Catching Fire
discussion
Justin Bieber as Finnick?
message 801:
by
Courtney
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
May 03, 2012 06:39AM
I hope you all realize there was an APRIL FOOL'S article that said Justin would be Finnick and Taylor Swift would be Johanna. Very fake. Never going to happen.
reply
|
flag
Courtney wrote: "I hope you all realize there was an APRIL FOOL'S article that said Justin would be Finnick and Taylor Swift would be Johanna. Very fake. Never going to happen."Bahaha! Love Taylor, but the idea of her being Johanna is almost funnier than the idea of Justin being Finnick.
Justin Bieber is too young, too skinny, too full of himself. He'd be totally out of place. If there's a role he can play, it would be one of the patients of the hospital that burned down in the third book. if this should happen, i'll watch it on 3D.
Who in their right mind would consider him? A. He is too young to play Finnick.
B. Finnick is too awesome.
C.He hasn't had any acting experience. Which would result to bad acting and Finnick being portrayed terribly.
D. (did I mention Finnick is too awesome to be played by Justin. I did? Well,oh well. I am going to say it again.) FINNICK IS AWESOME!!!!!
Oh. My. God. NO!!!
Haha nice one Samantha
NO NO NO NO NO NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!IF HE BECOMES FINNICK I THINK I WILL TAKE ALL MY HUNGER GAMES BOOK AND LIGHT THEM ON FIRE
Please, please not Justin... I probably wouldn't go.Now if they wanted a teen draw... Zack Efron would be better, he is suppose to be in his mid-20's so it should work. Plus he's now attracting an older audience with his latest "The Lucky One". So more folks to dole out money.
Gah! Zac Efron! Yees, he would be a good Finnick, with like short hair... yes ;)
I'm not saying this because I don't like Justin Bieber's music. Even though I don't, I respect things he's done as a person because some of the things he's done are really great.But flat out, Justin Bieber CANNOT be Finnick.
1. The guy has to appear older than Jennifer Lawrence. Jennifer Lawrence is 21. And Finnick's supposed to be 8 years older than 16-year old Katniss.
2. I doubt anyone (except fangirling idiots) honestly pictures Finnick as someone like Justin Bieber. He's really not all that good-looking, and Finnick has to be the sexiest thing to walk the earth, because he's the sexiest thing to walk the fictional world. (And even though there might not be enough sexy actors for that, because everyone has different opinions, they'll try!)
3. Justin Bieber's only acted in CSI. A role as big as Finnick is out of his league. He's a singer, and when I saw him in CSI he was okay, but not the best. We need an actor who's amazing (or at least good!) for the role of Finnick. He has to have had legitimate experience!
Yeah.
Ariie wrote: "I'm not saying this because I don't like Justin Bieber's music. Even though I don't, I respect things he's done as a person because some of the things he's done are really great.But flat out, Jus..."
And, that ends this discussion, because you just said it all! I totally agree with you :)
no. nope. no. nopity no. ABSOLUTEMENT PAS!!!!! Thats French for over my dead body... Can the kid even act??
Zac Efron? Yeah, that'd be okay.... I just can't really imagine Efron acting so cocky... (in a totally nice and awesome way but still)
Yeah, Efron... he would work, I guess, but now that I think about it, he doesn't really look like Finnick does.
Mercy wrote: "Ariie wrote: "I'm not saying this because I don't like Justin Bieber's music. Even though I don't, I respect things he's done as a person because some of the things he's done are really great.But..."
Thanks! x)
As for Efron... Eh... He could work, looks-wise, and his acting's fine, but... Eh...
Well IMDB says that Taylor Kitsch, Armie Hammer, and Garrett Hedlund were considered for the role of Finnick Odair. Robert Pattinson was also FALSELY rumored.... Oh! And the director is going to be different so we better hope that this new guy does a good job...
Bianca wrote: "Well IMDB says that Taylor Kitsch, Armie Hammer, and Garrett Hedlund were considered for the role of Finnick Odair. Robert Pattinson was also FALSELY rumored.... Oh! And the director is going to be..."Amen to that!
soo... who's the best out of the three??
and Justin Bieber is short. 5'7"?? Really?? Im taller than that. And Jennifer Lawrence is the same.
Garrett Hedlund, baby. <3
Claire wrote: "Haha nice one Samantha"Hey it's the truth finnick is also a guy lol he was not described as a 16 year old cry baby girl
Samantha wrote: "Claire wrote: "Haha nice one Samantha"Hey it's the truth finnick is also a guy lol he was not described as a 16 year old cry baby girl"
hahaha funny(: ikr?? well I vote Kitsch. I love Hedlund but he doesn't seem Finnick-y enough to me...
JB is simply a pampered baby, no way Finnick. That's funny, though.
Bianca wrote: "Samantha wrote: "Claire wrote: "Haha nice one Samantha"Hey it's the truth finnick is also a guy lol he was not described as a 16 year old cry baby girl"
hahaha funny(: ikr?? well I vote Kitsch. ..."
Justin bieber would not strike me as a hot GUY who could work a trident much less a toothbrush lol I like Benjamin stone for finnick
Samantha wrote: "Bianca wrote: "Samantha wrote: "Claire wrote: "Haha nice one Samantha"Hey it's the truth finnick is also a guy lol he was not described as a 16 year old cry baby girl"
hahaha funny(: ikr?? well ..."
Oh yeah definitely! But he's not an option ):
I thought Zach Efron was playing him
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! If Justin Bieber is going to be Finnick I will NOT see it! He will ruin the whole thing!
Ariie wrote: "Bianca wrote: "Well IMDB says that Taylor Kitsch, Armie Hammer, and Garrett Hedlund were considered for the role of Finnick Odair. Robert Pattinson was also FALSELY rumored.... Oh! And the director..."Pattinson, don't get me wrong I loved him in Twilight and he was perfect in that role. But seriously, superstud Finnick needs to have a bit more of a physical presence...
Sue wrote: "Ariie wrote: "Bianca wrote: "Well IMDB says that Taylor Kitsch, Armie Hammer, and Garrett Hedlund were considered for the role of Finnick Odair. Robert Pattinson was also FALSELY rumored.... Oh! An..."Lol I think so too. I just hope that despite who Finnick Odair (one of my favorite characters) is, the movie is still good...
Bianca wrote: "Sue wrote: "Ariie wrote: "Bianca wrote: "Well IMDB says that Taylor Kitsch, Armie Hammer, and Garrett Hedlund were considered for the role of Finnick Odair. Robert Pattinson was also FALSELY rumore..."I'm gonna digress here, apologies up front.
Okay pandora's box moment... If there was no Annie, I'd have been cheering Finnick and Katniss on. Finnick was the perfect character, funny, brave, loyal and smart. What's not to love... I honestly felt worse when he died, because I knew his character better than Prim's. I know she was the full circle character, Katniss sacrificed herself to save Prim and ultimately her action (Volunteering and Winning the Hunger Games) didn't change what fate had in store for Prim. So I guess in that regard, it was a proper ending... it's a pretty dark tale especially in book 3, S. Collins wasn't looking for happy.
Justing Beiber would not work as Finnick, personally I've always imagined Alex Pettyfer as the part
Never!I would actually cry if that happens.
BEEBZ IS NOT WELCOME HERE!
I'll kill myself if that happens! I'll burn all the Banners and related to the movie if that ever happens !
So I just told my friend about this and basically after a lot of screaming and swearing we have come to the conclusion that the casting director is a moron or on crack.This cannot happen. NOT EVER.
i belive some one like alex pettefer but not alex pettefer, jb just looks like some pre-pubesent girl!!!
Look, Finnick is supposed to be hot! That is all I need to say about that!!!
Oh come on! Beiber as Finnick, seriously? Thank goodness, Harry Potter was wrapped up before Beiber was born or he would get in there too!
What?! No way! Are they really considering that? If he is a really good actor the i guess that would be ok i guess but that would also be weird because e very time i saw fjnnick in the mo ie i would think jusin beiber and not finnick and that would annoy me
Ariel wrote: "HE double hockey sticks no. They have to actually use someone cute."Agreed
Alex Pettyfer? Eeeeeh... I imagine someone different. Plus, he's really not all that good at acting... I mean, he's okay. xD
NO WAY! Justin Bieber should stay at his music and try to make it good in stead of try out for acting. He shall NOT Be in such a good serie as The Hunger Games!
i agree with everyone saying heck to the NO!!!!!! NO POSSIBLE WAY, IT WILL LITERALLY RUIN THE HUNGER GAMES FOR ME!!! i THINK that will ruin catching fire ...not saying he is a bad person but NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
LOL THE THOUGHT OF JB AS.... oh you were serious?
Janie wrote: "Who in their right mind would consider him? A. He is too young to play Finnick.
B. Finnick is too awesome.
C.He hasn't had any acting experience. Which would result to bad acting and Finnick bei..."
Why do I laugh every time I read this comment?!
They need someone who isn't very well known to play him! If JB plays him all I'll be thinking for the entire movie is "If I was your boyfriend...." No one wants that. :P
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
Catching Fire (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
Serial Games (other topics)Catching Fire (other topics)
