Mockingjay
discussion
Now That You've Read the Whole Series....
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Elizabeth
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Aug 17, 2012 09:23PM
Now that you've read the whole Hunger Games Trilogy, which one is your favorite? Mine is either The Hunger Games or Catching Fire.
reply
|
flag
Mine is either The Hunger Games of Mockingjay.
Definitely The Hunger Games!
I love the first two books, but I guess if I had to pick one it would be catching fire.
Its a close call between Hunger Games and Catching FIre. Catching Fire would have to be my favorite.
Hunger Games is a promising first book and the second book is even better so I guess it's Catching Fire.
the catching fire definitely, because it has the best scenes I've ever encountered on those 3 books. and also because finnick Odair showed up there. haha
Mockingjay but they are all great books
got the dvd last night! i've never seen it before so I'm excited to watch it!
It's hard to choose from the first two (I didn't really like mockingjay too much) but if I had to choose....umm...Catching Fire just because of Finnick <3
I loved Mockingjay. They are all great books but this one felt more mature and somehow real. It was a civil war as the really are. The rebel leaders were no heroes, the soldiers were, even reluctantly. And it made me cry a lot (oh Peeta... Johanna.. Katniss... Prim!) but the ending was very hopeful that a good future can grow over all the misery. It's not a very like able book and sometimes it is hard to take but nonetheless I believe it's a great one and it carries an important analysis on civil wars, hero figures and propaganda.
Close call between the first two.
The Hunger Games
The series is amazing but I would have two say the first book
Hunger Games for me. Eventho I like Catching Fire. It was pretty amazing, but at the same time it also felt like 'hey we've been here before'. But the Clock thing was pretty amazing to read. Mockingjay kind of lost me a little, but it has great shock value. Left me speechless at points. I'm not really in to the progaganda type of things, I think that's why it appealed a little less.But it's a trilogy everyone just NEEDS to read ;)
It's hard to decide, but I think Catching Fire and Hunger Games. Mockingjay is too sad, but I love it anyway.
The Hunger GamesIt just caught me the most, I mean, I read it in like eight hours, where the others were good too, but I didn't find it hard putting them down.
Wasn't crazy about last book (perhaps cuz I hated the ending). Thought 2d book was transitional - no real story (matrix 2 movie came to mind). So I guess the first book.
I thought the first was the most captivating and the second was a mind twister. I really disliked the third because I felt like it dragged on for a little and then I was left disappointed.
Definitely 'Catching Fire' for me 'cause I think that was when Katniss realized that she really cared about Peeta (and maybe fell for him too!!)
I like them all equally ik that sounds rly cheesy but i do
Catching Fire, definitely!
The first half of Catching Fire, when she knows what she's doing in the games.I hated the last book. It felt like the whole message was "everyone sucks, don't even bother".
Catching Fire! Because she sees that she could love Peeta. And you see more of Gail and her family.
I liked all three. U really cannot have one without the other two.
Catching Fire! i just love Finnick <3 The first one was just as good, but the third one was really disappointing to me. It felt forced and it wasn't as captivating as the first two.
Hunger games was sooo amazing Catching fire was good and Mockingjay um ok I guess
My favourite would have to be mockingjay. I loved the first two but mockingjay is my favourite. Even though it was really sad I loved the ending, I loved how it suggested that maybe everyone would be able to move on to a better life now.
Definitely 'Catching Fire'!
The Hunger Games. The second and third were letdowns for me.
The Hunger Games was my favourite, the idea was brilliant, but then the second one did the same thing... and the third just left me really sad.
I loved The Hunger Games but I loved the scenes with Peeta and Katniss protecting each other from their nightmares (or rather Peeta protecting Katniss...) in CF as well. And Finnick Odair and his sugar cubes, of course...!
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
