English Mysteries Club discussion
Archive pre-2020
>
Currently Reading?
message 2051:
by
Bionic Jean
(new)
Jun 04, 2015 03:13PM

reply
|
flag


Me neither. Too twee. I think marital detectives are awfully hard to write, & if Christie was trying for a nonalcoholic Nick & stronger Nora, she didn't really pull it off.

So does anyone know of an author (particularly a golden age author) who pulled off a good husband/wife detective team?

Currently, of course, the Debora Crombie Kincaid books.



Nice idea but Christie wrote Tommy and Tuppence 12 years before Chandler invented Nick and Nora!

Nice i..."
Dashiell Hammett wrote The Thin Man in 1934 which was the first appearance of Nick and Nora. I expect most people are familar with them through the movie versions.

Hmm! Thanks, Leslie. That makes me wonder if Hammett thought T&T were an idea he could improve upon...which he did...
I always mixed up Hammett & Chandler too, until I read more Chandler & realized what a better writer he is.




I think I need a break from Sophie Hannah's favorite Christies for a while.

I think I need a break from Sophie Hannah's favorite Christies for a while."
Yes it's possible to overdose on even the most favourite author.
I'm just about to start The Clock Strikes 12 by Patricia Wentworth.


I think I need a break from Sophie Hannah's favorite Christies for a while."
Yes it's possible to overdose on even t..."
I love Patricia Wentworth, and this is a good one!

"
Oh good! Someone from another group I'm in didn't care for it. For me, so far it's fine - very Christie-ish!

I just finished listening to the audiobook of Dodger, which I found had a little bit of a mystery component to it. I wasn't sure going in how I would feel about Pratchett using Dickens but I ended up liking it.
One question -- did people in London really call the police "peelers"? I had thought that was an Irish slang... I did figure out that the term bobbies must have originated (as peelers did) as a reference to Sir Robert Peel :)



Maisie Dobbs is the main character in a series of books by Jacqueline Winspear.

I just finished listening..."
I'm trying to remember any English references to "peelers", and I can't think of any. I'll keep my eyes peeled. (Oh, boy, cracking myself up.)


Me, too, Leslie! Although I do love Miss Marple's hidden-in-fluff intelligence, I like Miss Silver's straight-out, up-front professionalism better.


Miss Marple made her appearance in a short story in December, 1927, and Miss Silver's first novel was published in 1928. Miss Marple's first actual book was 1930. Practically simultaneous!


That's so interesting. I'm assuming it's highly unlikely that Wentworth read the short story. They have both taken the conventions of the detective story & created a distinctive female sleuth.
There is a parallel now (although it's between a TV programme & a book) with The Rosie Project & Sheldon from The Big Bang theory. Lot's of similarity in the male lead & Sheldon, both both created virtually simultaneously.
& EG I was just starting to think (view spoiler)

Not yet. I'm about at the half way point!



Based on this reading I prefer Miss Silver too! I liked Miss Marple but her waffly stories sometimes got on my nerves!

Me too! I have my hands full right now with my attempt to read the Inspector Appleby books but I should reread these (and Ngaio Marsh and Margery Allingham)...


Me too! ..."
I haven't read the Inspector Appleby books. Where do I start?
I've recently read my first Ngaio Marsh and enjoyed it. As soon as I manage to hand back the other 6 books that I borrowed from my mother, I'll continue with the series since she has most of them, but I don't want to borrow anything else at the moment.

Books mentioned in this topic
The Taken (other topics)Sherlock Holmes: Murder at the Savoy & Other Stories (other topics)
Wicked Autumn (other topics)
Cover Her Face (other topics)
A Mind to Murder (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Alice Clark-Platts (other topics)Chris Ould (other topics)
Adrian McKinty (other topics)
Will Thomas (other topics)
Anna Katharine Green (other topics)
More...