Mystery Lovers! discussion
Hot topics
>
What are you reading? Do you recommend it?
message 401:
by
Vicki - I Love Reading
(new)
May 17, 2009 06:16AM

reply
|
flag

I read The Lincoln Lawyer by Michael Connelly yesterday, loved it, and today I'm halfway through Still Life by Louise Penny... I don't know about this one. Maybe cozies just aren't for me.


Just read The Thirty-Nine Steps by John Buchan, a sort of spy/adventure thriller novel released in 1915. I really enjoyed the characters, especially the Scottish road mender.

Louise Penny does however give a glimpse of idyllic village life in Canada, but your unstated comparison makes me want to know your list. I just finished HEADHUNTERS by Peter Lovesey which like Penny's books is too neatly constructed for my taste.


Ah Susan, obviously you've been missing out on some great mysteries if you feel the genre is debased. I would hold the quality of a James Lee Burke or Craig Johnson or Robert Crais or Timothy Hallinan or...up to anyone in any genre. There's no lack of quality in any of those writers and they could hold their own with ANY so-called "literary" writer.





Hmm. What a stimulating discussion! By all means keep it going. Why not look backwards instead of to 2020, to consider how these mysteries connect with earlier forms. A friend was convinced that Sophocles' Oedipus was the first mystery ever, for instance.


Great idea! I earlier this year read The Suspisions of Mr. Whicher. Not only did it discuss actual early circa 1870's detection, it also discussed the effect of these early dectives on early (not counting Oedipus) fictional detectives, Poe, Dickens, Doyle and a little about Lewis Carroll. Really interesting. We still read Poe, Doyle, Dickens--I read all the Rex Stout mysteries(including the ones written by other people). Hammet, Chandler are read today...perhaps the Spencer novels will last. IMHO, the ones that last have characters we like and enjoy visiting time and again. I don't think the plots last--I couldn't tell you 'who did it' in any Nero Wolfe, but I can tell you what Archie likes for breakfast and what time Mr. Wolfe had his afternoon beer! Just my opinion. I like the discussion.




I agree! (Alafair Burke is James Lee's daughter). There really isn't a mystery I won't read. We have to consider the Ladies' Detective Agency series, too. He really can write and I find him writing from the female perspective fascinating.








Finished the new Lee Child last night (Gone Tomorrow)--best Reacher yet!

I agree with you Mike. This is a page-turner, quite suspensful. The ending had some surprises too.
I see that you have read other books that I enjoy.
Have you read James Siegel, especially "Derailed"? I think that his books are even more hair raising, but in the same genre as Hart.





I am currently re-reading Agatha Raisin and the Quiche of Death. I had forgotten how much I enjoyed this "cozy" series

fast paced and informative about a lot of things
Mafia, medicine information is counter to what is usually broadcast about both and many other topics
language is very real life and not for tender ears and very graphic sexually not for easily offended/conservative mindsets


Billy jo, its been a fantastic read, its her first book, i've ordered the 2nd one now.lol
really good read would deffo recomment it.

I just finished "Fatally Flaky" by Diane Mott Davidson and realized that I'd missed at least 2 or 3 previous books, so I'm working my way backwards and I'm currently 2/3 of the way through "Sweet Revenge".

Westlake always seems to deliver a realistic plot with realistic characters and good dialogue/descriptions
good and fast read

JP O'Donnell
Author of Fatal Gamble and Deadly Codes


Books mentioned in this topic
Defending Jacob: A Novel (other topics)A Box of Darkness: The Story of a Marriage (other topics)
The Strangler: A Novel (other topics)
My Forbidden Past (other topics)
Double Life: A Love Story from Broadway to Hollywood (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Harlan Coben (other topics)Karin Slaughter (other topics)
Robert Crais (other topics)
Gerald Elias (other topics)
Robert Crais (other topics)
More...