The Throne of Fire
discussion
Who is a better narrorator: Carter or Sadie?
message 51:
by
Cali
(new)
-
rated it 2 stars
Mar 20, 2013 03:43AM
I prefer Sadie... she had more sarcasm :D
reply
|
flag
To hard........but my favourite bits are when they narrate one after the other, and they start complaining about their siblings.
sadie is funnier than her serious brother but there are sum parts where carter is much more good than sadie.it depends on the mood of the incidents in the book though.i think both the kane siblings excels at storytelling!
it's funnier when it's Sadie's turn. i like Carter but he's very serious haha
Sadie! but Carter is not bad.
Both of them! Carter's discriptions are a little better as he is more knowledgeable when it comes Egyptian mythology. Sadie has this cooler attitude which make her parts a little more witty. Both of them are really funny.
I honestly don't care who's better. I love Sadie's storiesss better!
Anna-Cosette wrote: "I like both... Sadie's pov has a bit more personality in it, but I like both. Sometimes it depends what part the book is at too.I like Sadie's a bit more though"
I agree with this review completely. I enjoy Sadie's narration more, but I listen to the audiobooks and the narrator for her is AMAZING! Carter's narrator is good too, just not as much.
Mae wrote: "Sadie!!!! I like her attitude :D"Could't agree more
I gotta go with Carter, but they both keep it interesting.
I like both of them, but if i had to hang out with one of them, id choose Sadie. Her personality seems really cool. I'd also stay around her to see if I develop a british accent. :)
I like Sadie better. She 's much more fun and has a cool attitude :)
hmmm that is hard . . . I'd say Carter
Carter. Sadie's always bringing up all the stuff from the beginning of the book going into long stories so you even forget what the stories about
sadie!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Definitely Sadie! I luv her accent
I personally love Sadie's attitude!!!
Sadie really connects with the reader
Definitely Sadie. Reading her perspective is fun. :) Carter's point of view is intriguing but it is normally too serious. I guess that's because he is older :/
I like both, but I preferred Carter's POV because I could relate to him a lot more, I guess...
Sadie. Carter is great, but I like Sadie's POV because she's so witty and attitudinal (yes...this is now a word) and I just love her style. Carter is funny, but not as witty as Sadie.
I dont really like kane chronicles but sadie all the way
I think Sadie puts a bit more energy into her narrations, and so therefore I must say Sadie's narration is better. I think it is very close in "who has the best narration" for me, though.
True, Carter does give more knowledge and keep the story moving more than Sadie does.
Sadie, she is hilarious!
i prefer sadie she's just more fun and enjoyable
Both Carter and Sadie have their pros and cons. I like Carter because he's more mature (most of the time) and nerdy. He gives us the history that we need. I also see more growth in the way Carter thinks as he develops into a stronger character. He starts out as a weak nerdy guy and throughout the series we see him become a warrior and hero. There are times when he's a bit dull (and there's one time I found him very frustrating which was when he chose to save Zia instead helping his own sister) but I like he more of the two.Sadie sounds more like a teenager. She brings wit and humor to the story. However, I can't stand her narration. She's rude and inconsiderate to a lot of people and very selfish - especially when she puts the destiny of the world on hold for her birthday. I can't stand it when she calls Carter thick and stupid (though the one time I did agree with Sadie was when Carter chose to save Zia over helping his own sister - I can't get over that one). Sadie is funnier, but her rude and inconsiderate comments ruin her character and narration for me.
Carter, I heard too much of Sadie's problems.
Carter... You see, Sadie reminds me a bit of Piper, not as bad of course. At first, i once liked Sadie's more, but after the first book, i liked Carter's better. Sadie...Keeps on blabbing on about her problems. If she was real, i probably WOULD NOT be friends with her. No offense because she is amazing.
Carter actually, i think he has a better personality than Sadie. I think he's hilarious. Because he's more awkward than Sade.
Sadie just is personal and if she was real, she would be with those people i don't like xD
Sadie, she's so feisty! But you get less biased stuff from Carter, so that's a toughy for me....
I love Sadie's character she's awesome. I find that I sticky note more when Sadie narrorates. When I read along with the audio books the narrorator for her was amazing. Don't get me wrong Carter's ok to but Sadie's better in discription besides Carter's ,as Sadie calles him, "a human encyclopedia" he gives too many facts.
I dont know... personaly I like Carter's better but mabey thats just because: 1. Im a boy so hearing the story from a girl is a little strange (no offense) and 2. because Carter's pov was first in both "The Red Pyramid" and "The Throne of Fire" Carter's pov was first and I don't like finally adapting to one pov just to switch to the other...
I read these series a while ago but I remember being annoyed when Sadies turn ended and waiting for it to be her turn again
I think Sadie is the better because I can relate to her more than I can relate to Carter.
i like both but i prefer cater more than sadie idk i just do
Sadie. I get uninterested in Carter's chapters for some reason...
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
