Ancient & Medieval Historical Fiction discussion
General Discussions
>
What Are You Reading Right Now? ( Hwæt béon ðu bocrædung?)
message 1701:
by
Terri, Wyrd bið ful aræd
(new)
Feb 02, 2013 04:44PM

reply
|
flag

Oh the writing is still good and the story so far is strong enough to keep me interested. So although those things I mentioned make the beginning seem not totally original to me the characters themselves are not straight copies from anyone else. If it maintains the quality that it has so far I'm thinking I 'll be likely to give it four stars, so unless something changes markedly well worth the effort. I'm up to page 68 now and already starting to form the more positive judgment that I thought would take much longer to develop 18 pages ago.

And the characters were all enjoyable, even the bad guys.



Yes it is the first Bobby, I liked it but found it a bit inconsistent in places. Felt the second was a bit stronger and worth 4 stars rather than three I gave the first one. This series is set during the first Punic War and is based around the naval conflict. I've recently finished the first book in Ben Kane's series on the Second Punic War Hannibal: Enemy of Rome and enjoyed that, so you may be interested in that at some point.




While the books are stand alone, they are less stand alone further into the series. Uhtred is a complex character with a complex history and a complex relationship with other key players in the story. Coming into the series at #5 in the series the reader is relying solely on the story and plot to maintain interest and I am not sure The Burning Land can pull it off in that respect. Whereas coming into #5 after reading the previous 4, the reader would have a different approach to the book and the Uhtred character.
(Deborah, could you please spoiler your stuff about the hostage. Thanks for that..:)..)



and started




To be honest, although The Burning Land was one of my faves of the series, I don't remember that part at all either. lol!

The writing was adequate and I was interested in the time and era ..."
You should really enjoy


While the books are stand alone, they are less stand alone further..."
Sorry about the spoilers Terri; I actually thought I had put it in properly, but it does not seem to be working so I have just deleted the whole post :(
I was quite likeing Uhtred but did not actually realise it was #5. I checked the cover to see if I was coming in at the begining or the center and it gave me no hint. I think I will return this one to the library and go back and find the first one. though I would still love to hear other peoples take on the hostage situation...
In the meantime I am really loving The Whale RoadThe Whale Road it is so detailed and descriptive I think I can smell the arctic ocean.

I think the only place would be in those first few pages where it has the other books listed.

Ah well, it Cornwell can go back on the to-read pile for a while.






or

soon when I finish my current reading."
Good luck with Pride of Carthage, Jane.


....and good luck with Ben's first book, Bobby. :-) Let us know how you get on.


I really liked this book. I thought it was very much like David Gemmell's The Complete Chronicles of the Jerusalem Man. But that could just be me thinking that all this dystopian stuff is the same. :)


I started


He kind of reminds me of me if l were tall, good-looking, brave and interesting to women.
Am reading



He kind of reminds me of me if l were tall, good-looking, brave and interesting to women...."
Hahaha! :D

Sovereign was a wonderful read.
I have just finished Revelation and didn't enjoy it as much (still good though: 4 stars). That may have something to do with the fact I read it so close to Sovereign. Hard book to follow.


Also, did you know that a new book to the series is scheduled to be released in mid June 2013? The Kindle version is showing as $4.99 on Amazon (pre-order.) Here's that link:
http://www.amazon.com/Canterbury-Murd...


Oh, thank you Dawn...didn't even think to check GR ;-)

Glad to hear you are enjoying it so far, Chris.

I really like a good long book, 600 pages plus if possible, l read way to fast and get though shorter ones to quickly.
Keep looking at suggested titles and changing my mind.
Sigh !

Next I'd better get on with God of War that I am halfway through.

I am currently reading the group read book, Mercenaries then I have the other group read book. Then I have some others out from the library to finish the month off.
Books mentioned in this topic
M*A*S*H: A Novel About Three Army Doctors (other topics)A Court of Betrayal (other topics)
Imperium (other topics)
The Handfasted Wife (other topics)
The Swan-Daughter (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Robert Harris (other topics)Carol McGrath (other topics)
Carol McGrath (other topics)
Carol McGrath (other topics)
Ken Follett (other topics)
More...