Twilight
discussion
Actor to play Edward instead of Robert Pattinson
Nicole wrote: "Madi (Wolf Girl) wrote: "Nicole wrote: "Forever Alone Bella is what I call a troll. She/he/it posts the most ridiculous things to get others to react. She/he/it thinks they are funny."
What is y..."
Well, if you're alowed to say what you want to say, then she is too. I agree with Disneytederfan. If you don't like it... ignore it!
What is y..."
Well, if you're alowed to say what you want to say, then she is too. I agree with Disneytederfan. If you don't like it... ignore it!

Thank you!

wait, who's parent?
and, no, I didn't point it out, either. I was just backing nicole up b/c I see no reason to call her mean just b/c she pointed out something quite obvious...

Meanwhile, I post whatever I want. Thanks so much.


Meanwhile, I post whatever ..."
Funny how you tell us to get over it when you're complaining how Forever alone Bella posts.

Nope. She sold that right in her contract. I think she probably had some influence but she's a writer not a producer and since they have more experience with actors... I think Robert did OK. I was a Jacob fan anyway but I don't think he did a bad job as Edward.


Nope. She sold that right in her c..."
yeah, I don't think authors should be allowed to put whoever (whomever?) they want in the movies...producers know more about all that stuff.
Nicole, I dont mean to be disrespectful, but I think that you're the one getting on everyone's nerves rihhf now. "Im going to back Forever Alone Bella up b/c I'm pointing out something quite obvious"…

what? I understand that you're mocking me in some way, but it didn't really make any sense...

Not to be disrespectful to you, but I simply said that I thought she was a troll then y'all starting in on me. Of course I'm going to defend my position.
Kirby wrote: "Madi (Wolf Girl) wrote: "Nicole, I dont mean to be disrespectful, but I think that you're the one getting on everyone's nerves rihhf now. "Im going to back Forever Alone Bella up b/c I'm pointing o..."
NO! im not trying to mock anyone. sorry if it came off like that. ;)
NO! im not trying to mock anyone. sorry if it came off like that. ;)
Nicole wrote: "Madi (Wolf Girl) wrote: "Nicole, I dont mean to be disrespectful, but I think that you're the one getting on everyone's nerves rihhf now. "Im going to back Forever Alone Bella up b/c I'm pointing o..."
Ok. before this gets ugly, can we just try to stop insulting everyone? please? nicole?
Ok. before this gets ugly, can we just try to stop insulting everyone? please? nicole?

Thanks for the apology and I apologize if I came across as nasty.
Nicole wrote: "It came across as me being attacked for my opinion. That's how I reacted.
Thanks for the apology and I apologize if I came across as nasty."
It's ok. Can we all just be friends?
Thanks for the apology and I apologize if I came across as nasty."
It's ok. Can we all just be friends?

quite all right, perhaps I was being a bit sensitive. :)
It's ok, Kirby. I'm just trying to make sure that Forever Alone Bella isn't insulted for no reason. Sorry to both you and Nicole if I was a little too straitforward. I tend to get a little sensitive about people being picked on.

Same here. It's funny though, I don't mind people getting picked on in books.
animaldisneyreaderfan4lyfe7 wrote: "Madi (Wolf Girl) wrote: "It's ok, Kirby. I'm just trying to make sure that Forever Alone Bella isn't insulted for no reason. Sorry to both you and Nicole if I was a little too straitforward. I tend..."
Well, you can't really help them XD
Well, you can't really help them XD

Haha, true :D
animaldisneyreaderfan4lyfe7 wrote: "Madi (Wolf Girl) wrote: "animaldisneyreaderfan4lyfe7 wrote: "Madi (Wolf Girl) wrote: "It's ok, Kirby. I'm just trying to make sure that Forever Alone Bella isn't insulted for no reason. Sorry to bo..."
But hey *shrugs* I've yeled at the mean characters b4. Like Rosalie! I didn't like how she constantly piked on Jake. ;( Made me so sad
But hey *shrugs* I've yeled at the mean characters b4. Like Rosalie! I didn't like how she constantly piked on Jake. ;( Made me so sad

It was funny how Jacob did blonde jokes to her
animaldisneyreaderfan4lyfe7 wrote: "Madi (Wolf Girl) wrote: "animaldisneyreaderfan4lyfe7 wrote: "Madi (Wolf Girl) wrote: "animaldisneyreaderfan4lyfe7 wrote: "Madi (Wolf Girl) wrote: "It's ok, Kirby. I'm just trying to make sure that ..."
Yeah! :D Jake's funny!
Yeah! :D Jake's funny!

ikr? I love him :)
animaldisneyreaderfan4lyfe7 wrote: "Madi (Wolf Girl) wrote: "animaldisneyreaderfan4lyfe7 wrote: "Madi (Wolf Girl) wrote: "animaldisneyreaderfan4lyfe7 wrote: "Madi (Wolf Girl) wrote: "animaldisneyreaderfan4lyfe7 wrote: "Madi (Wolf Gir..."
hes soooo cute! his personality seems to leap off the page.
hes soooo cute! his personality seems to leap off the page.

Yes, btw not being rude but you said he's so cute as a question by accident Lol
yeah. sorry bout that. i fixed it XD

YES! i agree with the passion of a 1,000,000 suns!
And then Lucy Hale can play bella.

I think the High School Musical kid would have been a good Edward. He doesn't exactly look the part, but I would have believed him. What is that kid's name?? lol
Zack Efron...that's the one. Also, they could have gotten a young looking older actor and that would have come off well. No way is Cedric over a hundred years old.

The one thing that irks me about the movie is that Jake is shorter than Edward. It was sort of a big deal in the book that Jake was a bigger guy. While it's true his muscles are bigger in the movie, Pattinson is taller than Lautner. Just one of those things that stick out in my mind.

As far as Jake being shorter, I agree. But there was never a moment when I didn't think Jacob could have kicked Edward's butt and that just made him SEEM bigger to me.
Lisa wrote: "Well, Nicole, it's Hollywood - they can make anyone look like anyone. I think I would have liked to see Efron act the part. I trust his ability more.
As far as Jake being shorter, I agree. ..."
Exactly Lisa! Jake seemed bigger than eddy XD. IMDb says that Taylor is 5' 10 and a half inches. It also says that rob is 6' 1" tall so there isn't a HUGE difference.
As far as Jake being shorter, I agree. ..."
Exactly Lisa! Jake seemed bigger than eddy XD. IMDb says that Taylor is 5' 10 and a half inches. It also says that rob is 6' 1" tall so there isn't a HUGE difference.

If the height wasn't such a big part of the book, I wouldn't have cared. Meyer made this big point about Jacob being like 6'6". There should have been a big height difference.

If the height wasn't such a big part of the book, I wouldn't have cared. Meyer made..."
I think she said Jacob was 7 feet tall in the book. Unless I'm misunderstanding

That's what I've been trying to tell everyone. Matt Damon is Jason Bourne, exactly.
Thanks Cherylcarnevale.

Perhaps...I'm going off memory.
That even furthers my point though. There should have been a bigger height difference between Lautner and Pattinson with Lautner being much taller. As it stands, Pattinson is taller. It bugged me a bit about the movie.
Nicole wrote: "animaldisneyreaderfan4lyfe7 wrote: "I think she said Jacob was 7 feet tall in the book. Unless I'm misunderstanding"
Perhaps...I'm going off memory.
That even furthers my point though. There shou..."
Jake is supposed to be 6' 9" inches. Bella says so in eclipse
Perhaps...I'm going off memory.
That even furthers my point though. There shou..."
Jake is supposed to be 6' 9" inches. Bella says so in eclipse

Perhaps...I'm going off memory.
That even furthers my point tho..."
Oh


You're fine. Post whatever you'd like. I shouldn't have assumed your a troll or said anything. I'm sorry.

You're fine. Post whatever you'd like. I shouldn't have ..."
Well at least you realize it.

I have feelings, too. I didn't mean to come across that way and I sincerely thought she was being a troll.
I was corrected. I apologized. I suppose if this continues I'll just leave the board.

I have feelings, too? I didn't mean to come acr..."
Let me rephrase. I'm glad that you said sorry to her. All conflict aside.

Thanks for clarifying! Let bygones be bygones and all that.

Thanks for clarifying! Let bygones be bygones and all that."
You're welcome, thanks for hearing me out

Henry Cavill would have b..."
I love you ;)
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
What, are you her parent? Leave what she does alone. Some members annoy me but I don't point it out.