Breaking Dawn
discussion
Which was the best book in the series?
date
newest »
newest »
message 51:
by
Kelsey
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Oct 05, 2011 10:28PM
yeah it is but all it is is dating and just being there for her as she grows up and having extra protection from both jake and the rest of the wolves if i was bella i would have killed him without thinking lol
reply
|
flag
i know so how many times have you read twilight
im back about 2 times the first three books and two thre times the 4th book
I loved them all, in fact I have read the series 4 times. (Whenever, I run out of something to read). I definitly fell in love with the series with the first book, and was addicted from there. (I read the books first, and now when I see the movies I think they are hysterical -other than looking at Robert Pattinson, because the characters are nothing of which imagined when I read the books).
i agree the actors did disappiont a few people
yeah the actors r normally better in our minds then they r in real life we picture them soo much better but they did do pretty good in the movies as for the directors especially the first one she could have done alot better it seems like she didn't read the book and got a story line from a friend
punk princess wrote: "i agree the actors did disappiont a few people"I agree... But not all of them though... Just some of them are totally different than the ones we read in the book...
Torie wrote: "There are different things I like about each book, I can't pick just one to be my #1 favorite!"I agree with that.
ummm breaking dawn i luved it the most honostlyy<3
Breaking Dawn was my favorite because it had the most action and the characters of Bella and Jake finallly made sense to me
Books in order of.. Goodness: Eclipse, New Moon, Twilight, Breaking Dawn.
Eclipse was very good but Breaking Dawn is my favorite. My daughter was the one to get me started on this series and it resulted in my own first fiction book. I have read this series seven times and will probably read it again because I love the way Stephenie Meyers writes. My book is not YA it it definitely an adult series. I have found reading other good series novels in this genera has helped my writing.
My favorite book was Eclipse, definitely. The first book had only Edward, the second had only Jacob throughout most of it, but the third brings them all together and there was an amazing story made out of it!
I Believe Breaking Dawn is the best of all because Bella finds finally her reason to live. Vampire Bella is powerfull of them all.
I liked Twilight and I think it is the best. It is the beggining of Bella and Edward and have a little bit of everithing -a little bite. Whatever. The point is that the author could have ended the thing with just one book and it would have been just fine. The series itself begins in New Moon, when the Vulturi apears and the 'ask' for Bella to be a Vamp. So Twilight.
I really loved Eclipse!!!!! I really loved the love triangle and it was interesting to see who Bella would pick.....
I liked Breaking Dawn, I think everything about it was beautiful, like the happy ending and true love and all that.
eclipse cus it had the triangle plot with bella, edward and jacob <3
same prabhjit, eclipse! because it had a fight scene ;D
twilight, the first one because it's not all complicating without jacob in the picture or victoria. it's just edward, bella, and them finding that first love. just the two of them and love. and james but it just makes it all more suspenseful. but it's all about thier love, not some other vampire trying to tear them apart
I love New Moon because thats the book were you saw Jacob the most
I think that New Moon and Breaking Dawn were the best. New Moon because it showed Bella's life without Edward and Breaking Dawn because Bella FINALLY became a vampire.
I don't remember which one I liked best, but it definitely wasn't Breaking Dawn.
Breaking Dawn is the worst in the series. Eclipse is the best, the other 2 are just ok. Eclipse has more action, and a better ending. I felt like things were tied up better in Eclipse than in Breaking Dawn. But that's just me.
Mary Christabelle wrote: "The best and the worst is breaking dawn... It's the best because it has the most twist and turns... Finally Bella and Edward got married... Bella got pregnant... And she became a vampire... Not to ..."I must have missed the part where Charlie finds out the Cullen's secret. Approximately where in the book does he find out?
New Moon suckedEclipse was the best
and I also liked the others
hope to see the movie :) cause its near my birthday :D
Twilight was full of a lot of uncertainty as both Bella & Edward did not realize the full extent of the others feelings. I wish she would finish "Midnight Sun" because I keep wondering what Edward was thinking when he got a little wild in the meadow. It mentions that he looked into the woods before he calmed down, I wonder if Alice had a vision, ran to the meadow where she, hidden in the forest, warned him through her thoughts. New Moon was just one big stressful heartache, I could never re-read it. I found Eclipse a bit slow paced, wanting more interaction between Edward & Bella. The immaturity of the characters in the Novella of Bree Tanner annoyed me a bit. Breaking Dawn was my favorite, at that point in the series Edward & Bella understand each other, and there was lots of one-on-one time which was missing in the previous two. I was never a fan of vampire-lore as it seems too far-fetched. Stephanie Meyer's type of vampire is more believable.
I tend to be a first-book girl. The first one is my favourite in many series!
breaking dawn!!!!!!!!!!!
Twilight was the best followed closely by Eclipse, I liked New Moon okay. I ruined Breaking Dawn for myself I think, I had in my mind what I thought should happen and how, I was okay with the baby thing but the whole birthing / pregnancy drama lasted waaaaaay too long for me. And didn't care for the Jacob part of the book which is probably why I didn't like New Moon as much, Edward girl I guess. The fight buildup and final scene was okay but like I said I had dreamed up my own version before I read it and it ended up not living up to what I wanted, I'm sure it would have been better if I hadn't of done that. I will watch the movie at some point but I am really not anxious to go through that whole birthing / pregnancy thing again. Someone will have to reassure me that the rest of the movie is worth it before I attempt it.
Out of the whole series, I liked New Moon the most.
I think it would still be "Twilight". Probably because there's no too many complications and the story just centered around Bella and Edward. Next would be "New Moon", obviously because Jacob got the chance to show her love to Bella...
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
