The Throne of Fire
discussion
Who is a better narrorator: Carter or Sadie?
message 1:
by
Hannah
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jan 25, 2012 06:52PM
I like Sadie's pov better but that's just me. Who do you think is better?
reply
|
flag
I like both... Sadie's pov has a bit more personality in it, but I like both. Sometimes it depends what part the book is at too.I like Sadie's a bit more though
Sadie!!!! I like her attitude :D
i think carter is more serious than sadie. but i like them both :)
I like them both :D Carter has more of a grown up perspective(most of the time)... where as Sadie has more spunk and attitude.
Sadie, because everything is so much more interesting!
Sadie because I love her attitude and spunk. Carter pov is sounds more serious than the Sadie pov. I think Carter pov can be a bit boring at times.
sadie. she's so sassy about everything.
Sadie. Carter's 100% by the book.
Both are pretty good but I just think it really depends on whats happening in the moment in the book. when bad things are happenning Sadie worries alot and then reacts while Carter just analyzes and attacks. i like Sadie's attitude and Carters'braver personality
I like them both. Carter has the more mature narration, but I like Sophie's dry wit when she narrates as well. I also think it's kind of funny to read what's going on in the background, like Sadie punching her brother, or Carter telling Sadie off about something she said!
Sonora wrote: "I like them both. Carter has the more mature narration, but I like Sophie's dry wit when she narrates as well. I also think it's kind of funny to read what's going on in the background, like Sadi..." \ Thats what I love about the Kane Chronicles, the humor.
Carter has adrag to it, so SADIE I look forward to her parts
Jimmy wrote: "Sonora wrote: "I like them both. Carter has the more mature narration, but I like Sophie's dry wit when she narrates as well. I also think it's kind of funny to read what's going on in the backgr..."That is what I love about all of Rick Riordan's books!
SAAAAAAAAAAAAAADIE!!!
Well Sadie has a awesome attitude and Carter is serious, they are both good.
Luke wrote: "Well Sadie has a awesome attitude and Carter is serious, they are both good."
Exactly Luke!
Exactly Luke!
SADIE!!!!! I love her British accent. I really hope she doesnt lose it!
Nya wrote: "SADIE!!!!! I love her British accent. I really hope she doesnt lose it!"Amen! That's what I love about her!
Sadie's pov is my favorite. She's so unpredictable. I love her combat boots!!!
Sarah wrote: "Sadie's pov is my favorite. She's so unpredictable. I love her combat boots!!!"Me too!
Nya wrote: "SADIE!!!!! I love her British accent. I really hope she doesnt lose it!"Sadly, she does start to loose her accent in The Throne of Fire. I wouldn't be surprised if she lost it completly in The Serpants Shadow.
Curlygirly wrote: "Nya wrote: "SADIE!!!!! I love her British accent. I really hope she doesnt lose it!"Sadly, she does start to loose her accent in The Throne of Fire. I wouldn't be surprised if she lost it complet..."
i know. you can tell she is starting to loose it. She needs to move back to England.
Lol so true. I miss how she used to say hullo...now she says hello. Why does Rick have to ruin everything.
well it is human nature.
If by human nature you mean to mess things up, that is incorrect. That is an author's nature alone! Trust me--I know! =P
no, i mean he is following human nature. i use to have a British accent but i moved to america and i have completely lost it. you adapt to your surroundings.
Oooh makes sense now. That's so cool you really used to live in England? My friends used to live in England but they like it much better in the U.S.
I like the us better.
Nya wrote: "I like the us better."Hm...personally, I would like England better. I can see how one loses the accent over time. It's kind of sad really--I like british accents!
me too!^
Sadie, oh Sadie,you are an inspiration. I am loving my new combat boots. Yes teh people who surround me are creeped out! I love Sadie! Her narrating is way cooler!
I'm sorry Carter, but Sadie is the better narrator, even though you're AWESOME at combat magic.
Carter says a lot of funny things in his head, while Sadie says funny things out loud, so I'd say it's a tie.
I don't know why, but I like Carter's better
I like Sadie, idk why. She just makes everything so awesome.
Both are very good. With Carter, you kind of learn more about the history since he's older and smarter so you understand the gods better. Sadie makes us laugh since she is this modern British diva who always chews gum and makes fun of Carter. I guess Sadie, since she is more like me than Carter. (Hahah just kidding they both rock!)
Kathy ~Kat luvvs Skrillex and the Dubstep~ wrote: "I don't know why, but I like Carter's better"I prefer Carter too! :3
I think SWadie's is amazing just because of her additude and cleverness but Cater really tells the story and puts me in the bookI also think its funy how all these girls are saying how Anubis is so hot and stuff even though they only have a descrition
(mind my spelling)
I like Carter's POV!
Carter. Most of Sadie's POV is whinging about Anubis and Walt. She's quite witty and has attitude, but Carter is more interesting.
@ Sean: Look up 'kane chronicles anubis' on Google Images.
@ Sean: Look up 'kane chronicles anubis' on Google Images.
Sadie ! i find her funny .
@Shahdia thanks for thatI never knew there was already pictures
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
