English Mysteries Club discussion
Archive pre-2020
>
Currently Reading?
message 801:
by
Ellen
(new)
Sep 22, 2013 07:17PM

reply
|
flag

Jean-Luke - I remember really enjoying those way before the films came out, but finding them surprisingly nasty in parts. Maybe they will seem tame now though!

That was my impression as well back in the early 80s.

hey Susan!!
I have thoroughly enjoyed Rickman's series. The main character is a vicar (a woman) but she is also the contact person in her area for 'ghostly' goings on!! The books all have an aura of other worldly stuff and yet that implies its sort of fantasy or slightly unbelievable and that's not the case. The mysteries are tightly woven and make sense even if there are supernatural stuff - the culprit is never a ghost!!! There's also lots of folklore and old myths woven into the stories - dont know if they are real or if Rickman makes them up but it feels right. As usual its best to start at the beginning as the stories of Merrily and her daughter and their love lives come through all the books.

Ellen I recently read the Harper's Quine too - I thought it was very good. Loved all the historical stuff and the odd Scottish phrases. Be interested to hear what the second one is like.



It is almost impossible to replicate greatness. "Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy" is a masterpiece and Smiley is one in several million.
But thanks for the suggestion. I will give this author a try.

Nicholas Feast was just as good as Harper's Quine. Some reviews I read complained about the language being hard to understand and I couldn't always make complete sense of some of the words either but it didn't stop me from making sense of the meaning in general or understanding the plot. I find the main characters really likable which is very important to me as far as staying with a series over a long period of time.

Try The Kill Artist for post Cold War espionage. It's definitely one of the better ones that I have come across recently.


That sounds like a great combination of book and locale! Plus hopefully it got you in the mood for our October Book of the Month :)

Sorry, I probably missed a message or two. What is the October book of the month? Something by Sherlock Holmes, or actually the "Hound of the Baskervilles."

October's BoTM is The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes.

"Life After Life" sounds worth looking for, Portia! I haven't read any Kate Atkinson yet, but maybe this is the one I should start with?

Joan, I didn't like Secret Asset as much as At Risk. I think that's because, although Rimington is very well positioned to write this kind of book, she's not a writer by vocation like LeCarre.


Hi,Karlyne. Kate Atkinson is a mystery/thriller writer. This is her first foray into regular (if you can call this book regular!) fiction. It is also my first Atkinson to read. What I have been hearing from fans of hers who have posted on discussions of Life After Life is to start with Case Histories. I am thinking of suggesting Case Histories sometime soon so we can all read it together.
If you get around to reading Life After Life, please let me know what you think.

Kate Atkinson has actually written 4 Jackson Brodie mysteries, 4 other novels (including Life After Life) and 1 collection of short stories. She wrote 3 of her other novels and the short story collection before starting her Jackson Brodie series.
I love all her books and only have a one novel and the short story collection to go before I've read everything she's written :-).

I will, Portia! I keep forgetting that I can check my little library's books in stock on line now, so I'll see if they have it and order it in if not!

Thanks, Jemidar. I didn't know most of that. What did you think of Life After Life. How did it compare to her other books? I've put Case Histories on my To Get List. Didn't she also write a book with Museum in the title?

Behind the Scenes at the Museum

The Jackson Brodie books are my favourites, then Life After Life & Behind the Scenes at the Museum. Personally, I think Case Histories is a good place to start :-).


Also finished



Penny,
I think the author intended for us find the characters shallow and self absorbed. I also think a lot of things in the book were satirical. Great book!


really? I obviously missed that then - can you explain a bit more? I get the shallow bit but not the satirical - who was sending up who?


I think the author was making fun of the predictability of the media. If people hadn't responded the way they did, nothing would have worked for Amy. Her plans hinged on the media and law enforcement, her parents, and Nick all doing what she knew they would. The Nancy Grace character, the mention of Dateline, all of that was sort of tongue in cheek, in my opinion. I thought there were shades of other big media stories in the book, like say the Scott Peterson case. Thing about the way the media responded to that, and then think about the book and you might see just a bit of parody.


OK maybe it doesnt cross the ocean - who is Nancy Grace, what is Dateline and who is Scott Peterson? Never heard of any of those - I did find quite a lot of references I didnt get when I was reading it - a bit annoying really !!


Penny,
I know what you mean. I read a lot of books that are British, French and German. I find myself looking things up on the web trying to find out what they are referring to.
In the US- Dateline and 48 hours mystery are hour long newsmagazine type shows that come on weekly. They highlight murder cases that are out of the ordinary and of course some of the high profile cases like the Amanda Knox trial etc.
Nancy Grace is on CNN and she also latches on to high profile cases and often tries and convicts people before they ever make it to trial. ( I'm not a fan, and she is often parodied over here) The Scott Peterson case: Scott Peterson killed his beautiful, vivacious wife who happened to be 8 months pregnant. At first when Lacey was reported missing, her parents were very openly supportive of Scott, then when the body was found, and evidence like his having a mistress came to light, they had a change of heart about old Scott. This case was horrific, but the media grabbed on and it was in the news, on Dateline, on Nancy Grace, it was made into a TV movie, books were written about it, the whole nine yards. A media spectacle in other words. I think that was the thing Gillian was kind of poking fun at.


Portia,
OMG! That lady loves to get her face on TV! I wonder what would come out if someone went snooping into her life? LOL



you made me smile Carol!!!
loved your descriptions Julie and that really made sense in relation to the book - seems Gillian Flynn was very up-to-date and topical as she wrote it. I dont think we have quite the same type of media behaviour here - yet. I must have been out of the loop for a lot of the symbolism of the book being English and yet the book still 'stood alone' enough without it - just didnt have all the nuances it would have your side of the pond. I usually dont read books if I cant find a single character I like but this kept me reading.




:) I like Heyer's mysteries & reread that last December.

Thanks for this tip, Leslie. I haven't read any Martin Beck, but oh, the Savoy!

Thanks for this tip, Leslie. I haven't read any Martin Beck, but oh, ..."
FYI, Beck is the police inspector. And Miss M - thanks, I was a bit puzzled as to how Beck was involved in a murder in England!

Thanks for this tip, Leslie. I haven't read any Martin ..."
Curses! Foiled again!


I really love this one! And since it's almost Christmas, I may have to read it again soon...


I really love this one! And ..."
I had this one on my TBR last year for a holiday read, but never got around to it. This year I made sure it at was the top of the pile. LOL

Books mentioned in this topic
The Taken (other topics)Sherlock Holmes: Murder at the Savoy & Other Stories (other topics)
Wicked Autumn (other topics)
Cover Her Face (other topics)
A Mind to Murder (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Alice Clark-Platts (other topics)Chris Ould (other topics)
Adrian McKinty (other topics)
Will Thomas (other topics)
Anna Katharine Green (other topics)
More...