Dirk’s Reviews > The Fellowship of the Ring > Status Update
Like flag
Dirk’s Previous Updates
Dirk
is finished
Why do I feel so familiar. Had read the book only 4 or fife times now.
And yes there are still some spots I do not remember.
The movie is also interrupting the memory of the book. One point in the halls of Moria where the one of the hobbits is throwing a stone down the pit doesn’t compare to the film. Or better the film changed the scene.
So the book is the source of all. All fantasy goes back to LOR.
— Jun 29, 2025 03:47AM
And yes there are still some spots I do not remember.
The movie is also interrupting the memory of the book. One point in the halls of Moria where the one of the hobbits is throwing a stone down the pit doesn’t compare to the film. Or better the film changed the scene.
So the book is the source of all. All fantasy goes back to LOR.
Dirk
is on page 172 of 398
Tom Bombadil. Sorry
He never was in the film. Should have been some really great part. I love him and his art.
— Jun 05, 2025 10:16PM
He never was in the film. Should have been some really great part. I love him and his art.
Dirk
is on page 45 of 398
As time flew by. My last read was nearly 15 years ago. But running over the pages is like coming home. The story and the characters are like old friends. And still there are some questions. Where had Gandalf been in all the years. How had Frodo survived without money.
— May 26, 2025 04:40AM

