Twilight (The Twilight Saga, #1) Twilight discussion


201 views
Carlisle Cullen

Comments Showing 1-29 of 29 (29 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

em (lattereads) Does anyone else love him too? Why? Why not? What's your favorite thing about him?


Zino Who doesn't love Carlisle?
I love his compassion, and the fact that if it weren't for him there really wouldn't be a story because all the Cullens would have died way back in the past so Bella wouldn't have met Edward


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ I love him. It's so sweet how he and Esme meet. Really adorable.


message 4: by [deleted user] (new)

i luv carlisle, he's so sweet and even though he's a vamp, he still is a doctor


Jettcatt Well.. I'm a bit undecided, to me he is kind of too nice and a little boring and then there's the fact that he single handedly decided to play god with other peoples lives and turn them for his pleasure. Created a family of vampires whilst all the while claiming for the greater good??? Sounds a little selfish to me but then again that seems to come with the territory of vampires (Edward,, just a little selfish don't you think) Well anyway I don't hate him but can't say that I love him either, I am switzerland.


Sunny C-s The story of how Carlisle and Esme met, were separated, and meet again is awesome, I agree with Alexia. I disagree with Jettcatt, because they were all DYING. And Edward's mom begged him to save her son. (Kinda like she signed a permission slip...) I doubt he could stand seeing anyone die, he's that compassionate.


Emma I Love Carlisle. There is a softness and empathy in him that makes him so good as a foil for the normal vampire characterisation... He was always my favourite, no contest!!

I think he actually signposts the ease with which Bella copes in the last book... He showed how the change did not need to be a murderfest.

I also like that he is British!!!


Menka I think the Twilight Saga should've been about Carlisle and Esme <3


Kirby Jettcatt wrote: "Well.. I'm a bit undecided, to me he is kind of too nice and a little boring and then there's the fact that he single handedly decided to play god with other peoples lives and turn them for his pleasure..."

well, it's shown that he's still tortured over the decision he made to turn others. also, I don't really consider "for his pleasure" to be the same as "to lessen his misery." he never got any sort of god-like thrill from it or anything...


message 10: by Emma (new) - rated it 5 stars

Emma Kirby wrote: "Jettcatt wrote: "Well.. I'm a bit undecided, to me he is kind of too nice and a little boring and then there's the fact that he single handedly decided to play god with other peoples lives and turn..."

Kirby I quite agree... Carlisle is the man Edward wishes to emulate, so if we take it that Edward is "good, but tortured" then Carlisle is just noble and the family he creates and nurtures to a "better vampirism" is his legacy and his atonement for his "crimes" (in his opinion!
)


message 11: by Ana (new) - rated it 2 stars

Ana I absolutley love him, he is such a good character and so nice and wants to help everybody. His past is awful but he still goes on like nothing happened and is always wanting to do the right thing.


message 12: by Kim (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kim Dr. Daddy Cullen! Love him!


Helen I love Carlisle Cullen. <3


Iesha (In east shade house at...) I love him because of his actions and determination.


message 15: by [deleted user] (new)

love him


Wren I luv Calisle! he's so nice, plus the guy who plays him in the movie is really attractive (;


Justine Saulnier i luv him too everything about him is wonderful


AlbertaJenn I like that Carlisle is the philosopher of the series. His views on good vs. evil and redemption are very subtle, and SM never gets enough credit for including them in the books.


Justine Saulnier yeah but hes a good guy and hes cute too lolz


message 20: by [deleted user] (new)

In the movies he is HOT!!!!!So sexy


message 21: by Ana (new) - rated it 2 stars

Ana haahah you really think that?


Justine Saulnier yes she does


Elizabeth Day He is so nice! Carlisle is awesome!


Justine Saulnier yes he is


message 25: by [deleted user] (new)

Anna the crazy girl who cant wait for school!!! wrote: "haahah you really think that?"

You talking to me?lol well if you are yesss!!! I think he is so freakin sexy. Remember in the second movie(i know but he's not was hot in the books sorry)when he's sewing Bella up and she has her hand on his waist??I would have killed to be Bella in that scene. Course I would have done less talking and more...other stuff;)


message 26: by Xxemo_vampxx (new)

Xxemo_vampxx I love him because, he's hold on to his humanity quite well, he's kind hearted, compassionate,sweet...I adore him <3, He's so sexy, probably the hottest Vampire and doctor you'll ever come across, He's the most McSexiest Vamp everr lol Team Carlisle,,,oh and i can't get enought of his peircing gold eyes and sexy English accent,,,they make me melt!! <3 If you aren't on Team Carlisle than you really haven't lived XD


message 27: by Xxemo_vampxx (new)

Xxemo_vampxx Baylor wrote: "Anna the crazy girl who cant wait for school!!! wrote: "haahah you really think that?"

You talking to me?lol well if you are yesss!!! I think he is so freakin sexy. Remember in the second movie(i ..."


IRK....i agree,,,totally!! He's really sexy in NM,,,well all the movies actually.


message 28: by [deleted user] (new)

I think he's probably the most developed character in the story. Carlisle was definitely my favourite character.


message 29: by [deleted user] (new)

I love Carlisle!!!!


back to top