Breaking Dawn
discussion
What do you think would happen if Bella dated Harry Potter or Luke Skywalker from Star Wars or Sherlock Holmes?
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
brooke1994
(new)
Feb 05, 2012 03:03PM
Well????
reply
|
flag
@Libby your sherlock reaction is dead on.
Libby wrote: "Bella + Harry: He would get incredibly bored with her and try to pass her off to Crabbe or Goyle.
Bella + Luke: He wouldn't even be bothered.
Bella + Sherlock: He would glance her up and down on..."
No one post discussion over, that comment is the correct/so true answer!!;););
Bella + Luke: He wouldn't even be bothered.
Bella + Sherlock: He would glance her up and down on..."
No one post discussion over, that comment is the correct/so true answer!!;););
Come on... None of those guys would date Bella.
Harry actually found Cho a complicated girl..And you know Bella..She gives a new definition to the word 'complicated'!!!I don't see it lasting a week :P
Kristin wrote: "Come on... None of those guys would date Bella."I know, I just wanted to be a little humorous....
Libby said it all. Nothing to add.
bella has her own freaky world that would never match any other creepy world :))Because the guys in her world are desighned to be stupid enough not only to fall in love with her but also to fight every thing for her sake.
Harry Potter would never waste a minuete on her :)
Libby wrote: "Bella + Harry: He would get incredibly bored with her and try to pass her off to Crabbe or Goyle. Bella + Luke: He wouldn't even be bothered.
Bella + Sherlock: He would glance her up and down on..."
Actually, Lucy is wrong... Holmes would say 'Boring' before walking away with Watson and going to find an interesting, complex case to solve. :P
Bella is better of with Edward.
None of those characters would date a boring, needy 18 year old
Libby wrote: "Bella + Sherlock: He would glance her up and down once, look her in the eye, and tell her her life story based on her scars, clothes, and flat hair. After, he would walk away to Watson - home where he belongs. "Sherlock: *Stares at hands* Remarkable, *Stares at clothes* extraordinary!, *examines Bella's room and surroundings* Truly in the annals of crime and history you are unique! Watson this is a case we shall not soon forget! It appears you do nothing, and have little to no distinguishing characteristic, everything about you seems so ordinary and nonspecific I would swear you do not exist! The lengths to which you go to hide nearly everything about you strikes me of great criminal intellect. What on Earth could she be hiding Watson!
*Bella speaks*
Sherlock : *Appears Shocked! A moment passes and a great sigh escapes him and he appears to deflate* Watson It appears I have Erred, come I have never before felt so board. I fear you will have to drag me back from some great depth of a depression soon......
On the flip side, I think Bella and Keanu Reeves would have made a perfect couple.
Together they could have created a 4 by 4 or a 2 by 8...
Swathika wrote: "Bella is better of with Edward."
I KNEW SOME fan was gonna say that! This thread isnt about edwrd, or how its sooooo" amazing "
Its fun thread! Pleez, twi-fans, let me have one place where i can say hate about it bd not get killed by a bunch of commens!!!! have mercy!!
:p
I KNEW SOME fan was gonna say that! This thread isnt about edwrd, or how its sooooo" amazing "
Its fun thread! Pleez, twi-fans, let me have one place where i can say hate about it bd not get killed by a bunch of commens!!!! have mercy!!
:p
Sherlock would tell her crap bout hersel then s ay she wscreepy, then leave, m commmnts are shorter and have mitax cuse this pice of shit zepad, this took me 22 mins oo rite!
I just want to say that is the strangest question I've read in a while and it unsettles me a bit.
Harry would eventually use the avada kedavra curse on her, which I for one would approve of...Luke would slice her into tiny bits with his lightsaber so....she is better off with Mr. Glitter ;)
Sherlock would see her "many" expressions of emotion and would tire, probably use her as some part of his escapes but other than that no love there at all..
I love sherlock holmes the 2 movies rock, and tht actor who plays him... wow! <3
Libby wrote: "Bella + Harry: He would get incredibly bored with her and try to pass her off to Crabbe or Goyle. Bella + Luke: He wouldn't even be bothered.
Bella + Sherlock: He would glance her up and down on..."
Thank you.
...really? This is a question? Well, because I'm a dork about crossovers, I'll give everyone the answer you KNOW is coming...Bella - No! None of you understand my feelings! None of you SPARKLE!!! BLAARRRGGHHHH!!!!!
...okay, trolling aside, I don't think any of these would work, and here are the series reasons why.
Harry - Far too impatient to be with her. Let's be fair: he isn't able to put that much time and energy into the romances even in his own books. He barely notices that Ginny is interested in him since the second book, when he courts Cho Chang he's awkward at best, and he isn't able to help Ron and Hermione out with their relationship very much, despite wanting to care for both of them. He isn't the passionate love type. The only reason he and Ginny work out is because they were friends before, and their romance developed.
Bella is more superficial, and her romance with Edward doesn't seem to have a basis on any emotional needs. Harry wouldn't date someone he couldn't hold a conversation with, so this relationship is doomed to fail.
Luke - ...is Luke capable of this sort of relationship? I'm not big on the whole expanded canon, but I know that he ends up with Mara Jade, who is a bad-ass fighter. Also, it depends on what Luke Skywalker. Beginning of the movie, I don't think Luke's had any communication with a girl who wasn't working on farms that produced...whatever it was they produced on that farm. By the end, he's a Jedi, focused on his goals. Unless Bella learns how to use the Force and a light saber, he'd have no reason to give her much thought at all.
Sherlock - ...impossible. Every version of Sherlock Holmes has him either detached from any sexual interests, or into Irene Adler (his intellectual equal, thus an intriguing anomaly for him), or Watson (thus making him gay, and TOTALLY not interested in Bella). It's not so much that Sherlock wouldn't like Bella. He's INCAPABLE of liking her.
...that's it in a nutshell. ^_^
I'm with Anthony on HP (don't know the others well enough to comment, ACTUALLY kinda remembered Skywalker being boring enough to be a good match, based on other comments I'd say I'm wrong :P)Harry is awkward as hell with girls, he even awkwardly forgets Hermione IS one now and then till she starts crying or having feelings. Harry and Bella would only get together through a blind date or a desperate willyougototheballwithme because someone needs a date. While on this date, however it happened, silence would stretch oooooon and oooooon till Bella said something "quirky" or "genuine" or "in-the-moment" or "irreverantly clever" like .... "You kinda have an accent when you talk. Are you british or something?"
Harry would stare at her, chuckle awkwardly, and say something dry in return. He'd soon make an excuse to leave. He'd probably let her find her own way home but he'd definitely pick up the bill if it was a restaurant. He's not ungallant after all.
Samantha wrote: "I'm with Anthony on HP (don't know the others well enough to comment, ACTUALLY kinda remembered Skywalker being boring enough to be a good match, based on other comments I'd say I'm wrong :P)Harr..."
I had almost forgotten about the Yule Ball! The one where he literally forgets his date is there and lets her fade into the scenery. THAT would be Bella Swan, only she'd go off to stare at that Cedric Diggory guy, and wonder why he looked oddly familiar...
Anthony wrote: "...only she'd go off to stare at that Cedric Diggory guy, and wonder why he looked oddly familiar..."Holy crap. How did I miss that obvious joke. Bella into HP crossover would almost be enjoyable for book 4 only.
Samantha wrote: "Anthony wrote: "...only she'd go off to stare at that Cedric Diggory guy, and wonder why he looked oddly familiar..."Holy crap. How did I miss that obvious joke. Bella into HP crossover would alm..."
I wouldn't mind a Twilight/HP crossover in general. Just have Edward Cullen switch places with Cedric Diggory, and have them do the maze scene together. ^_^
...of course, I'd much rather hope for a Twilight/Buffy crossover, or--better yet--Twilight/Hellsing. Seriously, even for the fans of the book, you know that would be fun to watch.
It could work! Harry DID go for Cedric's girl, with Cedward in the mix who knows? Maybe the Harry/Bella plot could play out, short as it may be.
Harry would never date Bella. Luke wouldn't let it pass th first date.
Sherlock would chuckle and leave.
All three of them would inevitably tire of her ineptitude, and slit her throat.Sherlock would snap first, and no one would ever find the body. Harry would snap second and likely feed her to Aragogs family. Luke would last the longest out of sheer desperation but ultimately will follow in his father's foot steps, and Bella would be the final piece to his demise to the dark side.
Bad idea boys, Bella is a selfish whiner with an incredible aptitude for not only breaking hearts but driving her victims insane.
Harry would have Hermoine cast a spell to get rid of her.Bella would drive Sherlock to an extra large dose of cocaine.
Luke might actually stick around for a while: he was so eager to be a hero that, even though he'd want to, he would feel bad about dropping her; Leia would have to pull her aside and tell her to stay away from her brother, or Han would ditch her on an asteroid.
Disaster
Holmes feels no love, so he would never even look at her. Unless she was the key to a case, in which he'd get proposed to her under pseudonym and once the case is over, vanish.
Harry will be to busy to be in a relationship with her. I think Bella will fall in love with a death eater or even the dark lord himself and will end up being avada kedavra'd by bellatrix herself. Sherlock will never ever date Bella Swan most especially since her brain is as small as pea. Sherlock will end up putting up more disguises as ever while he avoids her.
Luke Skywalker might date her for a while - he likes to show off his light saber. Plus Bella is the type of girl he'd get to save more than once. she's that stupid.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
