Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
discussion
If, in fifty years or so, they made a remake of the series, would you watch it?
date
newest »
newest »
Gabriel wrote: "Rachel wrote: "I'd pretty much have to. Even if they sucked. It's Harry Potter, they could probably dress up a bunch of dogs and have them play the parts and I'd still see it."That gives me an id..."
Oh no. hahaha
By the way, I *am* going to PM you later. I bought Skyrim and it's been taking over my life.
Rachel wrote: "Gabriel wrote: "Rachel wrote: "I'd pretty much have to. Even if they sucked. It's Harry Potter, they could probably dress up a bunch of dogs and have them play the parts and I'd still see it."Tha..."
The same with Jillian.
Vincent Valentine wrote: im scared of what theyll do to The Hunger Games"
Same here..
Same here..
No. Never. Nuh uh. No. Nope. Nooooooo. No. uh uh. No. NO.The books were good enough, all the movies were great (except the 6th one... they messed that one up.....), but if there was a remake, I wouldn't even let my children see it. Or my grandchildren. No. No one does Harry Potter like Daniel Radcliffe. And no one could ever be the beautiful Weasley twins but James & Oliver Phelps. No.
Gabriel wrote: "Linda wrote: "Sandy wrote: "Being a big fan I probably would watch it even though my first reaction of hearing they are making a remake would be "why??!!!" and "leave it alone!!" :P"Agree! (but a..."
Selena Gomez as Luna? No Way!!
NOOOOO! They could never make the movies any better than they are now, it would just mess them up. Honestly, I couldn't see them any other way. Plus, in fifty years I'll be 63, it's very doubted that I'll have any interest in Harry Potter then.
Depends but I was happy with most of these movies
Only if they learn from their mistakes from these movies. I can't stomach the current movies (one heck of a trainwreck). I actually want a remake as long as they're going to improve upon the awful ones we have.
YES!! why do you think they would wreck it? It's quite bad this time. I think they will make it better. although some characters would be extremely missing: Snape (Alan Rickman FTW. Everyone else will be worse as Snape. But you can't do anything about that, can you?), Ron (just that. I thought he played Ron really good. but well, didn't have frecles and was too short, but I love his voice. maybe he can play Arthur next time :)), Hermione (Emma is a great actress I think). next are the twins, emma Thompson, mcGonnagal, Umbridge was great done too, Neville. that's it.other than actors I don't belive they would spoil the movies (of coure they can't be done by disney). at worst they would be as bad as now. I mean, the shoelaces scene, Ginny (!!), the first movie (as for visual effects - Neville falling from his broom was really bad I daresay), Harry's eyes, the pink dress, the her-mee-nii scene in the hospital was so terribly awkward, .... there are just too much things I hated in the movies. of course, some scenes they added were good, but even the new series could come with something.
I would definitely watch it!
I would wach it just to see why they felt the need to remake it. Although i would love if how recently they made one of my favorite movies of all time - The Lion King in 3D and put it out again they were to upgrade the movies 50 years down the line.
I figure that in 50 years that they'll make something that will allow us to LIVE in the Harry Potter universe. We won't need a remake.
Maybe, I just would hate to see a different person taking the place that Rupert, Daniel, and Emma portrayed so well.
If they do, and I expect that they will, I wouldn't mind them exploit some of J.K. Rowling's alternative storylines, instead of making a simple remake.
I don't think I'll be alive in 50 years. I'd probably watch it if I were to still be alive though....
Later years=More realistic effects and graphics. So yeah, why not? Let's just hope they put EPIC Quidditch matches in them! :D
No. I stopped watching the movies after I saw the mess that was made of the Prisoner of Azkaban. I guess it's because I expect the movies to be faithful to the books.
I would love to see it :)
I would never watch it... I love the ones made already too much (no one can portray Ron Weasley as awesome as Rupert Grint!!! Nor can anyone play Hermione Granger or Bellatrix, or even Draco Malfoy like the actors they had playing them now) :)
NO. Daniel Radcliffe will always be my harry potter...
I don't want a remake. I want more books! I feel abandoned. :-(
Who says itll be a movie or tv series?maybe another book series
maybe depending on how it sounds
I'm actually surprised it hasn't been made into a cartoon and or tv show yet. We may just get to see the remake in our lifetimes. They remake everything else. I just hope they wait at least 20 years or more.
Definitely - but in 50 years I'll be 100 so.....!
In 50 years hopefully people will learn to be a little more original and stop stealing and remaking beautiful works of art that was fine to begin with. You don't see anyone remaking the Lion King! I hope the HP series gets reMASTERED instead.
Kim wrote: "In 50 years hopefully people will learn to be a little more original and stop stealing and remaking beautiful works of art that was fine to begin with. You don't see anyone remaking the Lion King! ..."Give Disney time...
I would probably watch it cos I wouldnt wanna judge it until Ive seen it
a phenomenon such as harry potter need not become another bolly-style remake disaster.its the best in its originality.beside after fifty years or so,do you guys really think anybody would fit the characters perfectly?I'll watch it if I'm alive by then or i get seriously mental
I think I would watch it, purely out of curiosity, but I don't think that anything could EVER beat the original films. I also think that no American actors (no offence meant!) could take the place of Daniel Radcliffe, Emma Watson, Rupert Grint etc. And another thing - if they were remade in America, they wouldn't have the authentic English weather and setting!
Gabriel wrote: "Kim wrote: "In 50 years hopefully people will learn to be a little more original and stop stealing and remaking beautiful works of art that was fine to begin with. You don't see anyone remaking the..."Lol, oh jeez, I hope I never have to see any Harry Potter or Disney classic remade.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
That gives me an idea! Rachel, you are a genius!