The Son of Neptune
discussion
Piper or Reyna ? Who should Jason choose?
message 1401:
by
Blogger
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Oct 24, 2013 05:24PM
we are STILL talking about this?
reply
|
flag
Piper, it's obvious because Reyna is not Jason's type and she's just a little too crude to be dating Jason. But if there was a third choice it would be me. I am in love with Jason Grace.
Hannah wrote: "Okay Piper or Reyna? Who should Jason choose? At the end of the Lost Hero we were left hanging."reyna, piper is USELESS.
Frankly, I believe who you like better and who a character should be are completely different things. Reyna is one of my favorite characters, and I definitely love her more than Piper, but Jason should be with who he wants to be with.
After reading House Of Hades, I think that Jason does not deserve Reyna at all. I really loved them together at the start , but gradually after reading the books, I think that Reyna really deserves someone who loves her truly and deeply for who she is, and not unwillingly. I REALLY LOVE REYNA A LOT. SHE DID A LOT AND DESERVES HAPPINESS.
piper haven't you read mark of athena
Okay. It should be Piper and Jason- they are sooo cute together!
I love Reyna- she is one of my favorite characters, but Piper and Jason are a much cuter couple.
I haven't read The Mark of Athena yet so I don't know anything more aboout Jason and Reyna's relationship, but so far I don't even know if they had any kind of relationship at all, except for the fact that they were praetors and some kind of partners, and Reyna possibly had some feelings for him, but we don't know anything about Jason. On the other hand, I really liked how his relationship with Piper developped in The Lost Hero, and he actually dud start liking Piper from the moment they met. I was actually really excited for them to get together. I don't know, maybe I'll read the Mark of Athena and something will happen and I'll want Jason to end up with Reyna, but so far I don't even consider her a possible choice for him, and I really want him to get with Piper.
Reyna! She's known Jason longer and they were really close before Jason even met Piper but personally I don't like Jasonbecause he betrayed the legion by chosing Greek in House of Hades but if Reyna likes him and wants him she should get him because she's just way better then Piper.
Piper is not my favorite character, but her and Jason just go naturally together
I Honestly think he should choose Reyna......
Reyna deserves soooo much better than Jason
Piper and Jason just fight together. Who says Reyna even needs a man? She'll find one when she wants to because she has a lot of great qualities. Right now she seems fairly content with just holding the world together.
I used to ship Jason with Reyna. Now I ship him with a brick.
I ship Jeyna because Jason and Reyna have had a long history together so Reyna was with him first just like Annabeth. I feel like piper is realy desperate to get with Jason,and if Juno(Hera) had never erased Jasons mind and put him in a school ( which piper just happened to be there) for bad kids he would be with Reyna.Piper is only cute is because her mother is aphrodite.I have always personaly always liked Reyna because she is strong ( and i like the Romans better ) confident more pulled together and regal.I think Jason and Reyna would make a great couple but i think ( and this has always made me sad) that Rick Riordan will put Jason and the other girl together because they are both apart of the 7of the prophocey and when jason first met piper he just thought cute and that was really all he could think of. Yea so Rick will probobly chose Piper and maybe leo will fall for Reyna and she will reject him (like Khione and Thalia).
I vote for Jason and Piper, because it doesn't matter if Jason has "real" memories of Reyna. It wasn't a romantic relationship. It's like expecting anyone to date their coworker after their memories have been wiped. Jason and Piper both know that there are fake memories regarding their relationship, and they don't care because they really do like each other. Jason doesn't even have the memories! And really, Piper is only cute because her mother is Aphrodite? Everyone gets their genes from their parents! No matter who your mother and father are, if you're cute it's thanks to them!
I think he should stay with Piper because, well, she's better. Jason already got his memory, if you read the beginning of The Mark of Athena, then you'll know that Jason and Piper are together and he's fond of her as well as she is. Reyna is not good because, let's not forget, she also hit on Percy when Jason was gone.
^^ I understand how you may think it's sad but what I mean, assuming you were replying to my statement, is that Reyna couldn't have felt that strongly for Jason if she was ready to move on with another guy who could be just as reliable as Jason was and could qualify for praetor.
I don't want to be rude, I'm just offering my opinion, but we also have to remember Reyna was desperate. She needed someone else to lead with her, and obviously Octavian was not her first chose.Let me also say I don't ship Reyna with Jason (or anyone) I'm just saying this because she's my favorite.
All in all, I think we can conclude that they all deserve to be happy and eventually will be, w/ or w/o Jason, because honestly, Reyna and Piper are awesome and we would be insulting them if we decided if they are or are not good enough for Jason. It's not like Jason is a god, just half, hehehehe, and he can just choose them because they are so willing like objects.
Piper, duh. It says in House of Hades that Jason never even liked Reyna, they were just regular friends but Reyna thought they had something going.
I like Reyna as a leader, but thats it. I don't think Jeyna would have had any romance in the relationship, and evern though Jiper does not have a ton, you know they care about eachother and want to makeout with their faces.
He will probably choose Piper but i perfer Reyna.
Piper. reyna just seems to pushy and arrogant for jason.
Didn't Piper say in the mark of Athena " I should've used more charm speak." Or something like that. What if she charmspeaked Jason into dating her? NOO!
this is turning into a Reyna vs. Piper showdown xDQuite honestly, I would like it to be Reyna, but I KNOW it will be Piper. (SPOILERS AHEAD) in HoH, Cupid said that Jason had a glance at true love. MAYBE he meant "A glance with Reyna" or maybe "a glance with Piper"
Uncle Rick said that there was never any Jeyna, though, so I doubt Jeyna will happen. I love Reyna so much, but I have a feeling that Jason Grace will end up with Piper McLean.
He should choose Percy. Yes....
Piper is cool and funny and brave and is so amazingly cool. Reyna is also all these things, but she also is a bit ruthless and not entirely trustworthy in my opinion. I do think her and Jason certainly do have chemistry, more than he and Piper do, but I think he and Piper fit better together. Reyna and Jason kind of have similar personalities and while their friendship and co-leadership worked well with that, I don't think a relationship between them would work to well.
I don't know... but you people keep saying Raina/Piper and Leo!! Does anyone but me remember Calyspo or whatever her name is?!?! I mean, Leo acted liked her and promised to come back for her! Also, didn't she kiss him!?!
Yeah, she's right!
My gosh, REYNA! I honestly feel so horrible for Reyna, I mean her and Jason had "REAL" memories together, but Jason chooses Piper who he literally just barely met! Not to mention that Piper is a whiny brat. She annoys me in so many ways.
Okay, REAL does not mean ROMANTIC! IF HE DIDN'T LIKE HER THEN, WHY SHOULD HE LIKE HER NOW? HE WAS NEVER IN LOVE WITH HER! GOSH!
...and people are still commenting...
Piperif he dumps Piper for Reyna I will never read a Rick Riordan book again
reyna bc piper is so annoying. and reyna is so pretty and powerful
REYNA! All of you where going mental when Rachel got in the way with percabeth because Annabeth and Percy knew each other first and had a relationship.
That's the same with Jayna. We don't know if they had any romantic feelings but they did have a relationship and it was really shady of Jason to choose Piper even though he thought about Reyna. Piper's also really annoying.
Ah, but comparing this to Percabeth-If Percy woke up now without his memory and it turned out all his memories with Annabeth were fake, and remembered only by her, you'd be furious and would want them to get back together. If his real memories were with Rachel or somebody else? I don't think that would matter to you. But, since you didn't follow Piper's mist edited adventures with Jason, you don't care about them and think he should be with Reyna. It's so different from Pipers POV.
message 1447:
by
Tana Lovegood of Dumbledore's Army✞~
(last edited Jun 16, 2014 12:08PM)
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Piper is not weak! In TLH she had the guts not to betray her friends! Sure she might have thought about it but her Dad's life was on the line! In the end she never betrayed them and her dad was safe!Piper isn't useless because she's saved Percy and Jason in Mark of Athena and also in House of Hades she was pretty strong too!
She isn't a Mary Sue either! Sometimes her self esteem is low like she thinks her dad was ignoring her and she gets self continuous too. She isn't flawless Drew, Jane,and the girls at Wilderness Camp didn't like her!
Pipers memories with Jason aren't " fake" in the beginning then yes but after that she probably made some real ones too!
“She didn’t even worry that her knowledge of him was mostly based on three months of false
memories. You can sense possibilities, her mother had said. And Piper was determined to make those possibilities a reality.” (The Lost Hero, Chapter 52).
So Piper wanted to make real memories, and I think we can assume that she did, since she and Jason are now dating.
She's a little Jason obsessed but she doesn't think about him all the time! She thinks about saving her friends and her dad and other things. For you girls if you were in her shoes going on a quest with 2 boys one was funny and he was like a person you loved as a brother. Then another guy is like hot and you really like him and your pretty sure you kissed him but he doesn't remember! What would you be like?!
I would say Reyna, just because I like her as a character more than Piper, but I can definitely see her as a Hunter of Artemis. She reminds me of Zoe from the previous books.
Olivia wrote: "I would say Reyna, just because I like her as a character more than Piper, but I can definitely see her as a Hunter of Artemis. She reminds me of Zoe from the previous books."Yes, she does so too to me!
Sabrina *The REAL Princess* wrote: "Reyna, those 2 have an actual history and besides, if you like percabeth imagine that instead of Jason wondering who it will be, it was Percy. Then you'd all choose Annabeth, because those 2 actual..."Totally agree.. Exactly my thoughts.. :)
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
The Son of Neptune (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
The House of Hades (other topics)The Son of Neptune (other topics)
