Ancient & Medieval Historical Fiction discussion
General Discussions
>
What Are You Reading Right Now? ( Hwæt béon ðu bocrædung?)


Some of the character development is quite good.



I tend to agree on your fantasy views here, Jane. The series was mentioned in the Roman thread in the early days of the group, but I was always at ill ease with telling people that the Manda Scott Boudica series is historical fiction.
It really is more in the sub genre of historical fantasy. It is one of the main reason I started but never finished the Boudica series.
However, if you can decide to go on with the other Manda Scott (M.C. Scott) series. The Rome one that a few of us have been talking about lately, the author has gotten away from that heavy 'dreamer' fantasy. They are more straight historical fiction. M.C. Scott

Terry Pratchett wrote to beware of any appliance which instructions manual weights more than the thing itself. Now they cheat putting instructions online...


This is the kind of response I hope to get when I select the group reads. To help people find new favourite authors or books that inspire them. :-)


That series sounds interesting, so I'll have to look into it. The library doesn't have it...darn it!
What interests me most about the 'Dreaming' series is following Boudicca's brother, Bán [aka Valerius].

The Genghis series doesn't interest me, but I thought I'd try Rome series to get a sense of Iggulden's style since I've never read any of his.



And I started







It has been so long since I read this series I'd forgotten about them in our discussions on her other work. Thanks for reminding me.



Rome: The Eagle of the Twelfth

You will love the Heaven Tree books. I read them years ago and have never forgotten them.

I keep watching for her historical fiction (not her mystery stuff) to come on sale at bookstores, because I want to own them.


My next read will probably be The Kingmaker's Daughter."
I am almost finished with it. Hilary Mandel is an amazing writer. I don't know if her perspective on Thomas Cromwell is accurate, but I definitely think differently about him now.

Not accurate. Plausible.
Why didn't you come up with that short, succinct gem in the historical accuracy thread. :-)


It is the latest entry in his series. The series is a Napoleonic British Naval series ala Alexander Kent or Hortio Hornblower, but a step down in quality. That said I've enjoyed most of them.


I liked it. It's purely escapist, so save it for when you're in the mood for escapism. Iggulden played absolute havoc with history -- Caesar and Brutus boyhood friends, now come on! -- and pure adventure. It's very readable, author's style not bad, and was a page-turner.


You will love the Heaven Tree books. I read them years ago and have n..."
I finished them and they were some of the best hf I've ever read.


Very true, Sharon.


I liked it. It's purely escapist, so save it for when you're in the mood for escapism. Igg..."
I think this is why I have put this book off for as long as I have. I don't find Iggulden the greatest writer and he relies heavily on b grade action to impress... (I thought he was pretty good in the first two books of his Khan series, but I read then a long time ago when I was first starting out in the historical fiction genre.....wasn't much into the rest of that series)...and that's why I have avoided book one in his Rome series. Worried it is not something I would like these days.



I liked it. It's purely escapist, so save it for when you're in the mood for e..."
You have to be in a particular mood for escapism; it was kind of pulpy. I have 4 criteria for what I consider a good book:
1. quality of writing, including descriptive passages
2. good, interesting story
3. characterization and character development, with sympathetic characters
4. for hf: at least historically PLAUSIBLE, and you learn something of the period. 'Author's note' and/or bibliography a plus.
Iggulden got a C for #1 and B or B+ for #2. I wasn't able to rate my other two criteria.

What did you end up rating it? I don't think you said.

If you ever look at my goodreads books I've rated, the 4 and 5 stars meet or surpass my criteria; [of course everything is subjective]. You can see I've really got an eclectic selection, except my 'favorites' are mostly [but not all] hf from a particular ancient period... :)



A fantastic book by a writer at the very top of his game. The rest of his series was excellent, too. If you like his style, you should try Nightrunners of Bengal and The Ravi Lancers by John Masters. different eras, different locations, but very similar styles.
Nightrunners of BengalThe Ravi Lancers,


It's definitely unusual -- the story of Roman Emperor Elagabalus, one of Rome's most outlandish and bizarre rulers, in the 3rd century AD. Elagabalus really was historically that unbelievable--Nero or Commodus had nothing on him. The purported memoirs of one of his Praetorians tells his biography. I love Duggan's wry cynicism and snatches of dry and sardonic humor.
Books mentioned in this topic
M*A*S*H: A Novel About Three Army Doctors (other topics)A Court of Betrayal (other topics)
Imperium (other topics)
The Handfasted Wife (other topics)
The Swan-Daughter (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Robert Harris (other topics)Carol McGrath (other topics)
Carol McGrath (other topics)
Carol McGrath (other topics)
Ken Follett (other topics)
More...
Got it waiting on my kindle to read with you guys next month!