Status Updates From Montana 1948
Montana 1948 by
Status Updates Showing 1-30 of 7,550
Jay Kang
is on page 25 of 186
Watson spends the first pages of the book describing the setting of Montana. David describes Bentrock, Mercer County as dry, sparse, very windy, and a small town. Watson's intent in depicting the setting is to form an image for the Hayden family to grasp power and fame. David mentions that his family has power as sheriffs, like how is father "is the law" and how his grandfather was able to control sheriff elections.
— 1 minute ago
Add a comment
Angelo Chu
is on page 24 of 182
In the beginning of the book, David narrates about the books setting, his dad's job, and when a Sioux woman named Marie who is their family's housekeeper falling ill. What intrigued me was when Marie was told that Dr. Hayden who is David's uncle, she frantically tried to refuse treatment from Dr. hayden. My prediction is that the author is showing Marie's reluctance to guide the story to a conflict between the two.
— 8 minutes ago
Add a comment
Maxwell Mullins
is on page 81 of 186
This part of the book made me feel sad for David because now he is dealing with someone he really cared about dying. He also saw his uncle for teh first time after the incident, and he was trying to block it out of his mind, but he really couldn't. I wonder if later in teh book we find out Uncle Frank poisoned Marie so she couldn't tell them what happened.
— 11 minutes ago
Add a comment
Talbot Sheldon
is on page 43 of 186
I find it very interesting that the people in the town see uncle Frank as a very good person and a hero in the town. But when they find out what he has been doing they find it hard to see that like when Wes heard that his brother has been doing that he says "And you believe her." Wes is in total shock and same with David because they cant believe he would do something like that.
— 11 minutes ago
Add a comment
JJ Cheung
is on page 78 of 186
I’m glad Wesley is finally investigating instead of staying passive like earlier, though seeing Grandpa Julian’s strong influence makes me nervous about how this will go. Even with Wesley talking to Ollie Young Bear, his choice to question Marie alone leaves me unsure, is he actually trying to get the truth, or still protecting his brother?
— 15 minutes ago
Add a comment
Leo Tao
is on page 32 of 186
Watson shows David vividly recalling the events during his childhood, but now he’s grown up. He’s trying to tell the story accurately, but can’t stop his own perspective of it from showing up in his narration, which may influence the readers too. This makes the story more compelling by offering a view to compare with your own. The reader can see David’s viewpoint, reflect on his interpretation, and make their own.
— 41 minutes ago
Add a comment
Antonio Quiroga
is on page 60 of 186
I am concerned about the family gathering that's about to happen. Considering that we don't know Uncle Frank's true reason behind his grotesque actions, in the worst case, he could molest David. Gail clearly said she doesn't want Uncle Frank close to David, which I think is a way for the author to foreshadow that something dreadful might happen.
— 45 minutes ago
Add a comment
Andrew Ames
is on page 11 of 186
Larry Watson portrays Wes Hayden in an interesting way that makes the reader feel sympathy. He shows in the first pages, that his entire family thinks he should be doing something different in his life or be someone else. I think that Watson is describing this character this way because he will get torn between two worlds. Later in the book, I think he will have to make a difficult choice between those two sides.
— 3 hours, 36 min ago
Add a comment
Reader
is on page 76 of 182
David's observations and personality are truly insightful considering his age, and I remain impressed—particularly when he contemplates the felled magpie. In a twist of fate that disputes my earlier prediction, Wesley does confront Frank. Interestingly, though, he asks him as a brother as opposed to a sheriff. This resolves the conflict for now, assuming Frank ceases his actions—though personally I believe he won't.
— 3 hours, 42 min ago
Add a comment
Andrew Gochman
is on page 23 of 186
These couple pages were a lot, but one thing that caught my eye was how much David cared about Marie. David kept walking around the house making sure she will be ok. The big thing for me was the role reversal, Marie was hired as a house keeper/babysitter for David but at this point in time his dad said "I Hear you baby sitting the baby sitter." This gives us another look at how those roles have been reversed
— 3 hours, 52 min ago
Add a comment
Dylan Chen
is on page 65 of 186
Watson uses heavy silence to embody buried family secrets and the censorship that shuts David out of the conversations the adults have. Even the muted radio mirrors Marie present in the room, yet silenced by power, not being able to speak up and stand for herself. Another symbol used by Watson is the wind and dirt, which represent the spread of rumors and the "dirty things" that are being spread throughout Montana.
— 6 hours, 14 min ago
Add a comment
Morgan Mai
is on page 66 of 186
I was surprised at how the white residents praised Ollie Young Bear as a “war hero” only because he complied with their standards. But they still view the rest of the Sioux community with bias. I realize that the town’s respect is dependent and racist towards others, and it is hard for other groups to gain acceptance in the community without losing their identity. I wonder how this will affect Marie's accusations.
— 6 hours, 16 min ago
Add a comment
Niklas Tahvanainen
is finished
I hope what Klotey said in class isn't really true and if the book is actually going to turn into a murder mystery. Larry Watson is a great writer, he makes the reader want to read more, by revealing secrets about Frank and the Hayden family. He makes David's role realistic by imagining things are right or wrong, since he is 12. I hope that Marie doesn’t actually die since she is one of my favourite characters.
— 8 hours, 12 min ago
Add a comment
Constantino Laborin
is on page 54 of 186
Larry Watsons writing is very important in this part of the book because its is hinting at something bigger for the midpoint of the story from Davids perspective. He is purposefully writing from a kids point of view on very delicate subjects because a a kid would see things differently than an adult. David sees it in black and white where Wes would see it in grey.
— 8 hours, 19 min ago
Add a comment
Kameron Clarke
is on page 57 of 186
The boy kills a bird and says that it is not the first time that he killed something or the last. I really think that the boy might kill somebody in the book. The foreshadowing is scary. I hope it does not mean that he will kill a human. I might even think that the disgust for his uncle that he has might lead him to even hurt him because that might be the only way his ways will stop uncle Frank.
— 8 hours, 20 min ago
Add a comment
Coleman Martin
is finished
The author writes Frank's mannerisms as very suspicious, and this makes me wonder if he killed Marie. When Wes says, “Does anyone else know?” The author is making Wes seem desperate so he could decide whether to stay loyal to family or the law. It is hard for Wes to make a decision based on a 12-year-old witness. I also think that Watson made Len know so that the information could get out and everyone would know.
— 8 hours, 23 min ago
Add a comment
Ethan Dutton
is on page 63 of 194
David listens to a conversation and hears what uncle Frank is accused of is true. I think this will change the way he thinks of his uncle. The author added the fact that he heard the conversation in order to promote foreshadowing into how David will change his opinion on his uncle.
— 8 hours, 32 min ago
Add a comment
Constantino Laborin
is on page 54 of 186
larry watsons writing is very important in this part of the book because its when uncle frank is getting cougth by marian and how he raped the native american girls and it is hinting at something bigger
— 8 hours, 36 min ago
Add a comment
Michael Bao
is on page 61 of 186
It's surprising that David can follow his father's investigation into Marie's accusation against his uncle despite his young age. I wonder if Wesley started to doubt his previous thoughts about his brother, Frank. Marie's description of Ollie as a Native American who won't be happy until he's fully white made me question how hard it is to maintain your cultural identity within the two communities he's living in.
— 9 hours, 3 min ago
Add a comment
Thomas Tanglertsumphun
is on page 35 of 186
The author includes the theme of justice vs. law as Wes faces a battle between his occupation and his own values. As the story develops, Uncle Frank is introduced. The picture the author has written creates suspense as Frank is accused of sexual harassment by Gail, who is defending the Native American caretaker, Marie. I believe Wes will have to choose between his own morals about his brother and the written law.
— 9 hours, 3 min ago
Add a comment
Gerardo Gonzalez
is on page 30 of 186
I find it crazy when the father refuses to not bring the doctor, even though Marie shouts for no doctor. I wonder if this has to do with his racism or if he is part of the problem with his brother. I can't help but ask: what did the doctor do to her? Did he rape her, or did he beat her? The book surprises me every day, and I feel like the dad has something to do with it, and he is turning a blind eye for his brother
— 10 hours, 23 min ago
Add a comment
Jihwan Park
is on page 15 of 186
Watson implies David’s father became sheriff through his father’s influence. Although studying to become an attorney, he abandoned this to inherit his father’s duty as sheriff. This suggests the authority his father held over him. Through this, Watson once again contrasts David’s desire to leave the town and to be himself, and his father’s conformity to explore how family expectation can influence one’s identity.
— 10 hours, 42 min ago
Add a comment
Shotaro Tsunoi
is on page 70 of 186
Given how invested and observant David is regarding his uncle's crime and past, I wonder if he will be the first to uncover the truth. I also wonder how he might become officially involved in the investigation alongside his father, the sheriff. I am very impressed by David's maturity; I see a 12-year-old as someone who is very naive about the world, but David seems to me to resemble his father, the sheriff.
— 12 hours, 2 min ago
Add a comment
Read Mortimer
is on page 72 of 186
I am completely shocked by what I have just read. This evidence, discovered with the help of the Grandfather, has made me despise Frank. Hopefully, this is enough for Wesley to arrest Frank. I do also wonder what happened in the conversation between Uncle Frank and Wesley by the river? What did they agree on? On the other hand, I wonder how long this loss of Marie will affect the family?
— 21 hours, 43 min ago
Add a comment
Reader
is on page 63 of 182
It seems possible—or even likely—that something will happen to Marie Little Soldier while David's family is gone. Even with Daisy there, the wording the author uses to frame the situation feels too ambiguous. Even more troubling, in response to my previous query, David's father opts not to tell his own father about the allegations regarding Frank. This leads me to believe he won't confront Frank—at least not yet.
— 21 hours, 49 min ago
Add a comment
Leon Chen
is on page 52 of 186
The radio mentioned at the start of page 52 is a symbol for Marie. David narrates that she always turns the radio on when she is there, but now the house is silent, showing an obvious impact of her sickness. My sentence is weirdly worded, what I mean is that the radio being off is something that someone could easily notice, unlike if David was depressed because Marie is sick.
— 22 hours, 5 min ago
Add a comment
Jude Afari
is on page 30 of 186
The author showcases Uncle Frank as this great achieving person to set up the story. Uncle Frank is even the favorite son. He wants to show how important Uncle Frank is going to be for the story. Everyone sees Uncle Frank as a great person, a star. But is he really a good person? The author shows how scared Marie gets at the mention of his name. This leaves me wondering whether Uncle Frank is a good person or not.
— 22 hours, 17 min ago
Add a comment
Ian Lee
is on page 59 of 182
I genuinely enjoy how the book conveys emotions through subtext and silence instead of explicitly stating how the character feels. I also appreciate how easy the subtext is to digest, since I usually have a hard time understanding deeper meaning in writing. My favorite example was when the mother talked about the wind to show her discomfort with her son questioning her about Uncle Frank.
— 22 hours, 18 min ago
Add a comment
Jeronimo Mancebo
is on page 18 of 182
David's family plays a huge role in the novel, and I noticed how much Watson focuses on each family member. I find it interesting how their personalities and relationships shape David's view of people. I think Watson wants to show how family influences our beliefs and decisions. Since David tells the story, we see his family through his eyes, making me wonder how they will shape his understanding of the world.
— 22 hours, 18 min ago
Add a comment
JJ Cheung
is on page 62 of 186
Watching David’s image of Uncle Frank fall apart in these pages felt pretty big. What frustrates me most is realizing that Wesley actually knows Frank is guilty, yet he still avoids conflict instead of stepping up, just like how I noticed in my earlier updates. Seeing David lose trust in his family makes me wonder how this will change him.
— 22 hours, 20 min ago
Add a comment



