Twilight
discussion
Twilight vs. Harry potter
message 1:
by
Celeste
(new)
-
added it
Mar 29, 2012 10:30AM
Which is better, which ever side wins will win a prize.
reply
|
flag
Harry Potter. No competition whatsoever.
Harry Potter 100%. I don't know how anyone could say otherwise.
totally different books for me but from these two I would have to say Harry
OMG, that is such a hard que-HARRY POTTER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1000000000000000000000000000000%
Go Twilight!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! GO TWIHARDS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Twilight isn't worthy enough to be competed with HP. Harry Potter is better in so many ways. (that's my opinion so I'm sorry to any Twilight fans out there)
Harry potter would win by a mile!!!!
Harry Potter hands down.
Harry Potter has more thought, more plot, more character development and healthier displays of relationships. Harry Potter hands down.
I'm leaving Twilight for Harry Potter.
harry potter!!!!!!!!!!
Why is this even a question?
I love the Twilight books but......HARRY POTTER IS WAY BETTER!!!!!!
sorry Edward, I want my wizard. :)
HARRY POTTER!um.....DUH!
Harry Potter! I am ready to die for it!
Terribly hard choice. but i have to say: Harry Potter! it's funnier.
Harry Potter. No doubt about it.
Why am I the only one for Twilight? Twilight changed my life and the way I saw things. Twilight is the most amazing book ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Wait I reread the comments and ONE person was with me. Thank you Widi!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I mean I love harry potter but nothing can compare with how astounding Twilight is.
Patti wrote: "Wait I reread the comments and ONE person was with me. Thank you Widi!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I mean I love harry potter but nothing can compare with how astounding Twilight is."no. just no
Im sorry but there is no contest between these two.Harry Potter has everything over twilight in all aspects, story, writing everything!
I have read all the twilight books and liked them all but Harry Potter was on another level of enjoyment!
For me Twilight is special because of Meyer's use of first person POV in dialogue ( actually thought monologue) to hold the reader in tight to the action and tension. RT
obviously is Twilight!!!! because it has love, adventue, mystery...it has everythimg
Lizette wrote: "obviously is Twilight!!!! because it has love, adventue, mystery...it has everythimg"Harry Potter has all of that too.
Harry Potter of course!
Why would anybody wanna compare in the first place?
That being said, HARRY POTTER.
Shehrin wrote: "Why would anybody wanna compare in the first place?"Agree with you
I personally love Harry Potter!! I grew up with that book!! Twilight has so much romance!!!
Harry Potter all the way! :D
Harry Potter 4 sure, nothing beats the boy with the lightning scar! <3
Morgana_lefay wrote: "Shehrin wrote: "Why would anybody wanna compare in the first place?"Agree with you"
Of course :P
Harry Potter no contest
Alex (message 23) no to you, just no :P
Thank you everyone who wrote Twilight!!!!!!!!! You're awesome!!!!!
twilight all the way sorry guys
Once again, why does every popular series have to be compared to Twilight?I love both series, I am a confessed Potter Geek and a Twilight Lover!
But come on people, how can you compare them? They are in different genres!!!!!! Compare Twilight to The Vampire Diaries or Harry Potter to Percy Jackson! Uggggg!
I enjoyed the twilight books the First time I read them, but not anymore. I think the three main actors ruined Edward, Bella, and Jacob completely. I do NOT picture them the same way as in the books. Even then, I'm all for Narnia more.
I enjoyed twilight, but c'mon! It's so obviously Harry Potter!
There is no verses. Harry Potter would win, hands down, every single time. There is no comparison between the two series. Harry Potter is genius and Twilight is fluff. I find it funny that this is even a thread because its so impossible that Twilight even stands a chance.
Michaela wrote: "lol every time this question is asked (and it's asked a lot!) Harry Potter has the majority by a huge amount lol :D"Well it has a more general appeal, wider target audience and less problematic/controversial aspects. Plus, it's not "cool" to like twilight. xD
I'm team wolves, in the BOOKS, not in the movies. Some movies ruin book characters.
animaldisneyreaderfan4lyfe7 wrote: "I'm team wolves, in the BOOKS, not in the movies. Some movies ruin book characters."It didn't ruin it for me.
But then again, I watched the movies first, lol. xD
You didn't like the wolves in the movies?
Diane *Ahnnihilate* wrote: "animaldisneyreaderfan4lyfe7 wrote: "I'm team wolves, in the BOOKS, not in the movies. Some movies ruin book characters."It didn't ruin it for me.
But then again, I watched the movies first, lol. x..."
I did, but I liked their book descriptions much better. That's just my opinion. True, in some movies I like what they do in both the book and the movie, but not for the Saga.
animaldisneyreaderfan4lyfe7 wrote: "Diane *Ahnnihilate* wrote: "animaldisneyreaderfan4lyfe7 wrote: "I'm team wolves, in the BOOKS, not in the movies. Some movies ruin book characters."It didn't ruin it for me.
But then again, I watc..."
The book wolves were much better. I liked the whole aspect of the interwoven connections of the pack. The pack is the only redeeming aspect of the books.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
