Questions (for those who have read the book):

[karlipagemaster]

Yeah, I usually reread them randomly, but I haven't had a chance to read them lately because I have a huge stack of books that I'm trying to get through right now.

[Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood]

wow. yeah i was going to change it to the right date of when it does come out. bc after i got off i checked my phone scents i keep the dates for stuff like that on there and it was for a diftent serise

[Essz]

Am i the only one who felt confused at the end of Cresencdo??
I mean whats with Patch showing up at her house, and then without words they just forget about the kiss with Marcie and Scott, and go to his place??

And when Nora takes Patchs car, and he comes to get it back - what the hell happened with the clock and the beating? It was all very confusing?..

[Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood]

you just tottaly lost me at the last part of that

[Essz]

page 309 in crescendo.. what the hell was that all about??

[Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood]

uh good question i dont reamber page 309 in crescendo or the the clock and the beating. inless your talking about Hank bursting in on Patch and Nora at the end of it............

[~☺MiNi☺~]

But guys, wasn't the whole point that Patch wasn't allowed to love anyone for that matter? Isn't being with Marcie sending a message to the archangels that he is in love with her (even though he isn't, but this is what the archangels may think)? Aren't there the same consequences involved like him being with Nora?
Correct me if i'm wrong, it's been a while since I read the latest book of Hush Hush. :)

[Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood]

i offisaley have No idea. i havent read it scents like......last year. but yeah that kinda sounds right. inless the Archangels know he's not in love with Marcie and he's still in love with Nora. hell i dont know. but im going to say your right anyways can i dont know

[Rachel]

Cassie wrote: "um......... october 6th i think. caz its around my birthday some time."

Thanks! But it's so far away!!!

[Essz]

Cassie wrote: "uh good question i dont reamber page 309 in crescendo or the the clock and the beating. inless your talking about Hank bursting in on Patch and Nora at the end of it............"

No no.. it wasnt at the end.. It was when Nora blaimed Patch for killing her father, and being the Black Hand.. dont anyone remember??

[Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood]

OOOOOOOOOH Now i reamber what your talking about!!!!!

[Essz]

okay! Then does anyone know what the hell happened? I mean how can she push him away one second, and than the next hes gone, and the only thing she hear is the clocl going one two three..
And why did they just hug and forgive eachother without any words at the end??
We didnt get to know why he didnt want Nora to go to his place, and then all of a sudden shes allowed..

[Essz]

And he even puts a key in Noras pocket, but he have to put a new one in her pocket in Silence.. what happened??

[Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood]

good question........maybe he thought if he showed her were he lived if she got kidnapped or anything else, the kidnapper might try to prie it out of her if they thought she knew and he didnt want to take that change....maybe he had to give her anouther key beacuse he changed the locks on his door! lol. i dont know why they didnt say anything at the end of it and just made up. maybe they knew the other one didnt mean it and they were just doing it to make the other persion upset, but knew that it was wrong or somthing. dont know

[Essz]

and what about the clock?

[[deleted user]]

Annie wrote: "Probably he kissed her because he wanted to show the angels that he didnt love Nora so they wouldnt send him to hell. Even though he really did love nora, he had to pretend he didnt."

even though I sort of have to agree with you.. i got mad and almost almost threw the book at the frikin wall! almost I didnt cuz I wanted to see what would happen next!

[Essz]

Kelsey a.k.a. BOOK GODDESS wrote: "Annie wrote: "Probably he kissed her because he wanted to show the angels that he didnt love Nora so they wouldnt send him to hell. Even though he really did love nora, he had to pretend he didnt."..."

I agree!
But then Nora kissed Scott.. so I guess that made them equal..

[Essz]

Kelsey a.k.a. BOOK GODDESS wrote: "Annie wrote: "Probably he kissed her because he wanted to show the angels that he didnt love Nora so they wouldnt send him to hell. Even though he really did love nora, he had to pretend he didnt."..."

I agree!
But then Nora kissed Scott.. so I guess that made them equal..

[Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood]

yep!!

[Sydney]

To let the achangels know that every girl he is with he dosen't have feelings for her. Not that he likes Marcie. Ew!

[Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood]

Marcie sucks!! hate her!!

[Meagin]

Cassie wrote: "Marcie sucks!! hate her!!"

I actully liked her towards the end of silence.....she gets alot nicer

[Dahlia]

SofiaJeane.♕ wrote: "This is a discussion section where anyone who has read the book are able to ask questions and discuss topics freely surrounding details of the novel.

My question is:

Could somebody tell me the re..."

i know right! what a jerky moment. but he he made up for it!

[Dahlia]

Elena wrote: "I think he did because Becca Fitzpatrick didn't structure well her series. ;D"

what!? Becca Fitzpatrick is one of the best writers in history
and she did a great job at writing her series! i dont know what is in your head but she is very good at her job!

[Dahlia]

Essz wrote: "Yearh thats why they got back together at the end of the book - 'cause they had both kissed other people?.. i dunno.. i just like Patch way more in Silence - that's where he finally prove how mu
ch ..."

cant wait!

[Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood]

Cassie wrote: "Marcie sucks!! hate her!!"

I actully liked her towards the end of silence.....she gets alot nicer


yeah she does get nicer....but somthing tells me its not going to last though the whole 4th book.

[Destinyclaire]

yea it probley wont but im toally stoked about the last book and i want to see how Nora is going lead the Nempilum you know?

[Ashley]

SofiaJeane.♕ wrote: "Zool wrote: "Thats actually a really good question. Patch, being one of my favorite YA characters, I hate to think that Patch is anything but loyal to Nora. But really Patch is a player, I can't re..."

I think in a way, Patch did explain to Nora about the kiss with Marcie. I don't think he's a player. Rixon wanted Nora to think he was a player. I agree with an earlier post, he probably kissed her to prove to the archangels that his love for Nora didn't mean as much as it did to him.

[Essz]

Ashley wrote: "SofiaJeane.♕ wrote: "Zool wrote: "Thats actually a really good question. Patch, being one of my favorite YA characters, I hate to think that Patch is anything but loyal to Nora. But really Patch is..."

Yearh! But thats a theory! We dont know for sure why he kissed her - so we can sit her and make up stories that'll explain the kiss all day but the fact is that the kiss did happend - and we dont know why..

Lets ask Becca the next time she gets online? If we all spam her she would have to answer right?...

[Shaye]

SofiaJeane.♕ wrote: "Rebecca wrote: "Probably to show the angels watching him and Nora that he does not ae any feelings for her"

You have a point there..
did he ever say that though?"

Patch has never really been the type to explian himself though...espcially if what he did wasn't a big deal to him. He let it happen so he wouldn't draw attention and then forgot about it cause it meant nothing. That's what I think at least

[Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood]

Essz wrote: Lets ask Becca the next time she gets online? If we all spam her she would have to answer right?...


i would guess so.....

[Essz]

Cassie wrote: "Essz wrote: Lets ask Becca the next time she gets online? If we all spam her she would have to answer right?...


i would guess so....."

mhm.... confusing though.. i would have prefered him not to kiss her..

[Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood]

yeah.....but then the book wouldnt of been that good if he hadn't had. sense that was half the drama in the book about.

[Essz]

yearh.. but it seems like Hush Hush is the only book where the to of them is realy TOGETHER.. in Crescendo they break up, and in Silene they dont get back together up until the last part of the book..

[Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood]

yeah...but they were together in like the frist few chapters of Cresendo. then BAM!!

[[deleted user]]

Because Patch is Patch and he does whatever he wants. :P

[Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood]

SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO TURE!!!!!!!!

[Essz]

Cassie wrote: "yeah...but they were together in like the frist few chapters of Cresendo. then BAM!!"

and the last chapter of Crescendo too -course she gets kidnapped when he finally says he loves her.. what is this!!?

[Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood]

it's called Crap on Hanks part. well....yeah i guess you could count that chapter too.

[Essz]

Cassie wrote: "it's called Crap on Hanks part. well....yeah i guess you could count that chapter too."

hell it is crap on his part..

[Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood]

yeeep!! sure is

[Czerina]

ZOMG i loved Hush Hush...the others though, not as much. I met Becca Fitzpatrick and got my books signed by her when she was in Sydney :D some segments of the book were inspired from her teen life...it was so funny.

[Sonia]

Patch is a bit of a man-whore, not gunna lie. But, it is what it is. I think that he did a lot of those crappy things in part because of the archangels and also because Nora shut him out. There’s always a bigger picture that she can’t quite seem to grasp, but then again if I saw my boyfriend hanging out with another girl I’d be asking questions too. I think the only frustrating part for me was how she forgave him so easily. There were parts (where he kisses Marcie), that I felt like I wanted to punch him through the book myself! I think Nora should have been able to at least slap him or teach him some kind of lesson for acting the way he did. Regardless of his motives.

[Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood]

as much as i want to agree with you Sonia, i can kinda see what Patch was getting at. although i do kinda agree with the slap acrose the face thing. but then Nora isnt really that kinda gril...............Vee on the other hand. i can see her doing that to some guy.

[Sonia]

Cassie wrote: "as much as i want to agree with you Sonia, i can kinda see what Patch was getting at. although i do kinda agree with the slap acrose the face thing. but then Nora isnt really that kinda gril........"

@Cassie, I just meant that he wasn’t a saint when it came to being with different girls. Especially before Nora. I guess a better term would be “womanizer”. Or maybe just a “big flirt”?
Throughout this book he kept saying “it didn’t mean anything” when he was with Marcie, so I only assumed he was pretending because of the archangels. And because Nora said that she didn’t want him as her guardian angel anymore, so it’s not like he could really be around her. You’re totally right about a slap not being something Nora would do. But I totally agree that it’s definitely a Vee thing. :)

[Sonia]

@Musicsoul26, I can see that too.

[Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood]

yeah i can also see that to. although i dont really pity her

[Koleen]

some time and this only what I have heard man do this thing I think fool myself that I don’t love her I am Protection her nonsense so I am with a girl that need help like the girl I what’d to be with need help so I can underhand help her so he feel less guilty about what the action he is taking not all men are like this in book all right only in manga and anime I have seem this that are not like this and the love triangle are some better in manga less Annoying

[Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood]

huh??

[izzy]

Michael wrote: "to make the angels watching think he not interested in nora"

So true!!