The Lightning Thief
discussion
Is this book so good that it could be a play?
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Fariha
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jul 12, 2011 12:31PM
I think it is.
reply
|
flag
A musical?! Nuh-uh.
A play, maybe. A musical? too corny, in my opinion. It's too epic to make it into a musical.
Nope. Not a musical. Book, play, and movie. NOT MUSICAL.
This book is FANTASTIC. However, there is no way on this planet that it would work as a musical. It goes in too many different directions, and it is way too complex. I also agree with Stephanie that a musical would be way too corny.
message 6:
by
Kaleigh - Captain Bubbles ESTP(intj)
(last edited Jul 12, 2011 04:07PM)
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
True that. But, it would be pretty funny if someone tried. I bet people would only watch it BECAUSE it would be so corny.
definitely not a musical! i don't want to see my favorite characters sing... that would be weird
ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!
NOOOOO! That would just ruin everything.
I love the book, and I love musicals, but I would not want this book as a musical! I agree, play and book, movie not good!
>>>>>>><<<<<<<<>>>>>>>><<<<<<<((((((()))))))(((((((()))))))
Kaleigh wrote: ">>>>>>>>>>>>>><<<<<<<((((((()))))))(((((((()))))))"my brain can't compute...
:) I was just doing patterns, and I was bored. I seem to be bored a lot don't I? And I think it's pretty.^
<<<>>><<<<>>>>
<<<<<>>>>>
<<<<<<>>>>>>
<<<<<<<>>>>>>>
<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>
<<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>>
<<<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>>>
ok ok srry for asking i didnt no tht nobody would like musicals. everything i do on goodreads is always wrong. and litterally i mean everything
We don't mind that you asked. At least I don't. We're not mad at you at all. I just don't like the idea of Percy singing. :) Haha. I do like musicals though. :) Don't feel bad. You didn't do anything wrong. We just have strong feelings about this. Sorry If I was rude at all.
Oh yha and once the question has been answered we usually get distracted so it's not your fault we were doing patterns.
thank you for understanding! i wrote play and then someone changed it since we were having a party tht day (with alot of naughty little kids)
definietley not. maybe if some school play or something and they make it into a paradoy. but definitley not professional. And if a musical is just too corny plus its not a very musical type book most of the time hes falling to his death wat r they gonna sing about?
Fariha wrote: "ok ok srry for asking i didnt no tht nobody would like musicals. everything i do on goodreads is always wrong. and litterally i mean everything"no it was an intersting question to ask!! i liked it! and like i said a play would be good like for school or something.
TikiPaws12 wrote: "We don't mind that you asked. At least I don't. We're not mad at you at all. I just don't like the idea of Percy singing. :) Haha. I do like musicals though. :) Don't feel bad. You didn't do anythi..."hah Percy signing tht would be funny. But seriously wat wud he even sing about. I dont want to point this out but i think PJ is not the most positive book in da world :P
lalalalalala innnnnnnn theeeeee underwoooooorrrrrlllldddd!!!!
then i guess a book is like the only thing tht wood be fit for percy jackson
i know even the movie wasnt tht good. mostly cuz they friggin messed it upp :(
Yeah I know!
Fariha wrote: "ok ok srry for asking i didnt no tht nobody would like musicals. everything i do on goodreads is always wrong. and litterally i mean everything"'S'okay. I do that sometimes. And literally not EVERYTHING you do s wrong. Even this isn't wrong. Your just putting up an opinion.
Your welcome. It's nice to be nice you know.
ya its nice dont u think
:) Righteous.
:) Ha ha.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
