUSG: 4.5 stars. Ya can't go wrong with a good treasure hunt story!
— Apr 02, 2024 05:20PM
Nostalgia Reader
is 36% done
GLOR: 4 stars. That was a fun one, a a great background to Holmes' first case.
— Apr 02, 2024 08:45AM
Nostalgia Reader
is 28% done
STOC: 2 stars. Meh. Not really any stakes involved.
— Mar 31, 2024 06:21AM
Nostalgia Reader
is 11% done
SILV: 3 stars. A unique-ish twist, very middle of the road overall.
— Mar 20, 2024 06:27AM
