Jem vs. Simon

[Daylighter, Mizpah]

We already have a topic for Will vs. Jace, I thought we should have one for Jem & Simon as well.
So who's better out of the two?

[Jennifer]

Good one! And hard one! I LOVE THEM BOTH! But I must say Jem is my all time favorite out of everyone!

[Daylighter, Mizpah]

I love them both too, but I really can't decide which one I like more!

[WinterRose]

I'm not crazy about either, but I hated Simon until CoFA, once he was done pining over Clary lol. I liked him much more in CoFA. LOVE him and Izzy together. I guess if I'd have to choose I'd say Simon. (The Jace/Kyle/Simon moments were such win in CoFA)

[Palak]

I vote Jem!!!

[Margaret]

Jem. I love his character so much more than Simon's. He's got more... wait for it... depth. (Shut up, I know that sounds corny! =P) I never really liked Simon but I do love Jem. :)

[Rachel]

I like Simon well enough; but am MUCH more interested in Jem. I think because even though Simon liked Clary and Jem most obviously loves Tessa- Clary never loved Simon BACK. Not really. It was never a proper love-triangle because of that; and Tessa is absolutely torn. Clary only ever dated Simon because she thought that Jace was her brother, which is totally gross.

[Darlene]

Rachel wrote: "I like Simon well enough; but am MUCH more interested in Jem. I think because even though Simon liked Clary and Jem most obviously loves Tessa- Clary never loved Simon BACK. Not really. It was neve..."

I agree. The love triangle in TID is actually real

[Megan]

Simon is awesome. I like him a lot better than Jem. Though i didn't like him up until CoFA. Jem just doesn't seem to have a personality besides...polite.

[Hana]

Well, i love both of them but i am more addicted to Simon.

[Breeze]

I kind of feel like the two are incomparable (is that a word?), or at least for me. This is because Simon and Jem's traits don't really have anything in common. Simon's all cuteness and geek, while Jem is all beauty and intelligence. If I had to choose one... I can't. Ha, I actually just can't. I love them both too much. <3 Love triangle-wise, Jem's part is better than Simon's.

[Hana]

"The Breeze" wrote: "I kind of feel like the two are incomparable (is that a word?), or at least for me. This is because Simon and Jem's traits don't really have anything in common. Simon's all cuteness and geek, while..."

that's right...

[Geeny]

Jem all the way. He is the best!

[Don]

~ Simon and Jem has different personality and obviously, lifestyle. But, I can't decide. I pick BOTH as well! :)

[jmbswim]

Jem is so much better than Simon. Jem is the answer to everything

[Megan]

Jmbswim wrote: "Jem is so much better than Simon. Jem is the answer to everything"
Of course...

[jmbswim]

It's SO true.

[Carly]

I like Simon better... Jems so perfect, he makes it hard to say..... Never the less Simon is my fav!

[Michelle Herondale]

JEM!!!!!

[Caitie]

Jem obviously!!! <3

[Michelle Herondale]

I put up a picture of what I think Jem would look like under the movie topic.

[Ailyn]

Jem. Jem all the way. I just feel so much for him; plus, I think his character is much more developed and beautifully portrayed. This may also have to do with the fact that I am Chinese.

[[deleted user]]

simon is my second choice, actually third no sorry fourth.
first- will
second- jace
third- jem
fourth- simon
fifth-luke

[Belle2908]

Simon. Tho I don't like either much, I'm starting to like Simon a little better. (I'm halfway, or so, through CoLS)

[Shan]

how about none???

[Jess]

I'm sorry i love Jem way more them simon at lease Jem won't cheat

[Amiamo]

Simon!!

[Cheyenne]

Jem!!! :D

[Maya]

I absolutely love JEM/JAMES CARSTARS/ KE JIAN MING!!!
I love Will, Jace and Jem very much!
I dont exactly have an order for who I like more, so I'll just say that I love shadowhunter boys [ especially Herondales and Carstairs]

[Emiri]

Jem all the way!!

[Cheyenne]

♥ T.M.I ♥ wrote: "I absolutely love JEM/JAMES CARSTARS/ KE JIAN MING!!!
I love Will, Jace and Jem very much!
I dont exactly have an order for who I like more, so I'll just say that I love shadowhunter boys [ especia..."

I AGREE WITH YOU COMPLETELY c:

[Ana]

Ash wrote: "simon is my second choice, actually third no sorry fourth.
first- will
second- jace
third- jem
fourth- simon
fifth-luke"

lol I like them exactly in the same order as you :)

[Inês]

first now - simon
jace
jem
will
luke

[Lottie]

jem

[[deleted user]]

Go jem

[Nina]

SIMON!! HAND DOWN!! Simon is the funniest out of ALL of the series'!

[Jessica]

I do love them both but Jem is my Fav out of all of them <3

[Alcelinia]

yes, i do love them both...... simon is the funniest of all, and Jem is the sweetest thing..... LOve theeemmmm

[Enelra]

I like Simon. he is funny and loyal but i would pick Jem. Simon is a good friend anyone would love to have. but Jem is Mr. nice guy and mr dreamy combined together.

[Christina]

Oh! That's a tought question! What should I answer to that? Mmmm....maybe both!!!

[Madi]

Tough question, I like them both. I think Simon is one of my favourite characters in TMI (along with Izzy and Alec), but I definitely like Jem more.
He's just so sweet and kind and sensitive, and funny too.
It's gotta be Jem, hands down. :P

[miguel]

JEM. :)

[Rosie]

I HATE JEM SO MUCH HE BROKE MY HEART. HE PROPSED TO TESSA NOW WILL CANT BE WITH TESSA

besides, Simon's got sexy vampire mojo

[Abigail]

Um... I'm actually Team Jem... because if Will isn't here, Jem's the second best.

But that doesn't mean I don't like Simon... I would just prefer Jem in a romantic relationship.

[Lo]

I dunno really...I think they might be both friend zoned, but more likely Jem would be not.

[Melissa]

Simon!

[Jamie]

they're both so loyal and sweet though NO but im leanin towards jem..yeah.totally jem now.

[Abigail]

But I like will more than both of them...!

[Angel]

SIMON all da way.

[Duks]

After reading "Clockwork Princess" Jem all the way!!!! :D

*Still a Simon girl when it comes to TMI.