Starlight’s Reviews > The Earl’s Timely Wallflower > Status Update
Starlight
is 92% done
the mmc was written to have a past as kind of a manwhore
of his time
but seriously
i hate reading shit like that
esp in a supposed fucking romance book
nothing about him was interesting or likeable
same with the fmc
who was and is a fucking bore
so they deserve each other ig
the proclamations of love so soon was unbelievable
the lust even more so
i did not enjoy the smut this time around
— Jul 04, 2026 09:58AM
of his time
but seriously
i hate reading shit like that
esp in a supposed fucking romance book
nothing about him was interesting or likeable
same with the fmc
who was and is a fucking bore
so they deserve each other ig
the proclamations of love so soon was unbelievable
the lust even more so
i did not enjoy the smut this time around
Like flag
Starlight’s Previous Updates
Starlight
is 92% done
i think i only noted it the first time reading bc it was just so sudden in this type of genre and setting
on top of the shitty writing that added to the shit plot
at the same time taking me the fuck out of the story with how poorly this regency trope was done
i cant even rn
i have more to rant about this stupid ass book but id rather forget it all asap
— Jul 04, 2026 10:00AM
on top of the shitty writing that added to the shit plot
at the same time taking me the fuck out of the story with how poorly this regency trope was done
i cant even rn
i have more to rant about this stupid ass book but id rather forget it all asap
Starlight
is 92% done
i hated all the other little side characters
besides christian-the shy clockmaker bestfriend of the mmc
and the mmc of the next book i think
violet the sister of mmc was fine if stupid at first
but she got better after she finally got to punch someone
that other woman
the mmcs mistress(ex)
was a fucking weasel and a half and she didnt get the beat down she deserves
— Jul 04, 2026 09:56AM
besides christian-the shy clockmaker bestfriend of the mmc
and the mmc of the next book i think
violet the sister of mmc was fine if stupid at first
but she got better after she finally got to punch someone
that other woman
the mmcs mistress(ex)
was a fucking weasel and a half and she didnt get the beat down she deserves
Starlight
is 90% done
i apparently rated this book two stars the first time around
ill be changing it to one star
.
the note i have next to the digital book said (meh) 🌶️
ive deleted that and replaced it with 👎
so yeah i kind of hated this story and everyone it it
besides-the old steward Reginald
and he was BARELY in it
save for some snarky remarks and behaviors i appreciated
let the man smack a bitch
— Jul 04, 2026 09:54AM
ill be changing it to one star
.
the note i have next to the digital book said (meh) 🌶️
ive deleted that and replaced it with 👎
so yeah i kind of hated this story and everyone it it
besides-the old steward Reginald
and he was BARELY in it
save for some snarky remarks and behaviors i appreciated
let the man smack a bitch
Starlight
is 18% done
^especially when he’s thinking of them as being more beautiful and cultured than this fmc
not to mention
the quick skin ship between them
ruins the whole regency vibe
i cant stand this fmc
nor her/the
typical denial and realization of being stranded in the past
esp when theyre fucking stupid about it all
also
her low opinion of her own family already sours the next two books of theirs
— Jul 04, 2026 01:56AM
not to mention
the quick skin ship between them
ruins the whole regency vibe
i cant stand this fmc
nor her/the
typical denial and realization of being stranded in the past
esp when theyre fucking stupid about it all
also
her low opinion of her own family already sours the next two books of theirs
Starlight
is 18% done
this is a reread
just so i can finally finish the damn series thats been sitting in my digital library
i dont like it so far
not the fmcs pathetic little life she constantly whines about
and not the mmc repeatedly thinking of other woman
his past lovers or other woman drama to come i dont recall
i dont want to read about an mmc comparing the fmc to his past fuck buddies
— Jul 04, 2026 01:54AM
just so i can finally finish the damn series thats been sitting in my digital library
i dont like it so far
not the fmcs pathetic little life she constantly whines about
and not the mmc repeatedly thinking of other woman
his past lovers or other woman drama to come i dont recall
i dont want to read about an mmc comparing the fmc to his past fuck buddies
Starlight
is 90% done
meh
repetitive
not exactly cliffhangers or unresolved shit
it was just so unsatisfying how everything turned out
i wanted that bitch ow ruined
whatever
i guess i’ll have to read the next two books
— Aug 31, 2025 11:54AM
repetitive
not exactly cliffhangers or unresolved shit
it was just so unsatisfying how everything turned out
i wanted that bitch ow ruined
whatever
i guess i’ll have to read the next two books