Harry Potter discussion

Games > Would you Rather? 2!

Comments Showing 1-50 of 214 (214 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 3 4 5

message 1: by Ciara (last edited Jun 17, 2012 12:36PM) (new)

Ciara  | 109 comments This game is a bit different to the first Would you Rather topic. Here's an example of how you play: I will post a question, such as: Harry Potter or Hunger Games?
The next person to comment will answer my question, and ask one of their own.
The question can be totally random, or about Harry Potter, whichever you like :P
I hope you enjoy this one just as much as the first! =D
I'll start: Bellatrix or Molly Weasley?

message 2: by Emma (new)

Emma Hardman | 53 comments Molly Weasley, no questions.

Luna or Neville?

message 3: by Tessa (new)

Tessa  (panicrocks95) Well if I want more hilarious and adorable I'd pick Luna but If I want AMAZING then I'd choose Neville XD

Nosebleed Nougat or Ton-Tongue Toffee?

message 4: by Emma (new)

Emma Hardman | 53 comments Nosebleed Nougat. I don't really mind nosebleeds.

Seeker or Beater?

message 5: by [deleted user] (new)

Beater- i like hitting things

date Fred or George?
(with george with 2 ears and fred not dead)

message 6: by Candycloud (last edited Jul 01, 2012 09:38AM) (new)

Candycloud | 143 comments George - I seemed to always prefer him...

Neville or Harry?

message 7: by Tessa (new)

Tessa  (panicrocks95) Neville!!!

Would you rather see AVPM live or see AVPS live?

message 8: by Libby (new)

Libby (libbith220) AVPM.

Would you rather teach Transfiguration or Charms?

message 9: by [deleted user] (new)

Charms-Less major problems.

Would you rather a half-blood or a pure-blood?

message 10: by Lucie (new)

Lucie If I was to chose, I would rather be a pure-blood - there's just a little possiblity I would be growing up as a Muggle-born :) But I would take both just to be a wizard! :D

Would you rather be an apprentice of Salazar Slytherin or Rowena Ravenclaw?

message 11: by Ishani (new)

Ishani (IshaniG) | 425 comments Ravenclaw, doubtless!
Who wants to be with Slytherin (that Muggle hater)!

WYR have an owil as a pet or a cat!

message 12: by Ciara (new)

Ciara  | 109 comments Definitely an owl.

Ron or Neville?

message 13: by Ishani (last edited Jul 13, 2012 03:20AM) (new)

Ishani (IshaniG) | 425 comments Ron

WYR revive Lupin or Sirius if given a chance?

message 14: by Libby (new)

Libby (libbith220) Lupin. I think that he should be able to see is son grow up.

WYR fight a dragon for a golden egg or swim in the lake to save your friend?

message 15: by Ciara (new)

Ciara  | 109 comments Fight a dragon. I think that I would feel safer with people looking at me in the arena and knowing that there was someting else out then other than murky water.
And the Accio charm is very handy in that situation.

Umbridge or Wormtail? Who's worse?

message 16: by Ana (new)

Ana | 32 comments Wormtail, he betrayed his friends :(

WYR Be a good slytherin or a bad gryffindor?

message 17: by Ishani (new)

Ishani (IshaniG) | 425 comments Good Slytherin. Btw, Gryffindors can never be bad and Slytherin can never be good!

McGonagall or Snape?

message 18: by Ana (new)

Ana | 32 comments McGonagall. Btw, Wormtail was a bad Gryffindor and Snape was a good Slytherin :)

WYR become an Auror or a Hogwarts Professor?

message 19: by La Niña (new)

La Niña | 14 comments An Auror. I have so little patience to become a Professor of any kind.

WYR have a joke shop or a wand shop?

message 20: by [deleted user] (new)

Joke Shop
WYR eat chocolate frogs or BBEFB for the rest of your life?
((berty botts every flavoured beans))

message 21: by Ciara (new)

Ciara  | 109 comments Chocolate Frogs (if I could catch them!)
WYR live in Hogwarts or the Burrow?

message 22: by Ishani (new)

Ishani (IshaniG) | 425 comments Ana wrote: "McGonagall. Btw, Wormtail was a bad Gryffindor and Snape was a good Slytherin :)

WYR become an Auror or a Hogwarts Professor?"

But then Snape like all other Slytherins was stereotypical and if u remember then in Deathly Hallows at Malfoy Manor Wormtail did spare Harry and then he died! Although the fact that Snape was good cannot be denied but still if he had not loved Lily and if that story had not been there then Snape would hav been as bad as any other Slytherin!

message 23: by Libby (new)

Libby (libbith220) Ciara *I love Harry Potter!* wrote: "Chocolate Frogs (if I could catch them!)
WYR live in Hogwarts or the Burrow?"

Hogwarts. While I love the Burrow, Hogwarts has so many cool places.

WYR kill Bellatrix Lestrange or Lucius Malfoy?

message 24: by Julia (new)

Julia | 275 comments Bellatrix

Sirius or Remus?

message 25: by Charisma (new)

Charisma (charismamdrc) | 3 comments Julie wrote: "Bellatrix

Sirius or Remus?"


message 26: by Libby (new)

Libby (libbith220) WYR take Divination or Care for Magical Creatures?

message 27: by Ciara (new)

Ciara  | 109 comments Care of Magical Creatures.

Who is more evil: Wormtail or Umbridge?

message 28: by Ishani (new)

Ishani (IshaniG) | 425 comments Umbridge!!!

WYR Every Flavour Beans or Chocolate Frogs?

message 29: by indianvalantine (new)

indianvalantine | 7 comments Flavour Beans


message 30: by Ciara (new)

Ciara  | 109 comments Elder Wand.
It appears to me that the people who were summoned from the dead didn't want to be.
And besides, if I had the Elder Wand, I would probably destroy it, like Harry. It was more trouble than it was worth.

Hufflepuff crest or Ravenclaw crest?

message 31: by Sigrid (new)

Sigrid (sigri-d) | 131 comments Ravenclaw crest

Gryffindor house or Ravenclaw house?

message 32: by Ciara (new)

Ciara  | 109 comments Ravenclaw House.

Be part of a Slytherin family or Hufflepuff family?

message 33: by Libby (new)

Libby (libbith220) Slytherin family. I'd try to be like Sirius. (I didn't pick Hufflepuff 'cause I don't think that I'm nice enough!)

WYR meet Harry Potter or Albus Dumbledore?

message 34: by Martha (last edited Jul 30, 2012 04:26PM) (new)

Martha Barth (superducky022) | 14 comments Albus Dumbledore... he's so smarticle!!! I also think Harry doesn't like all the publicity too much.

WYR own the Elder Wand or the Invisibility Cloak?

message 35: by Julia (new)

Julia | 275 comments Invisiblity Cloak.

WYR be a wandmaker or a teacher?

message 36: by Sigrid (new)

Sigrid (sigri-d) | 131 comments teacher, don't think I would be a good wandmaker...

WYR meet Voldemort or Umbridge?

message 37: by Ishani (new)

Ishani (IshaniG) | 425 comments Meet and kill Voldemort!

WYR Dramione or AVPM?

message 38: by Nikoline (new)

Nikoline (annenikoline) AVPM
WYR Fred or George?

message 39: by Lucie (new)

Lucie Eeeh, it's strange, 'coz I loved them both, but I'd vote for George - maybe after reading James Potter stories, where George still is.

WYR Albus Severus Potter as a Slytherin or Gryffindor?

message 40: by Libby (new)

Libby (libbith220) Slytherin, just to prove that not all Slytherins are bad.

WYR meet J.K. Rowling or have an autographed copy of all the books?

message 41: by Ishani (new)

Ishani (IshaniG) | 425 comments Meet her. 'coz by meeting her I can ask her so many questions and if I meet her then I can get her autograph as well!

WYR Viktor Krum or Cedric Diggory?

message 42: by Candycloud (new)

Candycloud | 143 comments Cedric Diggory. Hands down.

(Guys, this is turning into the original Would You Rather! )

Harry or Peeta (from the hunger games)?

message 43: by Julia (new)

Julia | 275 comments Harry! (of course!)

WYR meet Emma Watson or Dan Radcliffe?

message 44: by Ishani (last edited Aug 16, 2012 08:13AM) (new)

Ishani (IshaniG) | 425 comments I am sorry for breaking all ur hearts but I'll have to go with Dumbledore.
Sirius was awesome but then I found him really arrogant and now if I think then there would have been no need for him in the next two books.
Yes I agree that it would have been interesting to see Harry and Sirius bond more but I always respected Albus Dumbledore because of his calm nature, intelligence and wisdom. Sirius might have been fun but no such feelings for him! Dumbledore could have guided Harry.
Personally I think that the deaths were perfect in the series except for Dobby and Fred which was seriously nasty. JKR wrote an amazing series and I chose Dumbledore just because a choice was given! I am contented with the series!

WYR Haymitch or Dumbledore?

message 45: by Prajakta (new)

Prajakta | 3 comments Dumbledore!!

WYR Katniss or Hermione??

message 46: by Maya (new)

Maya | 22 comments Hermione!!!

WYR Save Tonks and Lupin, or Fred and Madeye?

message 47: by Candycloud (new)

Candycloud | 143 comments Fred and Madeye. George is not George without Fred.

Draco or President Snow?

message 48: by Maya (new)

Maya | 22 comments Draco

WRY Expecto Patronum or Expelliarmus?

message 49: by Amanda (new)

Amanda Rousseau (amandaerinxx) Dudley.

Chocolate Frogs or Every Flavor Beans?

message 50: by [deleted user] (new)

Pumpkin Pasties, I don't like pumpkin juice.

WYR Voldemort or Umbridge

« previous 1 3 4 5
back to top