I Am Number Four
discussion
I Am Number Four
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Hina
(new)
-
rated it 2 stars
May 30, 2011 03:20AM
My Opinion---> http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...
reply
|
flag
I know that everyone is entitled to their own opinion, and that was a very well written review, but I personally really enjoyed I Am Number Four.
Jenna! wrote: "I know that everyone is entitled to their own opinion, and that was a very well written review, but I personally really enjoyed I Am Number Four."Oh, of course. Thank you. Ah, awesome. May I know why?
Why I liked the book? Well, because it was different than anything else I was reading at the time. It wasn't about vampires or werewolves or anything like that. I really liked the whole concept of it, and I thought that it was really interesting. Granted, I do wish they would have had a little more action in it, but still...
Yep. True. I'm all up for aliens, but the way the author executed the story was just wrong. The romance was the worst, and I think the whole story just sinks when you begin to detest the main characters. I also hated the ending.
Yeah, that's true. As soon as you begin to hate the characters, you also begin to hate the story. I thought that the ending was quite awesome. Mainly because it kept it open for the sequel
there is a sequel coming out in august and i thought tat the cliffhanger was a good one 2 get about everyone read the next one 2 c how it is
there is a sequel coming out in august and i thought tat the cliffhanger was a good one 2 get about everyone read the next one 2 c how it is
Jenna! wrote: "Yeah, that's true. As soon as you begin to hate the characters, you also begin to hate the story. I thought that the ending was quite awesome. Mainly because it kept it open for the sequel"I didn't like the ending because it felt like the author just went 'Right, I have to put some action in this now', so he puts some mutant dogs or whatever in the story, then I felt that John's guardian (forgot his name) was a bit of an unecessary death and the author just thought, 'Oh, okay, yes I need someone to die in this story to make it a good one so lets just kill off John's guardian and wrap it up and leave a cliffhanger so I can write many more books'. Didn't like the cliffhanger either.
^^ I don't know if that made sense, but oh well.
Jenna! wrote: "Yeah, that's true. As soon as you begin to hate the characters, you also begin to hate the story. I thought that the ending was quite awesome. Mainly because it kept it open for the sequel"I didn't like the ending because it felt like the author just went 'Right, I have to put some action in this now', so he puts some mutant dogs or whatever in the story, then I felt that John's guardian (forgot his name) was a bit of an unecessary death and the author just thought, 'Oh, okay, yes I need someone to die in this story to make it a good one so lets just kill off John's guardian and wrap it up and leave a cliffhanger so I can write many more books'. Didn't like the cliffhanger either.
^^ I don't know if that made sense, but oh well.
i love the ending and i saw the movie too so both ways it was really good!!!!!!
the movie,i thought,was disapointing 2 c,compared 2 the book!the movie was-well-disapointing!i still luved the movie!
I didn't like the ending of I Am Number Four very much, it was a bit too rushed and forceful.
i thought the same thing!agreed!
i just the whole book theres no dislikes i just like the whole book plus i also watched the movie be4 i read the book so the movie helps me understnd a bit
This book was amazing , i completely loved it !! & I cant wait for the 2nd one its not coming fast enough :/ & it was so sad when henri died :"(
i agree
I HATE THE MOGADORIANS
p.s i watch the movie :):):):)
I guess it is suitable for eleven year olds, but I don't recommend this book. It's horrible.
I LOVED THE BOOK
I think the word that best describes my feelings for this book is "meh"
Stray wrote: "I think the word that best describes my feelings for this book is "meh""I second that.
I loved the book, and I loved the movie! Of course, the book was better. I really liked the story and all the characters--even the ones I disliked. That makes a better read when there are characters you are suppose to dislike. I liked how it ended; obviously leaving it open for its sequel. I was sad when Henri died, but I did feel it was necessary for John, Sam, and Six's continued journey. With Henri's death, John is now on his own without his Cepan just like Six is without hers.
(These were a few opinions I wanted to convey after reading some comments in this thread. I'm not coming down on anyone; it's good people have differing opinions! That's what makes everybody different.)
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
