Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
discussion
At what point in the series did you feel the most emotion?
message 1:
by
Emma
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Aug 03, 2012 10:12AM

reply
|
flag





Hedwig's death upset me, too. Hedwig had been there from the very beginning, Harry's friend. Oh, and I bawled when Dobby died.

Dumbledore dying right after saying "Please Severus".
Harry's walk to the forest in the last book.
Fred dying with laughter on face.
Ron returns back and finishes off the horcrux...
The moments where you laugh like when Fred and George just zoom past Umbridge..Ron's comment about Animal magnetism..and just about nearly everything till the sixth book..

Dumbledore dying right after saying "Please Severus".
Harry's walk to the forest in the last book.
Fred dying with laughter on face.
..."
Now you're making me sad.
All of the above and the moment I finished the series. I know this is not exactly a moment IN the books, but there's nothing worse than realizing it was all over.
Snape's death. :( That tore me open and left me bleeding inside.




That too. I never really liked Dobby after CoS, and found him all annoying about being free and stuff, but his demise was sooo sad.




Beginning of the second book: Harry receives birthday cards for the first time in his life and I cry for some reason :P Also the warning from Maffalda Hopkirk made me SO mad.
4th movie: like Gretchen (and though I do not have kids) Diggory's father in that scene made the death mean so much more than it ever had in the book.
Later Moody's betrayal cut me DEEEEEP.
5th book: I've never been so angry as I was reading about Umbridge, when she took their brooms especially. I was shaking with anger most of the time reading about her, I still do on rereads. I think if she were real I'd have no qualms about murdering her.
6th book: Dumbledores death I simply shut the book and went for a loong walk outside before I could come back and finish it.
Also when the family was sitting around Bill's bed and Molly and Fleur had that adorable moment and Lupin and Tonks were dating I cried all over. Also the phoenix song and then he leaves forever...
7th movie: Harry and Hermione dancing to a Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds song (be still my heart!) I cried in the theatre, it was a beautiful moment and communicated their situation so well (even though I know many don't like it)
7th book: Most overwhelming might be the dedication, the lightning bolt that told me thankyou for sticking with Harry till the end. On "end" my tears hit the page and I realized it was correct and this was the end. I was too overwhelmed to read and had to try back in an hour lol.
Then an hour later when I got to Hedwig's death I had to leave it AGAIN because it was too much (she was mad at him when she died!!) By the time we got to Moody I was alright.
-Hermione's broken heart after Ron leaves
-Ron's triumphant return
Fred's death later didn't do nearly as much as the casual mention of Lupin and Tonks side by side in the great hall.
Finally like most of you said, The Forest Again, even though I was already crying I was actually sobbing while Harry walked over and kissed the snitch, when he summoned his parents and finally someone told him they were proud and he was doing right by the world and all he could ask, here at the end of it all, was the incredibly childlike question to his mum of "does it hurt" I couldn't even SEE the words after that. It reminded me that Harry, though a hero, is still so very young.

i cried like baby when Harry asked his parents "Does it hurt?" referring to death. It is by faaaaar the most emotional part ever.. he is still a child! he doesn't have to die!!

i cried like baby when Harry asked his parents "Does it hurt?" referring to death. It is by faaaaar the most emotional part ever.. he is still a child! he doesn't have to die!!"
Just thinking about it makes me want to blubber all over and I know how it ends. I have to say this is the most emotionally charged ending to any book or series I've ever encountered and I do read quite a lot.

in every harry potter book, i shed tears especially when I closed the last book.




Agreed...You actually feel as if you are doing it and simultaneously extremely proud of Harry doing it..well, if you know what I mean..!!!

The whole series had a different feeling when Voldemort returned in GoF.
I think the saddest moment for me was either Sirius' death or Snape's memories. I'm not sure when I cried more (and I usually don't cry while reading)
I think the saddest moment for me was either Sirius' death or Snape's memories. I'm not sure when I cried more (and I usually don't cry while reading)
When Lupin and Tonks died. I cried. That was so uncool.

Hit the nail on the head with that one! Forgot about it. Harry and Molly were always interesting, and I loved how badly she needed to mother him even though she wasn't really allowed to be his guardian.

Sirius is one of my most favourite characters and I was so sorry that he had to die.

It just has to be when Harry goes into the Great Hall and discovers just how many died in his name. I think I really started the sob-a-ton when we discovered the fate of Lupin and Tonks.


Gosh, it was emotional because that was when it hit me that Harry Potter was really ending. That there will be no book 8. That the story was about to end. You could feel it in the air as you read through that chapter. I felt a strong pang of loss in my heart... like someone just broke up with me.

Oh yeah, that was the first time I got my eyes watery, when the Nimbus was destroyed, especially because it said something like it was like a friend to Harry and he did not want to throw the pieces out.



You know, the thing about Hermione and her parents didn't hit me nearly as hard in the book as in the movie, that scene was gorgeous and heartbreaking! I cried right away lol.
And yeah, I felt soooo intense all the time while reading about them camping out, I distinctly remember 7 in the morning still reading the book since I got home from the midnight release I desperately had to pee but everything was so scary and intense that I felt like I would be ambushed the instant I opened my bedroom door.
And then another one no one mentioned was the heartbreaking puppy-like faith all the DA members had in Harry when he turned up again and how baffled he was by it. And how fiercly McGonnagle reacted to his return and then how fiercly she protected him...
Damn I might have to read DH again...
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows (other topics)Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows (other topics)