TWILIGHT HATERS discussion

301 views
Twilight: Characters of Shame > Who is worse: Edward or Jacob?

Comments Showing 1-50 of 271 (271 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 3 4 5 6

message 1: by Kate (new)

Kate (kate_elsey) Both, in my opinion. Jacob is just stupid and tries to steal Bella. He thinks it is possibly to 'get her away from an evil, better-looking-than-him vampire', but he is obviously just as dangerous. Besides, he acts really pompous and weird.

Edward is better though, if I had to choose. But only if I had to. I would love to create a huge bonfire with all the books. Mwahaha. Anyway, back to why Edward is bad: he is way too possessive. It is almost as if he is trying to see if he can keep Bella. He always talks about her being so breakable and fragile. BLEH! They both are just so . . . . lets be nice, bad.

Your opinion?


message 2: by Mallory (new)

Mallory (malloryrose17) Lol, I dunno which is worse. I mean here's how I see Jacob. "Oh, Bella! I love you so much! Why won't you notice me? Bella! I'm going to get you in trouble so you'll stop spending time with Edward and notice me-e-e-e!!! ...Never mind about you, Bella. I love your mutant kid."

*shrugs* But Edward is the creepy sparkly stalker freak. So...I dunno.


message 3: by Gemma, The Bitchy One (last edited Feb 25, 2009 02:18AM) (new)

Gemma | 357 comments Mod
the lesser of two evils....

hmm in this case i really think they're equally creepy (courtesy of breaking dawn)

edward performs a c-section with his teeth

jacob falls in love with a baby






ok maybe edward takes the cake


message 4: by Shlesha (new)

Shlesha | 7 comments Jacob for being a pedophile.
Edward for stalking.


message 5: by Jamine Isabel E. Uy, The creative makes-awesome-stuff-for-us one (new)

Jamine Isabel E. Uy (candy-rain) | 3069 comments Mod
Both for being utterly stupid to fall for someone like Bella.


message 6: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
I hate Edward, cause hes an over protective controll freak/ stalker/ emotionless statue.

It pisses me off how Jacob doesnt just let go of that whiny *bleep*

ugh he could do soo much better than her!!

Like, me for example.

:P


message 7: by Kiara (new)

Kiara OMG!! is it true? he falls in love with the mutant child? (i haven't read that book yet so this is all new to me!!!) I can't believe it! Its just like Quill falling in love with a 2 year old!!


message 8: by Jamine Isabel E. Uy, The creative makes-awesome-stuff-for-us one (new)

Jamine Isabel E. Uy (candy-rain) | 3069 comments Mod
Told you Meyer's had a creepy fetish... I didn't say that? Well there you go.


message 9: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
Yeah, i mean thats the SECOND pedophile in the series!!

talk about twisted


Fée d'écriture V (feedcriturev) Hmmm which is worst?? Jacob.... Sorry i kinda like Edward, itd be nice to have someone thats so worried about me all the time...(aka my sweetheart of a boyfriend) though i wouldnt want him to be totally like Edward. I also agree that Edward is way to possive, It does seem like he's trying to keep her. But Jacob is the worst by far. He's totally oppsed with Bella and cant seem to get over her, but truly she's the worst because she was leading him on and on!! and then he totally fell in love with a newborn because of a thing called imprinting! dude how wierd is that.


message 11: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
ewwww Edward would have his sister kidnapp you so you cant see ur BFF!!!


KIDNAPPER!!


Fée d'écriture V (feedcriturev) that would be horrible i heart my boyfriend and i dont want to be held agiasnt my will by a vampire!!! lol but Alice is pretty cool. So i think that we all agree that Edward and Jacob are the worst to male characters in the whole book. Edward is to possive and Jacob is way to clingy.


message 13: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
YEAH!!

Jacob isnt HALF as bad as edward (though he is a Pedophile its not his fault, it that b**** SM!)


message 14: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
LOL!


message 15: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
XP


message 16: by [deleted user] (new)

why is your name Bella then if you don't like it? Or by some chance, is it your name? Because if it is, I'm sorry such a nice name has been accociated with such a terrible book.


message 17: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
I actually think Bella is a nice name. Bella Swan on the other hand....


message 18: by Lynny (new)

Lynny (lynnyo4) | 272 comments I love Jacob!!!!!! :)


message 19: by Gabriela (new)

Gabriela (machetera11) | 4 comments I also luv jacob (Actualy the actor, taylor lautner is so hot) but anyways my point is i don't like either of them. edward: stalker, jacob: pedophile (i still luv him)

Seriously jacob: COME TO ME! I LUV U!!!!


message 20: by Gabriela (new)

Gabriela (machetera11) | 4 comments besides, who wants to kiss and do the ahem with i guy that is freezing!!!


message 21: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
Lol!


message 22: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
DEADWARD SUCKS!


message 23: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
We should protest at book stores!


message 24: by Lynny (new)

Lynny (lynnyo4) | 272 comments yah i know, it would be really strange kissing a "rock" as Jacob said it.


message 25: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
Lol


message 26: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
XP


message 27: by Jamine Isabel E. Uy, The creative makes-awesome-stuff-for-us one (new)

Jamine Isabel E. Uy (candy-rain) | 3069 comments Mod
um... a wet dog who just pissed on a sparkly rock? >.<


message 28: by Jamine Isabel E. Uy, The creative makes-awesome-stuff-for-us one (new)

Jamine Isabel E. Uy (candy-rain) | 3069 comments Mod
>.< HAHAHA! I found that funny, myself. I just thought that maybe I could merge them together. Hmm... that means Deadward is now Jake's territory


message 29: by Mallory (new)

Mallory (malloryrose17) *shudders* Ewwwww...


message 30: by Jamine Isabel E. Uy, The creative makes-awesome-stuff-for-us one (new)

Jamine Isabel E. Uy (candy-rain) | 3069 comments Mod
That kind of came out wrong... didn't it?


*HP&Twilight4eva* (smiley28) I LOVE EDWARD CULLEN!!!!!


message 32: by Jamine Isabel E. Uy, The creative makes-awesome-stuff-for-us one (new)

Jamine Isabel E. Uy (candy-rain) | 3069 comments Mod
Sure you do dear... we all know that just by looking at your username.


message 33: by Jamine Isabel E. Uy, The creative makes-awesome-stuff-for-us one (new)

Jamine Isabel E. Uy (candy-rain) | 3069 comments Mod
Sam: *catches Rose*

Dean: *shoves Sam and catches Rose instead* Daijobu desu ka, Rose-chan?

Sam: O.O Since when did you speak Japanese, Dean?

Dean: Wakaranai... (I don't understand/I don't know)

Sam: *sweatdrop*


message 34: by Jamine Isabel E. Uy, The creative makes-awesome-stuff-for-us one (new)

Jamine Isabel E. Uy (candy-rain) | 3069 comments Mod
*shoves Deadward's socks infront of ... Sock to make him release Rose* That worked...


message 35: by Jamine Isabel E. Uy, The creative makes-awesome-stuff-for-us one (new)

Jamine Isabel E. Uy (candy-rain) | 3069 comments Mod
Sock: no it's ok! You keep 'em!

No you keep em!

Sock: No! You!

No YOU!

Dean: how about we discuss this in the correct forum?

Oh.. ok.


message 36: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
Lolzz


message 37: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
Chan-chan: Where did that sock come from anyway? *pinches noes* Cuz it STANKS.


message 38: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
It really is. *refrains gag reflex*


message 39: by Fayla (new)

Fayla (bluebutterflyze) | 604 comments Candy-Rain wrote: "Both for being utterly stupid to fall for someone like Bella."

I KNOW SHE IS SO STUPID


message 40: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
And whiny. and stupid, and annoying beyond belief...oh wait we already said that didnt we...oh well its still true!


message 41: by Fayla (new)

Fayla (bluebutterflyze) | 604 comments your just plan funny!1!!!


message 42: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
we try.


message 43: by Fayla (new)

Fayla (bluebutterflyze) | 604 comments U TRY WELL *CLAP* *CLAP*


message 44: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
*drooling* Is that--Is that Berry bloody Bella?? *lunges at Rose in attemt to steal ice cream*


message 45: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
((lol))
Me: WHy do i have to hit him low? *shrugs* Oh well i want that ice cream!!


message 46: by Fayla (new)

Fayla (bluebutterflyze) | 604 comments ME TOO I COULD USE SOME OF THAT LIKE NOW!


message 47: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
totaly!


message 48: by Fayla (new)

Fayla (bluebutterflyze) | 604 comments *gasping for air and ice cream*


message 49: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
I SCREAM!


message 50: by Chandani , The TAC Prez one (new)

Chandani  (milkduds920) | 1475 comments Mod
....


« previous 1 3 4 5 6
back to top