The Next Best Book Club discussion

275 views
Angela's Shelf-A-Thon Challenge > Shelf-a-Thon 13 Reporting

Comments Showing 51-100 of 144 (144 new)    post a comment »

message 51: by Rebecca NJ (new)

Rebecca NJ (njreader) | 425 comments Standings as of August 31st:

Lori - 217 shelves; 11 books
Adrienne - 189 shelves; 8 books
Cherie - 185 shelves; 8 books
Rebecca - 155 shelves; 8 books
Kari - 131 shelves; 14 books
Pinar - 130 shelves; 5 books
Jessica - 123 shelves; 5 books
Heather - 121 shelves; 3 book
Adele - 119 shelves; 6 books
Tori - 104 shelves; 2 books
Pigletto - 70 shelves; 1 book
Mary - 64 shelves; 2 books
Kim L - 3 shelves; 0 books

Lori, Adrienne, and Cherie can each cross off three extra shelves for being top shelvers!

Adele, Mary, and Kari can each cross off two shelves.

Again, if there is an error, please let me know.


message 52: by Rebecca NJ (last edited Sep 01, 2012 07:37PM) (new)

Rebecca NJ (njreader) | 425 comments 15 books
210 shelves

Book 10: GR author, crossed off culture
Book 11: GR author, crossed off military
Book 15: GR author, crossed off not


message 53: by Heather (Heatso) (new)

Heather (Heatso) (hyperweather) | 7 comments 4 books
135 shelves


message 54: by Adele (new)

Adele Symonds (adelesymonds) | 34 comments Thanks Rebecca, I will cross off comics and graphic-novels


message 55: by Adele (new)

Adele Symonds (adelesymonds) | 34 comments 7 Books
139 shelves

book 7 GR author - 'youth'


message 56: by Hanne (last edited Sep 02, 2012 02:16AM) (new)

Hanne (hanne2) hi everyone
Just discovered the shelf-a-ton, so counted the books i had already read in august. (This has been quite fun, although i have been amazed how some people classify their books :s)

Read so far:
4 books - 103 shelves

Additional shelves (not counted above yet, so i guess 114 in total)
Goodreads author: 1 - crossed off self-help
Pages 400-499: 1 - crossed off mystery-suspense
Pages 500-599: 1 - crossed off mystery-thriller; philosophy
Pages 600-699: 1 - crossed off short-stories, sociology, theology
Pages 700-799: 1 - crossed off graphic-novel, graphic-novels; indonesia; manga


message 57: by [deleted user] (new)

Hanne wrote: "hi everyone
Just discovered the shelf-a-ton, so counted the books i had already read in august. (This has been quite fun, although i have been amazed how some people classify their books"


Someone classified one of the classics I read as Sci-Fi...I can't imagine how they got that!


message 58: by [deleted user] (last edited Sep 02, 2012 05:33AM) (new)

Thanks Rebecca!

Crossing off "signed", "need-to-get", and "print"

12 books
229 shelves


message 59: by Mary (new)

Mary (attorneymom) Thanks!

Crossing off "erotica" and "manga"

3 books
92 shelves


message 60: by [deleted user] (new)

9 books
187 books

GR Authors - business
400-499 pages - christian, graphic novel, manga


message 61: by Adele (new)

Adele Symonds (adelesymonds) | 34 comments 8 books
158 shelves
1 GR author - Travel


message 62: by Think (new)

Think | 332 comments 6 books
131 shelves
5 GRA - anthology, business, m-m, mm, non-fiction
>400pg - poetry
>500pg - picture-book, picture-books

I was way behind on keeping track of my books. :(


message 63: by Jessica (new)

Jessica | 190 comments 8 books
163 shelves

1st book 400-499 pages, crossed off: politics
2nd book by Goodreads author, crossed off: business


message 64: by [deleted user] (new)

13 books
232 shelves

goodreads - "vampire"
over 400 - "books-we-own"


message 65: by Suzanne (new)

Suzanne (thisoilfieldwife) | 134 comments 4 books
140 shelves

book four was by a Goodreads author, crossing off: reference
Book three was greater than 500 pages, crossing off: art
Book one was greater than 600 pages, crossing off: manga, theology


message 66: by Hanne (new)

Hanne (hanne2) Kari wrote: Just for fun maybe at the end we could post some of our favorite headscratchers. Like Jane Eyre as Scifi. "

Sci-fi in particular seems to be one that people have trouble with. Almost all my books came back as sci-fi and i can assure you that none of them were. Although none as bad as Jane Eyre... that's for sure.

I also had American Gods and 33 people shelved it as 'humor', which makes me wonder whether those 33 people actually read it. I also wouldn't have called this a spiritual book, but there at least i can see a link

Another shelf that has my scratching my head is the shelf: "books". I'm not sure what else we would be shelving on goodreads...


message 67: by Julia (new)

Julia (bambbles) | 69 comments Okay! I just found this again after losing track of it for a while. So bear with me while I catch up:

6 Books
126 Shelves


Book 1: +700 - biography, food, mm, m-m
Book 2: GR author - biographies
Book 3: +700 - women, spirituality, sociology, self-help
Book 4: GR author - theology
Book 5: GR Author - 1
Book 6: GR Author - picture book

So excited to have remembered this challenge exists!


message 68: by Rebecca NJ (new)

Rebecca NJ (njreader) | 425 comments I am really excited by the number of people who are just starting this challenge, returning to this challenge or even lurking!


message 69: by Hanne (new)

Hanne (hanne2) i have another one for the headscratchers list:
Gabriel Garcia Marquez shelved as 'German-Classics'.


message 70: by Pinar (new)

Pinar Celebi (pinuccia) 7 books
154 shelves

My last book was over 400 pages so I crossed off poetry.


message 71: by Adele (new)

Adele Symonds (adelesymonds) | 34 comments Suzanne wrote: "4 books
140 shelves

book four was by a Goodreads author, crossing off: reference
Book three was greater than 500 pages, crossing off: art
Book one was greater than 600 pages, crossing off: manga, ..."


I thought it was 2 shelves for 500+ pages and 3 shelves for 600+ pages?


message 72: by Adele (new)

Adele Symonds (adelesymonds) | 34 comments 10 books

183 shelves

Book 9 - GR author - business

Book 10 - 500-599 pages - theology and 21st-century


message 73: by Ellen (new)

Ellen (ellex66) | 155 comments May I join this challenge?

If not, then I'll make sure to join next time!

If yes, then I've already started counting my shelves:

4 books
116 shelves

Book 1- GR author- erotica
Book 3- GR author- spiritual


message 74: by Rebecca NJ (new)

Rebecca NJ (njreader) | 425 comments Ellen wrote: "May I join this challenge? ..."

Welcome! There are no set rules as to when you can start and remember you can track any book your've read since August 1st.


message 75: by Rebecca NJ (last edited Sep 08, 2012 09:11AM) (new)

Rebecca NJ (njreader) | 425 comments Adele wrote: I thought it was 2 shelves for 500+ pages and 3 shelves for 600+ pages?"


You are correct:
* If a book has 400-499 pages - Mark off 1 extra shelf of your choice
* If a book has 500-599 pages - Mark off 2 extra shelves of your choice
* If a book has 600-699 pages - Mark off 3 extra shelves of your choice
* For more than 700 pages - Mark off 4 extra shelves of your choice

With that said, Suzanne, you can mark off extra shelves for the books you posted in Message 72. (Good catch Adele!)


message 76: by Cherie (new)

Cherie  (cheriereads) It's been a while since I've updated so:


13 books
214 shelves

Cross-Offs

*GR Authors = 8
graphic-novel, german, christianity, art, middle-grade, essays, comic, french

*500+ pages = 3 books (6 cross-offs)
reference, anthology, politics, erotica, 1, children-s-lit

*Round 12 Hits = 6
business, comics, cookbooks, manga, mm, m-m


message 77: by Jessica (new)

Jessica | 190 comments 10 books
173 shelves

1st book 400-499 pages, crossed off: politics
2nd book by Goodreads author, crossed off: business


message 78: by Julia (new)

Julia (bambbles) | 69 comments 8 books
139 shelves

1st book: GR Author - religion
2nd Book: GR Author - business


message 79: by Hanne (new)

Hanne (hanne2) 8 books
185 books

1 over 400 pages: crossed off Cristianity


message 80: by Suzanne (new)

Suzanne (thisoilfieldwife) | 134 comments Rebecca wrote: "Adele wrote: I thought it was 2 shelves for 500+ pages and 3 shelves for 600+ pages?"


You are correct:
* If a book has 400-499 pages - Mark off 1 extra shelf of your choice
* If a book has 500-5..."


Yes. Thanks, Adele!

For the extra 500 page book I will cross off: business

For the extra 600 page book I will cross off: cookbooks


message 81: by Suzanne (new)

Suzanne (thisoilfieldwife) | 134 comments Ack! Forgot to add my newest count! lol

9 books
170 shelves

books 6, 7, and 9 were by Goodreads Authors, so I am crossing off: indonesian, sociology, and self-help

Everyone seems to be doing great so far!


message 82: by [deleted user] (new)

15 books
248 shelves

Goodreads - "German"
Over 500 - "2009-reads" and "unsorted"


message 83: by [deleted user] (new)

16 books
230 shelves

GR Authors - business, inspirational
400-499 pages - christian, graphic novel, manga, spirituality


message 84: by Adele (new)

Adele Symonds (adelesymonds) | 34 comments 15 books
210 shelves

GR authors books 11, 12 and 14 crossed off - women, tbr, and war

400-499 pages, Books 13 and 14, crossed off - 3-stars and started


message 85: by Adele (new)

Adele Symonds (adelesymonds) | 34 comments Suzanne wrote: "Rebecca wrote: "Adele wrote: I thought it was 2 shelves for 500+ pages and 3 shelves for 600+ pages?"


You are correct:
* If a book has 400-499 pages - Mark off 1 extra shelf of your choice
* If ..."


You are welcome Suzanne


message 86: by Adele (new)

Adele Symonds (adelesymonds) | 34 comments Will there be a leaderboard update coming up soon?


message 87: by Hanne (last edited Sep 16, 2012 01:18PM) (new)

Hanne (hanne2) 11 books
216 shelves

2 GR authors, crossed of christian and christian-fiction


message 88: by Rebecca NJ (new)

Rebecca NJ (njreader) | 425 comments 24 books
246 shelves

Book 19: GR author, crossed off travel
Book 20: GR author, crossed off politics
Book 21: GR author, crossed off kids-books


message 89: by Rebecca NJ (new)

Rebecca NJ (njreader) | 425 comments Standings as of September 15th (through post 91):


Lori - 248 shelves; 15 books
Pigletto - 230 shelves; 16 books
Cherie - 214 shelves; 13 books
Rebecca - 210 shelves; 15 books
Kari - 190 shelves; 28 books
Adrienne - 189 shelves; 8 books
Hanne - 185 shelves; 8 books
Adele - 183 shelves; 10 books
Jessica - 173 shelves; 10 books
Suzanne - 170 shelves; 9 books
Pinar - 154 shelves; 7 books
Julia - 139 shelves; 8 books
Heather - 135 shelves; 4 books
Think - 131 shelves; 6 books
Ellen - 116 shelves; 4 books
Tori - 104 shelves; 2 books
Mary - 92 shelves; 3 books
Kim L - 3 shelves; 0 books

If there are any mistakes, please let me know.


message 90: by Jessica (new)

Jessica | 190 comments 12 books
210 shelves

1st book 400-499 pages, crossed off: politics
2nd book by Goodreads author, crossed off: business


message 91: by Heather (Heatso) (new)

Heather (Heatso) (hyperweather) | 7 comments 6 books
172 shelves

Book 6 GR Author - christian-fiction


message 92: by [deleted user] (new)

17 books
259 shelves

Goodreads - "erotica"
500+ pages - "plays," "paranormal-romance"


message 93: by Pinar (new)

Pinar Celebi (pinuccia) 10 books
175 shelves


message 94: by Adele (new)

Adele Symonds (adelesymonds) | 34 comments Rebecca wrote: "Standings as of September 15th (through post 91):


Lori - 248 shelves; 15 books
Pigletto - 230 shelves; 16 books
Cherie - 214 shelves; 13 books
Rebecca - 210 shelves; 15 books
Kari - 190 shelves; ..."


see post 92 I am at 210 shelves for 15 books.


message 95: by Adele (new)

Adele Symonds (adelesymonds) | 34 comments Books 17
Shelves 217

Book 16 was 400-499 pages - crossed off, reference
Book 17 GR author - crossed off, to-read-2


message 96: by Rebecca NJ (last edited Sep 18, 2012 06:00PM) (new)

Rebecca NJ (njreader) | 425 comments Adele wrote: "see post 92 I am at 210 shelves for 15 books"

Adele - I only updated through September 15th (post 91). Next update will be at the end of the month. Sorry!


message 97: by Adele (new)

Adele Symonds (adelesymonds) | 34 comments Fine no probs hopefully I will have moved up a bit by then.


message 98: by Rebecca NJ (last edited Sep 23, 2012 03:47PM) (new)

Rebecca NJ (njreader) | 425 comments 28 books
252 shelves

Book 28: GR author, crossed off unowned


message 99: by Hanne (new)

Hanne (hanne2) 14 books
229 shelves

1 GR author: crossed off 1
2 books over 600 pages: crossed off art; biographies; collection; cookbooks; epubs and mm


message 100: by Pinar (new)

Pinar Celebi (pinuccia) 11 books
177 shelves

Last book over 500 pages: crossed off keepers, graphic-novels


back to top