Prerna’s Reviews > Lost in Math: How Beauty Leads Physics Astray > Status Update

Prerna
Prerna is 40% done
Adding this update solely so that I can apparently be the first person to quote someone quoting someone quoting himself quoting someone. But since the allowed number of characters here is too little to add the actual quote, I'm gonna do it in the comment section.
Feb 01, 2022 05:40AM
Lost in Math: How Beauty Leads Physics Astray

8 likes ·  flag

Prerna’s Previous Updates

Prerna
Prerna is 21% done
If you’re a hard-nosed layperson and your knowledge about physics was based on Brian Greene’s book The Elegant Universe—not to pick on Brian—but you could get away with the idea that physicists are just making shit up. This is unfortunate because it’s far away from reality, the reality of a decent, honest physicist.

Lol.
Jan 28, 2022 06:54PM
Lost in Math: How Beauty Leads Physics Astray


Comments Showing 1-8 of 8 (8 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

Prerna “The difficulty, of course, is that you don’t have to settle these issues,” Weinberg continues. “I’ve had a whole career without knowing what quantum mechanics is. I tell this story in one of the books that my colleague Philip Candelas was referring to a graduate student whose career essentially disintegrated, and I asked what went wrong and he said, ‘He tried to understand quantum mechanics.’ He could have had a perfectly good career without it. But getting into the fundamentals of quantum mechanics is a losing game.”
(If you quote this, you can be the first person to quote someone quoting someone quoting himself quoting someone.)



message 2: by Théo d'Or (new)

Théo d'Or I won't quote this, so as not to be the first person to quote someone quoting someone quoting himself quoting someone. Maybe I'II change my mind if someone quotes me, so I can quote indefinitely, depending on the number of those quoting me. You have priority.


Prerna But you haven't actually quoted it, so this infinite series of quoting hasn't even started. Yet. Theodore, you're such a party pooper.


message 4: by Théo d'Or (new)

Théo d'Or You know the saying - ladies first.


message 5: by Goatboy (new) - added it

Goatboy Very fitting for a book with "Lost" in the title... Although perhaps more appropriate for a book on set theory? LOL


Rosh ~catching up slowly~ I took my time to get the who-quoted-whom. It was fun. :D


Prerna Goatboy wrote: "Very fitting for a book with "Lost" in the title... Although perhaps more appropriate for a book on set theory? LOL"

Not sure about just set theory, but as much as I love it, 'lost' would be befitting for any book on math. Sadly, we don't seem to have as many pop-math books. I have difficulty thinking of math as existing on its own in an abstract space, although I do this all the time with physics, especially with quantum mechanics. Aaaaaaa, perhaps that's why I don't get Tegmark.

Anyway, 'Lost' is definitely apt for this book, because I am currently in the sixth chapter and the author seems so frustrated and LOST! In a good way.


Prerna RoshReviews wrote: "I took my time to get the who-quoted-whom. It was fun. :D"

To be honest, I didn't even completely absorb the who-quoted-whom bit because my brain saw the 'you can be the first person...' and went 'YES!'


back to top