Amanda Berry’s Reviews > Long Shadows > Status Update

I think that the character Lionpaw in my book is very naive. He is very gullible when someone tells him something for example he believed that Tigerstar really isn't a villain when Tigerstar literally said "I'm not so bad" crazy! He also freaked out as much as any other cat did when the sun 'disappeared' but as a apprentice that is ready to become a warrior he shouldn't be afraid.

In the book I am reading Jaypaw is out at the Moonpool with the other medicine cats from different clans. I don't exactly know / remember when they do this but it happens once or twice in each book. Anyway I'm noticing Jaypaw is having many doubts that ShadowClan will ever go back to StarClan and that Sol will be kicked out. I think if Sol were banished it would make it a lot easier for the 4 clans.

My prior knowledge on these books is that the old windclan leader Tallstar was very old, using some of his 9 lives because of that. Now I am thinking if Tallstar was younger and didn’t die and choose Onewhisker to be leader, then the battle would never had happened. Which would’ve prevented the clans to think that Starclan was mad because they battled.

Using my prior knowledge I know that the clans don't trust random cats that walk into their territory so this makes me confused why Shadowclan trusts Sol, although even so if Sol never walked into the clans territory and talked to Jaypaw about the eclipse, then went to Shadowclan and told them about it. Shadowclan would not have left StarClan.