Troy Terwilliger’s Reviews > Determined: A Science of Life without Free Will > Status Update
Troy Terwilliger
is 4% done
When you strip away free will, traditional praise and blame take a massive hit because the idea of "moral desert"—the notion that someone deserves credit or punishment because they could have done otherwise—collapses.
— Nov 11, 2026 10:32PM
Like flag
Troy’s Previous Updates
Troy Terwilliger
is 52% done
Whether your brain is governed by classical biological cause-and-effect or subatomic probabilistic noise, neither framework leaves any room for an uncaused "author" sitting inside your head.
— Nov 15, 2026 10:15PM
Troy Terwilliger
is 47% done
Emergence is not an escape hatch from causality. Whether you look at a single serotonin receptor or an emergent, high-level moral philosophy, every step of the process is locked in an unbroken chain of cause and effect. Free will doesn't "just emerge"—what emerges is an extraordinarily complex, self-monitoring biological system that misinterprets its own inner complexity as freedom.
— Nov 15, 2026 09:57PM
Troy Terwilliger
is 41% done
Just because a complex system’s behavior cannot be easily reduced to a simple linear equation does not mean the system is uncaused. The ant colony’s macro-intelligence is 100% bound by the biological rules of ant behavior; your brain’s emergent moral decisions are 100% bound by the neurobiological, genetic, and environmental rules governing your neural circuits.
— Nov 15, 2026 09:32PM
Troy Terwilliger
is 35% done
Chaos theory explains how startlingly sophisticated behaviors "emerge" from thousands of simple, unconscious biological triggers interacting simultaneously.
— Nov 15, 2026 09:16PM
Troy Terwilliger
is 33% done
The Butterfly Effect: In chaotic systems, microscopic, unmeasurable differences in starting conditions can amplify exponentially over time into wildly divergent outcomes.
— Nov 15, 2026 09:08PM
Troy Terwilliger
is 23% done
In Chapter 4, Sapolsky takes direct aim at our culture’s favorite modern religion: grit, willpower, and self-discipline.
Society loves to idolize people who pull themselves up by their bootstraps, resist temptation, and grind their way to success. We treat willpower as the ultimate moral scorecard—a pure reflection of individual character. Willpower is an illusion, and "grit" is just a biological luxury.
— Nov 15, 2026 08:35PM
Society loves to idolize people who pull themselves up by their bootstraps, resist temptation, and grind their way to success. We treat willpower as the ultimate moral scorecard—a pure reflection of individual character. Willpower is an illusion, and "grit" is just a biological luxury.
Troy Terwilliger
is 22% done
..then any belief system built on moral superiority, retribution, or entitlement collapses. In its place, the only logically consistent belief system left is one focused on reducing suffering and engineering environments that bring out the best outcomes for everyone, regardless of the hand they were dealt.
— Nov 14, 2026 12:09PM
Troy Terwilliger
is 17% done
Sapolsky uses prenatal and intrauterine environments to dismantle one of our most deeply held illusions: that we begin life as a blank slate. When we think about influences on a person, we usually picture childhood, parenting, or schooling. But he pushes the timeline all the way back to pregnancy, showing how deeply the womb acts as an environmental crucible that shapes the brain before a baby ever takes a breath.
— Nov 14, 2026 11:57AM
Troy Terwilliger
is 12% done
Where does intent come from? To have true free will over your intent, you would have to consciously choose what you are about to intend. But to choose that, you would have to intend to choose it—requiring an infinite regress of prior intentions. By showing that intent is an effect, not an uncaused cause, he closes the door on the idea that human choice operates outside the physical laws of nature.
— Nov 14, 2026 11:23AM

