Repello Muggletum: a Hogwarts Roleplay discussion

36 views
Discussion Group > Reasoning with Vampires

Comments Showing 1-20 of 20 (20 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Maggie, Disapparition is my middle name. (last edited Feb 01, 2012 02:46PM) (new)

Maggie (maggie-swift) | 477 comments Mod
So. There's this tumblr--don't know if anyone else has heard of it--called 'Reasoning with Vampires.' I. Love. It. I've read the whole darn thing. It's this girl, Dana, who's taken apart Twilight and New Moon, and has just started on Eclipse, methodically going through and scanning the pages into her computer and editing them. She points out all the hilarious little flaws, nitpicks on excessive comma and semicolon use, and generally pulls apart the entire book for her tumblr. It's amazing, laugh-out-loud, hysterically funny stuff, and y'all need to check it out, now. You won't be disappointed. ;)

Ciao for now,

Magggggggdalena!


message 2: by Jo (new)

Jo (Penname8) | 3183 comments This is great. Proof to demostrate to my sister Twilight isn't "well-written".


message 3: by Vanessa (new)

Vanessa | 7885 comments Mod
*follows Thera into the cyber world of tumblr* :D


message 4: by Jo (new)

Jo (Penname8) | 3183 comments I cannot reason with Meyer bats.


message 5: by *~Silvypoo~* (Chaser of Artemis), Witch of Rebirth (new)

*~Silvypoo~* (Chaser of Artemis) (Silverfur) | 977 comments Mod
XD Nice.


message 6: by *~Silvypoo~* (Chaser of Artemis), Witch of Rebirth (new)

*~Silvypoo~* (Chaser of Artemis) (Silverfur) | 977 comments Mod
XD Nice.


message 7: by *~Silvypoo~* (Chaser of Artemis), Witch of Rebirth (new)

*~Silvypoo~* (Chaser of Artemis) (Silverfur) | 977 comments Mod
XD Nice.


message 8: by Maggie, Disapparition is my middle name. (new)

Maggie (maggie-swift) | 477 comments Mod
NicE? :D


message 9: by Vanessa (new)

Vanessa | 7885 comments Mod
Triple-level niceness. xD

MAGGIE~ *glomp*


message 10: by Maggie, Disapparition is my middle name. (new)

Maggie (maggie-swift) | 477 comments Mod
VANNNNNNNY!


message 11: by *~Silvypoo~* (Chaser of Artemis), Witch of Rebirth (new)

*~Silvypoo~* (Chaser of Artemis) (Silverfur) | 977 comments Mod
So I tried to look at the site, and all I could rid was people asking questions and posts.


Iviana (The Sign Painter) Mʘ‿ʘP (thesignpainter) | 8158 comments Mod
Exactly? It's trying to reason with Twilight's absolutely horrid logic.



message 13: by *~Silvypoo~* (Chaser of Artemis), Witch of Rebirth (new)

*~Silvypoo~* (Chaser of Artemis) (Silverfur) | 977 comments Mod
Oh! I was expecting something different. Let's just say its late and I feel like shet, so yeahhh. I'm kind of out of it. XD


Iviana (The Sign Painter) Mʘ‿ʘP (thesignpainter) | 8158 comments Mod
xD No worries. ^_^



message 15: by *~Silvypoo~* (Chaser of Artemis), Witch of Rebirth (new)

*~Silvypoo~* (Chaser of Artemis) (Silverfur) | 977 comments Mod
I know, right? It's all genius.

Pfffft. As if you had the coordination I be a showgirl. XD


message 16: by Jo (new)

Jo (Penname8) | 3183 comments Iviana (The Sign Painter) wrote: "xD No worries. ^_^
"


xD


message 17: by . (new)

. (onawhim) | 1139 comments I like Reasoning with Vampires but unfortunately most of the flaws she points out have been done by JK as well ... They're not really enough to make a book 'bad', it's just fun to nitpick at Twilight. Kind of like how if you hate a plain-looking person you'll go out of your way to be like 'OMG HER NOSE IS WONKY AND .5 MILLIMETRES OFF CENTRE'.


message 18: by Jo (new)

Jo (Penname8) | 3183 comments Good point. Though Stephanie Meyer's choice of words is odd. Try to hiss the word thirty.


message 19: by *~Silvypoo~* (Chaser of Artemis), Witch of Rebirth (new)

*~Silvypoo~* (Chaser of Artemis) (Silverfur) | 977 comments Mod
It sounds like you're trying to say the word "dirty" with a lisp. XD


message 20: by Jo (new)

Jo (Penname8) | 3183 comments Exactly.


back to top