The Next Best Book Club discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Revive a Dead Thread
>
What are you reading?
message 22351:
by
Marti
(last edited Sep 13, 2010 07:02PM)
(new)
Sep 13, 2010 07:01PM

reply
|
flag

Well, that sounds interesting. I think it may be one that I check out again out from the library as I have not seen it mentioned until your post. But I love your description of it :) Thanks for the feedback!

it's wonderful


I loved Water for Elephants and had someone totally different in mind for young Jacob.
However, although I am not an RPatz fan in the clips I have seen so far he looks good.
Ms Witherspoon is a totally different kettle of fish. She plays a certain kind of perky character very well but not much else. She was terrible in Vanity Fair and I think for Marlena you need some like Neve Campbell who is better at playing 'damaged'.


I loved the book and am hoping the movie is good.

Started Fahrenheit 451. Love it so far. Reminds me of 1984.



Also reading The Alexandria Link, first one by Steve Berry but I like him very much. The book is really enjoyeble, very Dan Brownesque which is great!

Stephanie: I am about a third of the way through with The Gendarme and you are absolutely right. I sometimes feel as though I am walking right through the middle of his dream state sequences.


I felt the same. What was it you didn't like?



Alex wrote: "Nice that you're tackling Count of Monte Cristo, Monef! That's been on my to-read list for a while. I hear it's one of the Best Ever."
Gasp! You have not read the Count yet Alex? What are you waiting for? Oh my, this must be rectified asap.
Gasp! You have not read the Count yet Alex? What are you waiting for? Oh my, this must be rectified asap.





I felt the same. What was it you didn't like?"
It started off quite well but really lost focus too early on for my taste. There was a lot of pointless meandering that didn't really do anything to develop characters or advance the story. I felt like I was reading the work of someone who has been told that she writes beautifully, and so she pontifiacted endlessly without point. Maybe if I had read it before I read Kathryn Stockett's The Help', I would have been more taken with it, but as it stood, all I could think was how other people have done more interesting and enjoyable things with the genre. All in all, on paper it seemed like a book I would love, but somehow I just didn't.

You really got to the heart of the issue with that book much better than I did in all my waffle, kudos!

The Count is amazing! It is huge, so it makes it a bit of a nightmare to toe on the train, but it really is amazing. It started to drag somewhere around page 600, but once I got past the hump ot has started to pay off and even though I know the bare bones of the story, I am dying to see how it all shakes out. An absolute corker!

Wow, it seems as if they're making all the books I'm trying to find time to read into movies. Man, I hope I can get them read first. Jeez, (ha ha) talk about pressuring a girl.
Alex wrote: "I know, I know, very embarrassing. I'm hoping to get to it next year. I'm on Don Quixote now and I have Paradise Lost, Faerie Queene and Brothers Karamazov coming up the pike, so, y'know...one tr..."
Oh no, you havent read Brothers K yet either??? That was an amazing novel too!!
Oh no, you havent read Brothers K yet either??? That was an amazing novel too!!



Ruby wrote: ".... It was disjointed and muddled, set out to do things that it didn't accomplish....."
I agree with both of you. Some of the writing was lovely especially in the 'bee shed' but I felt mysself asking "And?' all the time because she never seemed to fully develop her thoughts.

I agree. The Forgotten Garden is nearly impossible to put down once you get started. I envy you because you have not read it yet! You have a real treat ahead of you.



Maria:
Soooooooo happy to hear you are reading this book. Haven't seen it mentioned too much in GR, but I loved it all the way through. There is so much historical "meat" to the novel.


The link for this one came up a different book. I think this is the correct link:




This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Little Bee (other topics)Canada (other topics)
Her Fearful Symmetry (other topics)
I Have America Surrounded: A Biography of Timothy Leary (other topics)
Inferno (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
William Shakespeare (other topics)Kevin Wilson (other topics)
Andrea Levy (other topics)
Lauren Carr (other topics)
Lauren Carr (other topics)
More...