Dani ♡’s Reviews > One of Us Is Lying > Status Update

my NEW theory is that simon killed himself. like.... no offense he was obsessed with ways to turn a school upside down, and wanted it to be creative so... this is a creative way to turn everything on its head. a suicide that ruins four people's lives. the ultimate way to keep himself alive, while successfully torturing everyone else –– personal and effective and no one would ever see it coming.

Okay my second guess is that it's Janae... She could be a fake crier and like, goes over to Addy's house only to like plant some evidence and frame her.... I GOT MY EYE ON U JANAE.

OH WOW I DID NOT SEE THAT COMING AT ALL. THIS JUST KEEPS GETTING BETTER AND BETTER.

Okay that's twice they mentioned the teacher... So it's probably not him. UGHHHH. Back to the drawing board...? Am I stubborn or stupid for wanting to stick with the theory regardless??

MY GIRL ADDY!!! She came out of nowhere and snatched my dang heart!!! Baby girl got out of a toxic relationship and is now learning to stand on her own two feet and that just makes me so happy and proud of her??

She quoted Song of Myself and the obvious stylistic choice there is AMAZING. "I contain multitudes" – so clever to have that be part of the line she quoted, because she IS more than who she was with Jake.

Okay but she literally just said it could be him so you know what I'm sticking with my damn theory. IF THIS IS WRONG I'M GOING TO BE SO FRUSTRATED

I'M LAYING DOWN A BET RN that it's the teacher, Mr. Avery who did it, because a) he emphasized "gossip" all weird, and he's the only other person who was in the room asides from the four. Uh... Did I just solve the murder?

Months of playing Nancy Drew have finally come in clutch. HIRE ME @ HER INTERACTIVE!!

OOOOOOOOOH HE LYIN!!!!!! The secrets are coming out and it is J U I C Y.

I'VE BEEN WANTING TO READ THIS BOOK FOR WHAT FEELS LIKE FOREVER. I'm so excited ahh!!!