Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
question
Who here was sad when in the movie part 2 they didn't fully show all of Snapes memories of him & Lilly?
Cat
Dec 26, 2011 11:55AM
I loved this part of the book, I was sobbing because he loved Lilly so much and their childhood memories were so sweet. And when the movie part 2 came out I was so excited to see it, and they didn't really show it, they just brushed on the memories but it wasn't anywhere near as sweet and detailed as the book. I mean I knew it wouldn't be but I was disappointed in how they didn't treat it as a very important part of the book even though it was.
reply
flag
ya that made me pretty mad!! i think Snape was very misunderstood in the books and in the movie they still made him pretty much the bad guy still!! :(
I was sad/upset/angry that they made James Potter seem like the villain in Prince's Tale, how they made it seem like James 'stole' Lily from Snape and gah it was awful. I really wanted to shout that it wasn't what happened. Alan Rickman's acting was flawless though. Just all the awards.
yes I was sad that they left out all those good memories out of the movie. As a metter of fact they did that a lot in the this movie, they took out all the good and detailed parts from the book. If they just put a few more good memories or the speech he made in the book when he was about to kill Voldemort and took out the part where both Harry and Voldemort fell from one of the towers then maybe the movie would have been much better then it was.
it was my favorite part of the book and i was very disappointed. they left out the most important thing! it wasn't fair
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
