Status Updates From Montana 1948

Montana 1948 Montana 1948
by


Status Updates Showing 1-30 of 7,529

order by

Jihwan Park
Jihwan Park is on page 15 of 186
Watson implies David’s father became sheriff through his father’s influence. Although studying to become an attorney, he abandoned this to inherit his father’s duty as sheriff. This suggests the authority his father held over him. Through this, Watson once again contrasts David’s desire to leave the town and to be himself, and his father’s conformity to explore how family expectation can influence one’s identity.
— 0 minutes ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Shotaro Tsunoi
Shotaro Tsunoi is on page 70 of 186
Given how invested and observant David is regarding his uncle's crime and past, I wonder if he will be the first to uncover the truth. I also wonder how he might become officially involved in the investigation alongside his father, the sheriff. I am very impressed by David's maturity; I see a 12-year-old as someone who is very naive about the world, but David seems to me to resemble his father, the sheriff.
— 1 hour, 21 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Read Mortimer
Read Mortimer is on page 72 of 186
I am completely shocked by what I have just read. This evidence, discovered with the help of the Grandfather, has made me despise Frank. Hopefully, this is enough for Wesley to arrest Frank. I do also wonder what happened in the conversation between Uncle Frank and Wesley by the river? What did they agree on? On the other hand, I wonder how long this loss of Marie will affect the family?
— 11 hours, 1 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Reader
Reader is on page 63 of 182
It seems possible—or even likely—that something will happen to Marie Little Soldier while David's family is gone. Even with Daisy there, the wording the author uses to frame the situation feels too ambiguous. Even more troubling, in response to my previous query, David's father opts not to tell his own father about the allegations regarding Frank. This leads me to believe he won't confront Frank—at least not yet.
— 11 hours, 7 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Leon Chen
Leon Chen is on page 52 of 186
The radio mentioned at the start of page 52 is a symbol for Marie. David narrates that she always turns the radio on when she is there, but now the house is silent, showing an obvious impact of her sickness. My sentence is weirdly worded, what I mean is that the radio being off is something that someone could easily notice, unlike if David was depressed because Marie is sick.
— 11 hours, 23 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Jude Afari
Jude Afari is on page 30 of 186
The author showcases Uncle Frank as this great achieving person to set up the story. Uncle Frank is even the favorite son. He wants to show how important Uncle Frank is going to be for the story. Everyone sees Uncle Frank as a great person, a star. But is he really a good person? The author shows how scared Marie gets at the mention of his name. This leaves me wondering whether Uncle Frank is a good person or not.
— 11 hours, 35 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Ian Lee
Ian Lee is on page 59 of 182
I genuinely enjoy how the book conveys emotions through subtext and silence instead of explicitly stating how the character feels. I also appreciate how easy the subtext is to digest, since I usually have a hard time understanding deeper meaning in writing. My favorite example was when the mother talked about the wind to show her discomfort with her son questioning her about Uncle Frank.
— 11 hours, 36 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Jeronimo Mancebo
Jeronimo Mancebo is on page 18 of 182
David's family plays a huge role in the novel, and I noticed how much Watson focuses on each family member. I find it interesting how their personalities and relationships shape David's view of people. I think Watson wants to show how family influences our beliefs and decisions. Since David tells the story, we see his family through his eyes, making me wonder how they will shape his understanding of the world.
— 11 hours, 36 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

JJ Cheung
JJ Cheung is on page 62 of 186
Watching David’s image of Uncle Frank fall apart in these pages felt pretty big. What frustrates me most is realizing that Wesley actually knows Frank is guilty, yet he still avoids conflict instead of stepping up, just like how I noticed in my earlier updates. Seeing David lose trust in his family makes me wonder how this will change him.
— 11 hours, 38 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

JJ Cheung
JJ Cheung is on page 62 of 186
Watching David’s image of Uncle Frank fall apart in these pages felt pretty big. What frustrates me most is realizing that Wesley actually knows Frank is guilty, yet he still avoids conflict instead of stepping up, just like how I noticed in my earlier. Seeing David lose trust in his family makes me wonder how this will change him.
— 11 hours, 44 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Benjamin Ficek
Benjamin Ficek is on page 22 of 186
Why does the David's father not like Indians, and holds them to a low regard? The author is manipulating the story by making David's father not feeling for Marie Little Soldier, like the normal person would and is being superstitious. He doesn't think much about Marie Little Soldier, when she is a maid for the family, and takes care of everyone in the family. Is that the low regard that the author is talking about?
— 11 hours, 48 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Austin Zheng
Austin Zheng is on page 24 of 186
Larry Watson built a comparison between Wes and Frank. Frank, being a war hero and charming doctor, has everything Wes has and more, while Wes was put in as the sheriff by his dad. But beneath this appearance, why doesn’t Marie want Frank to come when she’s sick? Why does she ask for Dr. Snow and seems to be afraid of Frank? Larry is implying that appearances can be deceiving. Frank is not who people think he is.
— 11 hours, 56 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Jaxon McNamara
Jaxon McNamara is on page 60 of 186
Something that I believe was important in this part of the story was when the father told David and his mother to go on a walk so he could talk to Marie for what I suppose was about what she said about his brother. When they are outside, David's mother is consumed in the wind as it reminds her of her hometown. I wonder if the father actually questioned Marie on what she said about his brother or if he threatened her.
— 12 hours, 21 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Angel Genaro
Angel Genaro is on page 60 of 194
After reading 17 pages I am getting a better understanding than before. On page 68 the author states that " Why would Uncle Frank want another woman when he had a wife like Gloria?" Which I agree with because Gloria seems like a really sweet person. I would want Gloria as a mother or a aunt in this case. Do you think that Gloria didn't want to have sex with Uncle Frank which is making him rape Native American girls.
— 12 hours, 24 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Nathan Gao
Nathan Gao is on page 12 of 186
I was hooked by the author's use of pace and perspective. Opening with haunting images hooks the reader with dread, then slows down into introducing the family. That contrast forces you to read between the lines for insights on the upcoming conflict. I foresee David and Gail pulling Wesley towards a new life away from Montana. Setting up a major conflict between Wesley's heritage and the family's future.
— 12 hours, 35 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Griffin Watts
Griffin Watts is on page 77 of 186
I would have been painfully surprised if Marie's death was not spoiled. But some of my wonders about Frank and Wesley's relationship. When Wesley let frank get off with a stern talking to that helped me understand their relationship. We also got so see Davids perspective. He brought up killing Frank. I think he feels this way because of the information he is aware to. I wonder what Frank's conversation leads to.
— 12 hours, 38 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Omar Kuri
Omar Kuri is on page 75 of 186
It was interesting when David pointed a gun at Frank. I think the author is trying to show how, in that moment, David realized that his dad's job was not as easy as it seemed, and it made him rethink the labels he had on his dad for being lame, for not carrying his gun or not doing the things that seemed cool to him. This makes me wonder whether David will have more respect for his dad moving forward.
— 12 hours, 40 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Jay Kang
Jay Kang is on page 11 of 186
The book's prologue intrigued me. In the prologue, the narrator compares his father’s begging voice to an insect, insistent and frantic. This image shrinks a sheriff, a man in the 1940s with power in the town, into someone weak. I believe Watson uses this role reversal to show the narrator’s shock at seeing his father powerless and to hint the readers about the conflicts the narrator might face later in the story.​
— 12 hours, 48 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Kameron Clarke
Kameron Clarke is on page 53 of 186
We find out from the grandfather that uncle frank has a thing native american women. I wonder if Frank is going to have big problems with his wife or even leave her because he has a thing for women of that race. I also wonder if he does not pursue them because his father would never approve of him doing that. I really think it might be his fathers fault because he was suppressed and forced to do it in secret.
— 12 hours, 57 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Joseph Clottey
Joseph Clottey is on page 80 of 186
David wants his parents to treat him like an adult and tell him what is really happening, but his mother keeps avoiding the details. I think he is learning that growing up means facing things he may not be ready to hear. Why do adults think keeping children in the dark always protects them?
— 13 hours, 9 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Coleman Martin
Coleman Martin is finished
After Wes confronts Frank about having affairs with the native americans, Frank says that he will stop doing it. I do not think Frank will stop doing it because he is probably already addicted, and I just don't trust him. Then, when Marie dies it increases the tension between Wes and his brother. I think the author had Marie die so that David could learn to persevere through tough times and maybe become more mature.
— 13 hours, 10 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948 (Paperback, 2007)

Poon Promphan
Poon Promphan is on page 11 of 186
So far I like how the author has introduced how the father became and a sheriff as well as how his wife doesn't seem to like the idea of it very much. The author also showed how the main character like to go outdoors but is held back by his dad's job as the sheriff in Montana. This could lead to a conflict in the future since the mom wants her son to be able to go outdoors and explore but is held back by the dad.
— 13 hours, 17 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Victor Sweeny
Victor Sweeny is on page 29 of 186
Page 29 is a hard read for me. Even though this is a fictional novel, it is still emotionally challenging to read about Marie yelling "no" when Uncle Frank is alone with her. Even more challenging is the fact that David and Wes both clearly hear Marie, but do not help. The author does an impressive job of grabbing my attention and engaging me in the novel by using this unfortunate event.
— 13 hours, 28 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Jaxon Wolterding
Jaxon Wolterding is on page 31 of 186
"I'm not concerned about social progress. I'm worried they're not going to survive measles" (31)

Why does the father seem more worried about the sickness than the idea of social progress? What does this reveal about what he believes is seriously going wrong in this situation.

What does it mean by survive measles?
— 13 hours, 30 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Junyoung Jang
Junyoung Jang is on page 58 of 186
As I read this book more and more, I think David is somehow both smart and innocent. Using both his cleverness and naivety, David questions and notices what readers would wonder about. I noticed that Watson shows the limits of Indians, as Ollie is the most respected and loved Indian by the people; however, his personality reflects the reality of Indians. I wonder if Marie's silence foreshadows trouble in the future.
— 15 hours, 2 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

James Underhill
James Underhill is on page 12 of 186
The author writes about David's dad and how he was kicked by a horse when he was 16. This lead me to believe that the reason his dad is a sheriff and not serving his country is because he can't walk. His dad may be so miserable because he could have dreamed of serving his country but his dreams were crushed by a horses leg. I believe that the author is providing the reader with a reason why his dad is a sheriff.
— 15 hours, 15 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Liam Tith
Liam Tith is on page 24 of 186
Larry Watson uses David's childhood memory to show how much the summer of 1948 shaped him. He compared Grandpa Julians loud, egotistical personality with Gails quiet criticism which showed to me the tension within the family, the way that Larry states the towns view on the Hayden family brings up the misuse of power and privilege in a small town. All while the family itself has experienced issues they haven't fixed.
— 15 hours, 15 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Cayden LeRoy
Cayden LeRoy is on page 24 of 186
Something about the way Hayden introduces Uncle Frank leaves an unsettling vibe in the novel. The narrator introduces Frank to Marie as if he is going to help her sickness but, does Frank want to cure or maniuplate her? The suspicion of various characters in this novel makes the reader anticipate but also wonder, are there more parts to the story that aren't being told? Time will tell Frank's intentions and secrets.
— 15 hours, 21 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Shuchen Wang
Shuchen Wang is on page 30 of 186
Larry Watson is describing a scene where David's family housekeeper Marie was sick and her fierce action of refusing to help from the doctor which is David's dad / Wesley's brother. The author wrote this to emphasize the stereotype David's dad has about Indian people for how he thinks the reason why Marie does not want to see the doctor is because she never met an actual doctor before but only tribal medicine men.
— 16 hours, 10 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

Shuchen Wang
Shuchen Wang is on page 15 of 186
Larry Watson is describing a scene where David's family housekeeper Marie was sick and her fierce action of refusing to help from the doctor which is David's dad / Wesley's brother. The author wrote this to emphasize the stereotype David's dad has about Indian people for how he thinks the reason why Marie does not want to see the doctor is because she never met an actual doctor before but only tribal medicine men.
— 16 hours, 12 min ago Add a comment
Montana 1948

« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 … 99 100