Scott’s Reviews > Girl in Snow > Status Update

Scott
Scott is 75% done
Oct 21, 2017 04:56PM
Girl in Snow

2 likes ·  flag

Scott’s Previous Updates

Scott
Scott is 10% done
Oct 19, 2017 05:02PM
Girl in Snow


Comments Showing 1-8 of 8 (8 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

Kathrin What are your thoughts this far?


Scott To be honest, I am struggling a bit with the author's writing style. She's all over the place. There are some strong scenes, but then there's a lot of jumping around in telling the different character's backstory which is rather hard on the reader.

I have about 50 pages left and will be writing my review later today or tomorrow. We'll see how I feel after the ending...


Kathrin I know what you are talking about. The writing style seemed a little unpolished at times. I did read an ARC which is why I hoped that it would be better in the published version.

Looking forward to your review.


Scott It feels like 90% of the books is background stories, which bounce all over the place, and about only 10% is focused on the actual mystery itself. So far 2 days have gone by and not much time has been spent on developing the investigation. Some editing would have helped tighten these problems up.

I am glad to know that i am not the only one who has these thoughts. Thank you for confirming that.


Kathrin Scott wrote: "It feels like 90% of the books is background stories, which bounce all over the place, and about only 10% is focused on the actual mystery itself. So far 2 days have gone by and not much time has b..."

Personally, I believe this book only tries to be a mystery but fails miserable. The investigation wasn't that important in the end. I liked the book a lot more when I finally understood that.


Scott I agree 100%. I am now posting my review and you hit the answer exactly! Excellent thought.


Scott You are so absolutely correct. I want to quote you in my review. That was an absolutely excellent observation. Thank you!


Scott All right, my review is out and I hope I did you justice in my reference. You are brilliantly observant. Thank you!


back to top